14 ms·
Measuring "efficiency" in document prepration: Microsoft Word vs. LaTex
- transfire 6y agoI love the concept of Latex, but usability it pretty terrible. We really need a modernized approach. Something akin to HTML but specifically for printed documents.
- paijiut 6y agoPlease, no. I've written thousands of pages in LaTeX, and it's far more usable than most tools IF you can resist trying to overcomplicate things. For example, want a diagram? If you do it in xfig/inkscape/omnigraffle, you'll have little pain. If you decide to get clever and try to programmatically do it via tikz or some other package, you've opened up a world of pain. The level of pain experienced by LaTeX users in my experience is more often poor choices made by the users who create unnecessary complexity. Avoid that, and it's a pretty reasonable model to work in.
- supergarfield 6y agoSure, but it's probably possible to design something better too, that would let users do more complex things without dying. Maybe you don't need it for your usage, but this seems a bit like a Blub problem[1]. Keep the same core design of compiled source code files, but there are many things that don't make any sense. As just one example having to use the `\makeatletter` / `\makeatother` hack to change the visibility of macros seems completely insane to me when we have had languages with fine-grained visibility control for decades. This is one of the many things that make using many packages together needlessly hard. [1] http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html
- s17n 6y agoSure! But the same is true of Word, or CSS for that matter. Any layout system is going to run into this issue: since the space of possible layouts is so big, it's almost inevitable that users will decide they want something that isn't well supported by the system. If the system is sufficiently powerful, they will be able to achieve their desired layout, at the cost of wrecking usability / maintainability. MS word is also perfectly usable, as long as you don't try to do anything weird (as the example in the article illustrates!).
- magicalhippo 6y agoI love LaTeX for writing math-heavy documents, but as soon as it involves figures, images or pseudo-code it is quite horrible compared to Word. For me, the ideal solution would be something WordPerfect but with ability to type LaTeX equations. I want to be able to manipulate the "code" of the document but with a nice UI with real-time preview that helps me placing and formatting figures, text boxes for pseudo-code etc.
- alphachloride 6y agoThat's a big if. One has to learn how to not over-complicate. Exactly the reason why latex has usability issues in many cases.
- gumby 6y agoSeems like a step backwards. One of the great things about Latex (or raw tex) is that you can simply type it into a buffer. No need to mouse around to select text or anything like that. Hard to find anything really more usable than that. Back in 1984 I wrote a small WYSIWYG editor at PARC that outputted primitive LaTex. Fortunately LaTeX was quite early stage and that little project went nowhere. But one of the lessons was that semantic markup was much easier to do by just typing rather than trying to infer it context, while -driven changes meant people usually just changed font and size and erased the semantic anyway. This has been borne out by Word. Edit: added bit starting “But one of...” to explain my comment
- supergarfield 6y agoI think the grandparent is talking about a better WYGIWYG language, like HTML generally is. You can (and most people, at least on HN, probably do) edit HTML in a buffer. Edit: changed parent → grandparent
- tapia 6y agoWhat do you mean? Writing a document in html is not much different than doing it in LaTeX.
- supergarfield 6y agoYes, that's exactly what I mean, I was replying to > One of the great things about Latex (or raw tex) is that you can simply type it into a buffer. and pointing out it also applies to HTML.
- gumby 6y agoI clarified my comment.
- nl 6y ago> One of the great things about Latex (or raw tex) is that you can simply type it into a buffer. No need to mouse around to select text or anything like that. Hard to find anything really more usable than that. More usable for you perhaps, but certainly not for me.
- mmcdermott 6y agoLightweight text markup (Asciidoc or Pandoc) seem to be getting there.
- AngusH 6y agoPerhaps, although personally I prefer latex, because at its best it is somewhat self describing: \chapter{Animals} instead of == Animals or should that be: === Animals I think an xml or html like approach is better: <chapter>Animals</chapter> One of the big issue is modal states for structure or styling. I've often found trouble in latex because you are in some state that you didn't expect and somehow have to get out of. Nested XML would hopefully be more obvious about what your state is. Docbook probably got this right, but it was too verbose for most.
- misnome 6y ago\chapter, or should that be \section, or should that be \subsection, or \subsubsection etc, depending on which layout you are using. \part maybe?
- AngusH 6y agoGood point, https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/LaTeX/Document_Structure#Sectioning_commands https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/LaTeX/Document_Structure#Secti... wikibooks latex guide suggests \chapter is level 0, which gives "=" (1 equals sign), But then surely the h1 document title should be above that, which would be "=" (1), so a chapter is below at "==" (2)? \part apparently is -1 in latex, which would be seem to be odd. But document title isn't part of the latex sectioning hierarchy... Given that there is a document title, part and chapter, chapter could maybe "===" (3) or maybe "==" (2) if we're not using parts or we don't consider the document title. I think anyway? It's unfortunate that the creators of latex did not follow the HTML heading rules better. (despite latex pre-dating html of course) :-)
- mmcdermott 6y agoTrue, it is more self-describing and that has some real benefits. What I typically found was that I didn't like writing in LaTeX for the same reason I don't like writing in HTML -- the syntax occupies more space and so it gets more attention, which pulls me away from the thoughts I was actually trying to write.
- meemo 6y agoI keep my custom commands and styles in a separate tex file that I `\input` into the document file I am working on. The document file usually looks very clean with this method. It feels very much like HTML and CSS to me.
- SebastianKra 6y agoHTML is the answer. - Can be opened on every device - Content can be embedded in base64, so you only have to share one file - Dynamic layout, so it looks nice even on phones - Searchable, standardized XML structure - Great customizability through CSS and optionally JS - Can be written in markdown - Basic support for page breaks, if you really must print the document (IA Writer already has some HTML-Templates meant for printing.) The only downside I can think of, is that you can't lock the document to prevent edits. However, conventions are what keeps PDF alive. Until the academic world realizes that they can do better than Latex, we're stuck.
- chromanoid 6y agoI disagree. The answer is not found yet. Even when using semantic HTML elements it's too much of a styling language. We need a system that solves the overlapping markup problem and is fully semantic.
- adrian_b 6y agoI have seen here similar opinions about HTML vs. PDF in a few other threads. However, this is a matter of personal opinion and I am certain that nobody knows how many people prefer PDF and how many prefer HTML. I strongly prefer PDF for any non-ephemeral content that I might need to read twice or more times, so I hate anyone who forces me to read an HTML user manual or scientific paper, instead of providing PDF documents for them. Even if HTML can be opened on every device, it also looks different on every device and it looks bad on those that are different from the one used by the developer (unless the HTML pages have been carefully designed to look good on various devices, which seldom happens). Even on a small smartphone screen, I prefer a good PDF viewer with a good user interface that makes it easy to zoom & pan, instead of the feeble attempts of the Web browsers to reformat the text, which make very difficult the navigation through complex technical documents. "Print" support is horrible for HTML. Modern Web pages, which use a lot of JS, are almost always mutilated when you use the "Print" command in both Chrome and Firefox, even if they display the pages correctly outside the "Print" mode.
- zzless 6y agoTo make some counterpoints: - On any device as long as it runs a browser - You can write TeX documents as a single file with ease - Phones are not designed for reading, so dynamic layout or not, it will still be inferior to finely typeset document - With care so can be TeX; carelessly written HTML docs will be just as bad as anything else - CSS is a pretty poor layout tool; typographically speaking, CSS is very subpar to TeX's capabilities, using JS... well how much better is it than just using macros in TeX/LaTeX? - markdown is fine for simple stuff but for highly complicated documents involving lots of generated tables, lists, and mathematics it is almost like having no tool at all; - but many people DO like printed documents (I rarely can stand reading anything but basic technical stuff on screen, say language reference is fine but anything that requires thinking, has to be printed); TeX is not locked to pdf in any way (it is not even it's native format). HTML's support for formulas is primitive (the only decent tools available are ... based on TeX). Academic world is not entirely uniform either but while I do think LaTeX is not ideal (TeX is though), I simply shudder when I think about Word or any MS or Adobe products.
- 08-15 6y agoDocbook?
- glandium 6y ago+ XSL-FO. A blast from the past. Waw, FOP is even still maintained: "Apache™ FOP version 2.5 was released on 13 May 2020." https://xmlgraphics.apache.org/fop/status.html https://xmlgraphics.apache.org/fop/status.html
- 08-15 6y agoI'd have said Jadetex. I fondly remember the SGML toolchain; the XML stuff felt horrible in comparison.
- erichahn 6y agoI never use Microsoft Word / Open Office to produce documents. If it has to be quick and dirty I just go to overleaf and maybe look up a template. The documents always look nicer this way.
- jacques_chester 6y agoOverleaf is a godsend for working on LaTeX documents.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoOffice word processor designed for basic documents can't compete with academic/technical typesetting tool for academic/technical applications? I think Word is a pretty mediocre product and has some ludicrous limitations. But really - this is just as nonsensical from the other side. Word and LaTeX not comparable tools and they're not designed for the same job. Comparing them makes as much sense as comparing a bicycle with a skateboard.
- com2kid 6y ago> I think Word is a pretty mediocre product and has some ludicrous limitations. But really - this is just as nonsensical from the other side. I wrote a ~200 page (digital) textbook on 3d Modeling using Word. Word is incredibly customizable, I had hotkeys setup to do everything I wanted, figures and diagrams manages themselves rather well, and I was easily able to get into a state of flow using Word. Now it took several days to get Word that customized, but having seen what it can do, I will not call it mediocre. However hot Word tip of the century is, and has always been, put all images inside a text box, they'll behave the way you expect then, and behave bizarrely otherwise. Should be noted I wasn't doing any typesetting or any such thing, just writing the document, I understand that beyond just writing, LaTeX is a far superior tool.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoI've used MS Word over very many years and I'm happy to say that it is a far better product now than it ever was in terms of reliability and doing what it's supposed to do. I'd even call it... good. But that is now, and the number of times I've been burned in the past and watched other people being burned, and the distress it is caused those who just want to get their job done and the time wasted; those memories fade slowly.
- bdamm 6y agoThis. Word is decent until it becomes a crashing, byzantine reformatting mess. Then it becomes some kind of obscene torture device as bug states propagate with the documents and restarting only brings inescapable anxiety.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago>The boss needed item 3 inserted into a numbered list of hundreds of items. The intern used a mouse to select the original 3 on the screen, then typed 4, then selected the original 4, then typed 5, then scrolled down, then selected the original 5, then typed 6, and so on. Another intern sat watching the screen to make sure there were no mistakes. Microsoft Word has automatic numbering. Just to be sure, I opened Word, and entered a numbered list. When I inserted a new numbered item, it automatically renumbered the list. Also, converting from a numbered list to bullet points is as simple as selecting the list and clicking the bullets icon instead of the numbered list icon. This opening anecdote makes me think the author is completely unfamiliar with Word, and is strawmanning it.
- Sniffnoy 6y agoGiven that he's apparently relaying something that actually happened, Bernstein can't be strawmanning it. In fact he can't be strawmanning it at all, as Microsoft Word doesn't make arguments or claims. You appear to mean something more like "Bernstein is incorrectly portraying how Microsoft Word works." But as I said Bernstein presents this story as something that actually happened, not a hypothetical example, so I guess what you actually mean is "I suspect Bernstein is making up this story"? Regardless, Bernstein does in fact address this criticism in the note added yesterday. Yes, it has automatic list numbering, but in order to achieve the desired formatting, the users had, instead of altering the formatting appropriately, removed this automatic numbering, because Microsoft Word doesn't make these sorts of distinctions clear and explicit.
- s17n 6y ago> the users had, instead of altering the formatting appropriately, removed this automatic numbering, because Microsoft Word doesn't make these sorts of distinctions clear and explicit. You can get into much worse situations than this once you leave the "happy path" in LaTeX.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoIf the argument that people who use Word that don't really know how to use it can end up using it inefficient ways, then doesn't it even more apply to Latex. I could probably come up with an anecdote about someone who tried to use Latex but spent hours trying to figure out how to get the format they wanted and got frustrating trying to debug their scripts. If we want to compare tools, we should not compare expert users of one tool with novices of another tool.
- warbaker 6y agoOn the other hand, Word never has compiler errors.
- gus_massa 6y agoI guess you never wrote a long document in Word full of equations that become unreadable at 6am a few hours before the deadline. (IIRC the automatic backup was readable, and I recovered most of the work from there. But one of the equations was cursed, and I had to delete and rewrite it. (I probably had a handmade backup, just in case, but it was a few hours old.))
- sam_bristow 6y agousing microsoft word moves an image 1 mm to the left all text and images shift. 4 new pages appear. in the distance, sirens
- tomjen3 6y agoMy guess is that people struggle more with Image placement in LaTeX by a huge margin. It is typically because they have the wrong mental model of how image placement should work. Floats are floating for a reason.
- rualca 6y ago> My guess is that people struggle more with Image placement in LaTeX by a huge margin. You should guess again. With LaTeX the biggest problem with images is seeig them reflow in a place you wasn't expecting because you did not paid attention to what you actually did. With Word, you even have to fight it to not put images and their image captions on separate pages. More importantly, with LaTeX the worst you get with images is them looking nice and neat in some other part of the text, maybe at the end of a section or with a single paragraph between them. With Word it's on par for the course to get your whole doc screwed up just because the image reflowed to the next page.
- gamblor956 6y ago
- smnrchrds 6y agoHow does ConTeXt compare with LaTeX and Word? It has been around forever, but for some reason it is always absent from these sorts of discussions.
- moonchild 6y agoWhen compared with word, context is not readily distinguishable from latex. It's more or less a cleaned up version of the language with a slightly different philosophy behind its macros.
- minusf 6y agocontext from the start used the pdftex engine and lua was a first class citizen. havent used it in a while but it's quite different from latex, it's much closer to original tex. while latex needs plugins for many extra features from all kinds of sources, and these plugins sometimes fight between themselves, context is more like bsd or django: comes with batteries included and i found it a much nicer experience.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoThis is motivated reasoning taking to extremes. "LaTeX users being more satisfied than Microsoft Word users and (2) KN claiming that Microsoft Word is more efficient" There is no conflict in this statement, despite the author's claim. People who walk to work (for reasonable distances) will also tend to feel better, even though it took them longer. Efficiency and satisfaction are different things. One is subjective ("how do you feel?"), the other objective (amount of work done per time). You are free to assign any relative value you like to these objectives, neither one is objectively "more important" than the other in all cases. But entirely denying a measurable result while being offended by the idea that, maybe, the measurable satisfaction LaTeX gives you could also, theoretically, possibly, cloud your judgement, is silly. It's literally a textbook example of a cognitive bias! I suspect the root cause here may be how much the tech scene loves to pretend to be "objective" / "neutral" / "scientific". If people were to consider the idea that they are just bundles of emotions, like everyone else, and, most importantly that there's nothing wrong with that, it would vastly improve some parts of the discourse. You chose LaTeX because (a) you prefer to spend an hour with a keyboard to spending 30 min with a mouse, because (b) it's part of the identity you've chosen for yourself, because (c) it gives your work that cool Bell Labs vibe, because (d) your peers would judge you, because (e) your peers chose it for you, because (e) you didn't invest a month into learning it to abandon it, because (f) you built this really cool continuous integration pipeline from your lab to Nature, or because (g) you're the type of person that noticed I used (e) twice, and those people just tend towards LaTeX. Some of these are emotional reasons. That doesn't mean they are invalid! You don't need to rationalise them. Be irrational and proud of it–it's been cool among a majority of numbers for a long time.
- robertlagrant 6y agoI'm pretty sure most of the world considers themselves objective and neutral, with occasional emotions. It's not just the tech scene.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zzless 6y agoThe author does not say 'conflict', he uses 'contrast' instead which is perfectly justified. Your subtly offensive (a)-(g) list seems to imply that the reasons for this contrast are rooted solely in the emotions of those who use LaTeX. I am fine with that but I am not sure I would agree with your (a): for me it is more like 10 min with a keyboard vs 2 hrs with a mouse.
- sien 6y agoThe paper this is a review of is at : https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0115069 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... The Abstract : "The choice of an efficient document preparation system is an important decision for any academic researcher. To assist the research community, we report a software usability study in which 40 researchers across different disciplines prepared scholarly texts with either Microsoft Word or LaTeX. The probe texts included simple continuous text, text with tables and subheadings, and complex text with several mathematical equations. We show that LaTeX users were slower than Word users, wrote less text in the same amount of time, and produced more typesetting, orthographical, grammatical, and formatting errors. On most measures, expert LaTeX users performed even worse than novice Word users. LaTeX users, however, more often report enjoying using their respective software. We conclude that even experienced LaTeX users may suffer a loss in productivity when LaTeX is used, relative to other document preparation systems. Individuals, institutions, and journals should carefully consider the ramifications of this finding when choosing document preparation strategies, or requiring them of authors."
- oblio 6y agoI would argue that for at least some mainstream languages (Java, C#, probably C++) the same is true of Vim/Emacs users vs VS/IntelliJ.
- jxy 6y ago> formatting errors Really? The whole point of using LaTeX is that there would be style files and you never would need to take the time to format anything.
- ketzu 6y agoMy latex documents often have formatting errors: lines extending into the margin, not properly breaking up words on line breaks, text flowing into other text in two column layouts. It takes a significant amount of work to get rid of those for me and I usually do not fix all of them in the end, because some minor ones are more work than they are worth.
- gus_massa 6y agoI agree. I initially use \hfuzz=5pt so only the horrible overflows produce an error and later I reduce it to 1pt and then to .5pt because nobody will notice an error of .5pt.
- ketzu 6y agoFor my latest document I finally made the same decision, just so I can focus on the text instead of the errors! But I haven't thought about keeping it at .5pt, I will probably do that, thank you.
- anoncake 6y agoIf you want to stick to the default formatting. But defaults are inevitably wrong so you have to fight LaTeX.
- chromanoid 6y agoI am not sure if I can trust somebody on such a topic when they produce such a wall of text.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoI will note that I feel much more productive in LaTeX or more powerful editors. I think some of that, however, is due to the fact that my brain is contently busy on the cognitively fulfilling task to develop a regex to do this find-replace instead of frustratedly waiting on my slow motor cortex as it drives a mouse cursor across the screen. See also the studies in [1], previously discussed on HN. I do a lot of work in a myriad of vendor-provided software with various degrees of quality for industrial control systems. I'm always grateful when they (1) don't mess with OS-provided text entry commands like tab stops to move between fields, F2 to start editing, enter or shift-enter to accept, copy paste, etc. and (2) provide a plain-text import-export utility. Literally today, I was faced with the barely unusual requirement to add a total of 1200 logic elements among 5 sets of 20 very similar lines of ladder logic to a program , I was grateful for the ability to do those 5 basic rungs once, export that section of logic, and run some regexes to generate all 100 rungs instead of being stuck using the mouse and clicking the add contact icon, scrolling to select the tag in the list, clicking the add coil icon, and scrolling to its tag, ad nauseam. A task that would have taken hours instead took just a couple minutes! However, I have observed that I feel better about these productivity wins and worse about some pragmatic drudge work than an objective analysis from the clock actually supports. Instead of boasting about the 'big win' on HN, had I been forced to spend half a day entering that logic manually, I would probably have complained about the vendor's awful UI for weeks, denigrating their hardware at the next project's quote phase. Realistically, though, it wouldn't have taken that much effort to do it manually. Similarly, I have no doubt that when trying to do something 4 times, it's often faster to just do it manually all 4 times, rather than copy-paste, keyboard navigation, find-replace, and edit machinations to make that happen. [1]: https://danluu.com/keyboard-v-mouse/ https://danluu.com/keyboard-v-mouse/
- oblio 6y agoThis should probably be on the wall next to every engineer's desk: https://xkcd.com/1205/ https://xkcd.com/1205/
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoA detail-oriented engineer would want to amend the chart to note that you should be willing to spend 1.25 years on making a daily task shorter by 6 hours, or 8.5 months making a weekly task shorter by 1 day. Regardless, it should go right next to https://xkcd.com/1319/ https://xkcd.com/1319/, though that may be less helpful as a reference and instead induce an existential crisis...
- whereistimbo 6y agoI tried to build my thesis using LaTeX. The uni doesn't have LaTeX template available, so I have to create them from scratch. It was a ludicrous task, so I stopped doing it and used Word instead despite of all the quirks.
- cinntaile 6y agoIf the first time you come into contact with LaTeX is when doing your thesis then I can see why you stopped. Preferably you would have used LaTeX for writing project reports in other courses. If you don't have to enter equations all over your thesis then I would say LaTeX is a bit overkill, markdown probably would have worked as well or Word as you mentioned.
- glial 6y agoMine required a PDF submission that met very strict formatting guidelines, but they didn't have a LaTeX template available either. I asked the graduate student help desk if I could use one from a former student's GitHub repo, and they said "oh yeah, that's what everybody else uses..." This at a school with 10k+ grad students.
- tpxl 6y agoMy uni had a latex template that was made and updated by one of the professors and it was glorious. No fussing about with styles or anything, just writing the content.
- svat 6y agoFor anyone who thinks that the author here (D. J. Bernstein) is biased in favour of LaTeX, he has elsewhere written one of the most stinging criticisms I've seen: https://cr.yp.to/writing/visual.html https://cr.yp.to/writing/visual.html (LaTeX haters, enjoy!) The point of this blog post here (the OP) is just that the study by Knauff and Nejasmic is really awful, for the reasons it mentions: studies the wrong metric, etc. (Of course typing "see [41]" would be more efficient than typing "see \cite{multiplication-survey}" for instance.) Far from the authors' claim of a “highly realistic working conditions”. (Also this blog post is titled “part 1” so I imagine there will be future blog posts either on this specific topic, or on measuring the wrong metric, in general?) Edit: Some of the comments here seemed odd to me, until I noticed that this HN submission is titled “Measuring "efficiency" in document prepration [sic]: Microsoft Word vs. LaTex [sic]”, while the actual blog post is titled “Optimizing for the wrong metric, part 1: Microsoft Word” and has the subtitle “Review of "An Efficiency Comparison of Document Preparation Systems Used in Academic Research and Development" by Knauff and Nejasmic.” From the HN submission title, I can imagine that before clicking one may expect the link to contain a measurement or comparison, rather than a review of some paper. Titles of articles are already (in general) a poor indicator of their contents, but please don't editorialize titles to make them less representative!
- wahern 6y agoBernstein's post is more a criticism of Lamport's claim[1] that > Even using LaTeX, which does not make the final formatting very easy, I usually spend less than two minutes per page doing the final formatting to produce camera-ready output and less a criticism regarding the superiority of logical (i.e. semantic) document editing systems over visual (WYSIWYG) editors. Lamport even says[2] > I know of no purely logical system that is currently available. Systems like Scribe and LaTeX permit the user to describe the visual appearance as well as the logical structure of the document—for example, by inserting a command to add a quarter-inch vertical space. The need to provide the user with such commands is a symptom of the deficiencies of these systems. [1] Leslie Lamport, "Document Production: Visual or Logical?", page 6, https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/uploads/prod/2016/12/Document-Production.pdf https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/uploads/prod/2016/1... [2] supra, page 2
- 6y ago
- lambdatronics 6y ago>Have I done a scientific study proving that Microsoft Word is less efficient than LaTeX? No. Ok, thanks, bye.
- speedgoose 6y agoYes, the blog post is mostly a rant because a scientific study didn't get the results the author wanted to read. Conducting a new scientific study would have been more interesting.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoWill I be downvoted for writing the word "Libreoffice" here? Probably I guess.
- KMag 6y agoIf you are downvoted, it will probably be for chiming in for the purpose of complaining about downvoting instead of attempting to forward the conversation. There are plenty of constructive comments you could make containing the word "Libreoffice" that would be upvoted.
- pseingatl 6y agoLaTeX is a typesetting program, not a notepad. Word is a notepad with 30 years of feature creep. For math, best to stay in LaTeX because of the need to produce equations. For everything else: Markdown with a few additions (centering support, page break support) => html = pdf or Markdown => LaTeX
- mieses 6y agoIt is not infrequent that a numbered list needs to be ordered out of numeric sequence. For example: 4. 1. 3. 5. If the language does not support this case (Markdown) then it's useless.
- renewiltord 6y agoHaha, I think indeed that Markdown is useless to you. I think I prefer it that way, though. The lack of this feature is fine for me.
- anoncake 6y agoAnd under some circumstances, it doesn't recognize that your list entries belong together. If you quote parts of a list: ------ > 1. Bla bla Yes, bla > 2. Blubb bar No, foo bar. ------ Markdown turns the 2 into a 1.
- renewiltord 6y agoIs there a Markdown flavour that permits TeX equations smoothly?
- gts_77 6y agoHave you looked at org-mode?
- renewiltord 6y agoI'm somewhat wary of the learning curve.
- RMPR 6y agoActually you can use org-mode without that much of a learning curve (at least in its basic form). Just pick an Emacs distribution (doom, spacemacs, ...) which come with pretty handy defaults, create an org-file and that's it. I use org-mode myself and didn't take the time to "learn" Emacs. This Google talk[0] was pretty handy to get familiar with org. 0: youtube.com/watch?v=oJTwQvgfgMM
- ashton314 6y agoI bet if you write your TeX in Markdown and then run the whole thing through pandoc, you’ll get well-set math in your PDF. I’ve done this with org-mode.
- renewiltord 6y agoThanks, man. I haven't used Emacs ever (except for C-x C-c amirite?) but looks like this will work anyway. Thank you.
- vicedvin 6y agoIt is possible to use plain TeX when using pandoc inside markdown documents.
- 6y ago
- vicedvin 6y agoI have observed my wife writing her PhD in M$ word, and indeed when editing either pictures or references the whole pages would shift, requiring post editing all subsequent sections. When I was writing mine I used markdown with pandoc to compile to either LaTex or pdf. When we compared our processes we approached the ground that text rendering shall be done separately exactly for the reasons of editing, as well as reference handling. Unfortunately, when she started she wasn’t exposed to those methods, nor by university; and the steep learning curve did not allow to switch in time. Those addressed points will much likely make the experience of writing on scientific topics much more pleasurable and efficient.
- RMPR 6y ago> When I was writing mine I used markdown with pandoc to compile to either LaTex or pdf. I wrote my master thesis with this combo, but wrestling with images positions made me turn back to pure Latex.
- ithkuil 6y agoHow does a tool like scrivener compare?
- pseingatl 6y agoScrivener is much better than Word for large documents. You can export a Scrivener-flavored file from Markdown to LaTeX without a problem. For that matter, you can also export to Word and directly to pdf. There's an import feature in Scrivener to bring in Word files, I'm not sure how it deals with changes made by others with respect to the original exported file. Scrivener is a terrific first draft program. And for the guy who asked, it does an excellent job of exporting to epub.
- jorgenveisdal 6y agoJust finished and submitted a 295 page Ph.D. dissertation written in LaTex. The only real downside, as I see it, is that «normal» people are used to giving feedback in Word documents.
- ketzu 6y agoCongratulations on submitting your thesis! My personal gripes with latex (or downsides): * Positional only Arguments with flexible in between options (makes it really hard for me to remember things) * Long. Long. Long compile times. * Intermediate results can be stale and create errors that are not errors of the document at all. * Errors that require multiple compile passes to go away * Unlocateable errors (Dozens of box errors that are reported for the first or last document line) * Bad error messages and error location in general (also due to the command structure) * Multistage tools that need to run in certain order, be rerun and producing various errors if you do it wrong (especially bibliography related) * Basic programming tasks like loops or coutners feel unnecessarily complex. My problems with the programming and syntax side of latex might be attributed to me never getting the feeling of being familiar with the syntax (and not using the programmatic aspects much). Even though I write some documents in latex for 10 years now. I never got familiar with alternatives either (like MS Word), though, because I assume it would be as much work as learning latex in the beginning.
- knolan 6y agoMy biggest problem on Word (for the Mac at least) is the awful input latency. It’s really bad. I use TeXShop and it’s very responsive. And of course there’s the presentation of equations and high quality vector graphics, Word is very poor in that regard.
- tpoacher 6y agoI hate when apples are compared to oranges. Try editing a word document by editing the .docx file directly in an editor and come back to me. Then try a nice interface for LaTeX like overleaf and also come back to me. At the end of the day if you want to write a simple document, go to a word processor (I prefer Libreoffice, but Word is ok too if it's installed); if you want to write something more elaborate that you want to be in control of programmatically and have a template, go with LaTeX. The reverse can be done too, but typically it's unnecessary hours wasted for the wrong reasons.
- incrudible 6y ago"Those poor interns!" What are the non-obvious factors here? Did the thought that "surely, there must be a better way to do this!" really not cross the minds of these interns? Of course, Word has a feature for this exact purpose. Interns get paid by the hour. Work expands so as to consume the time available for its completion. Consider that after completing this task, there may be more work to do that is less pleasant, so stalling makes sense. Consider that this work, dull as it may seem, is actually somewhat enjoyable as a social activity.
- maweki 6y agoA cost measure that isn't talked about is effort in collaboration. My partner works in the social sciences and when they write a paper, they send each other word documents with annotations and everybody works on it for a few days. While our computer science group writes papers much more in parallel as everybody works in a section and we synchronize our progress via a git repository. I believe Microsoft's Sharepoint could do the same thing, but none of us has Windows and the university does not have a sharepoint license.
- errelin 6y agoJust wondering could Google docs be useful in your case? It’s free plan may already be sufficient for a small group/team
- maweki 6y agoIn my case, we have to submit LaTeX-sources to journals anyways. In my partner's case, their collaboration workflow heavily relies on annotations and comments. I don't know whether google Docs would work in that case.
- johnwalkr 6y agoGoogle docs works much better. Real-time collaboration is smooth. Somehow it’s much more performant than using word locally. You can add comments, assign tasks to others (also using comments and +<email address> To tag the assignee). You can also write suggested edits for someone else to approve. Annotations/references and figure numbering are there via plugins. Share point/teams real-time collaboration also works, although not as well, but it has a fatal flaw: it’s too easy to download and work locally, so most users will do this and break the real-time collaboration aspect, without even realizing this was a feature in the first place, falling back on passing around v2_final.docs files that have to be merged. In google docs, you can even use word docs natively now, though a few features are missing. You need a bit of discipline in the team to live with missing this or that tiny formatting detail, again to avoid breaking real-time collaboration.