7 ms·
There's a silent but relatively big user base of CentOS in HPC and scientific computing. ScientificLinux and CentOS rules all HPC clusters. Clusters are like e
by bayindirh 6y ago
There's a silent but relatively big user base of CentOS in HPC and scientific computing.
ScientificLinux and CentOS rules all HPC clusters. Clusters are like enterprise servers. Big, monolithic, rarely upgraded. They're upgraded in one big-fell swoop and left to run.
There'll be another clone of RHEL since HPC can't accept CentOS Stream as the alternative. The whole infra is too big to move to Debian too.
So with today's announcement, a new distro is born. Also Greg (CentOS' founder's) domain (HPCng) is very telling...
We'll see. We're in for a hell of a ride. If you excuse me, I need to dust-off my XCAT servers...
- chasil 6y agoOracle already has a clone that performs an in-place conversion of an installed CentOS 7 system. There is a page describing the conversion: https://linux.oracle.com/switch/centos/ https://linux.oracle.com/switch/centos/ They have a shell script to convert a CentOS install to Oracle Linux, so you can buy support if you want. The converter only works with versions 5, 6, and 7. It does not work with CentOS 8. It would be nice if that could get updated.
- IntelMiner 6y agoI don't think many people who want to use something stable like CentOS, but don't want to pay for a RHEL support contract would want to pay Oracle for RHEL-but-with-Oracle-sprinkles-on-top
- kbenson 6y agoNot to mention Oracle is not known to leave money on the table, and if they see they can start charging for Oracle Linux because there's no large well known free version, I wouldn't put it past them. Put another way, if you jump ship from CentOS because IBM caused Red Hat to change it into a funnel to pay them money, if you landed on Oracle, you might be setting yourself up to do it all over again fairly soon.
- blaser-waffle 6y ago> Not to mention Oracle is not known to leave money on the table You're underselling it: Oracle grab money in a way that I would describe as "aplomb ruthlessness". They've managed to fuck no less than 3 orgs I've worked for. If they ask you for a license count or how many cores are in use, ignore them. Larry Ellison doesn't need another boat.
- _-david-_ 6y agoOracle Linux is free with optional paid support. "Unlike many other commercial Linux distributions, Oracle Linux is easy to download and completely free to use, distribute, and update. Oracle Linux is available under the GNU General Public License (GPLv2). Support contracts are available from Oracle. " https://www.oracle.com/a/ocom/docs/027617.pdf https://www.oracle.com/a/ocom/docs/027617.pdf [PDF]
- davoneus 6y agonever, Ever, EVER trust Oracle. Especially with something as important as an open source product. Evidence: Oracle's Sen. VP Glueck statement that "There is no math that can justify open source from a cost perspective." No chance you'll ever see me running OEL.
- apecat 6y agoAre there any license traps in Oracle Linux? Writing like this makes me very wary of putting Oracle Linux anywhere near my employer's systems https://www.computerworld.com/article/2992597/law-firm-warns-of-oracles-licensing-traps.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2992597/law-firm-warns... https://blog.dbwatch.com/how-to-avoid-oracles-licensing-traps https://blog.dbwatch.com/how-to-avoid-oracles-licensing-trap... Then there's the famous lawn mover quote from Bryan Cantrill https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5170246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5170246
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoCan you imagine if they had successfully purchased TikTok?
- apecat 6y agomatch made not in heaven but on Oracle Cloud
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> never, Ever, EVER trust Oracle. Been burned by them before. Not at liberty to give details, but the outcome is that I never choose Oracle for anything for the rest of my career. Even if it would save time and money.
- bayindirh 6y agoIn our setup we don't need any add-ons that Oracle brings to the table. We also don't need their greed too. We only need RH equal of Debian, since the software we use generally have explicit CentOS/RHEL support.
- macspoofing 6y ago>0racle already has a clone that performs an in-place conversion of an installed CentOS 7 system. "Out of the frying pan into the fire"
- CydeWeys 6y agoThere are two types of people: People who haven't used Oracle yet, and people who will never use it again. And I'll forever hate them for what they did to Java (and in setting the precedent that APIs can be copyrighted).
- pjmlp 6y agoWhat have they done, lets see: - Brought MaximeVM of research and creating GraalVM - In the process of adding value types to Java - In the process of adding support for explicit SIMD in Java - In the process of adding co-routines to Java - Added type inference support - Added pattern matching - Added record types - Integrated J/Rockit support for JIT caches - Made Flight Recorder available in OpenJDK - In the process of making AOT compilation work, instead of requiring you to fork money for a JDK with AOT compiler like Sun used to do - Integrated almost pauseless GC with support for TB sized heaps - Long term roadmap to replace C++ with Java on the JDK, as yet another proof of Java capabilities - In the process of having a JNI replacement And plenty more, https://openjdk.java.net/jeps/0 https://openjdk.java.net/jeps/0 I hope they squash Android Java, Google had the opportunity to buy Sun after screwing them up.
- bzzzt 6y agoWhen your company software stack is turned inside-out by Oracle reps to look for unlicensed JVM's on penalty of really big fines (sorry, opportunities to buy more Oracle software) all those nice-to-have features don't seem to matter that much.
- pjmlp 6y agoJava is like C and C++, plenty of implementations to choose from, including the free beer OpenJDK. Anything else is just FUD.
- bayindirh 6y agoThey've done all of them because they think it'll allow them to earn more money with less effort on the long run, not because of the sheer love of computer science and research. Oracle creates cool tech in the legacy of Sun because it impresses the right people who can influence the decision makers. To recap: "Hey, Oracle's these new toys are capable and fun to use. We can do much more with them. Can you buy these for us, engineers so we can be happy like children again?"
- pnutjam 6y agoWe used SLES like that on our HPC. SLES and RH will run just fine without subscriptions if you don't plan to update them. The license for RH precludes you from running unlicensed RH, if you have any licensed RH. I don't believe SuSE does the same.
- mattdm 6y agoOkay, this is a serious question. For me, not an official RH position. In my time in HPC, nodes were baked with a specific image and then that basically never ever got updates. As I came to that as a sysadmin from other areas, I found that somewhat horrifying, but it seemed pretty universal. Have things changed such that applying patches regularly (like, more often than once a month or so except in emergencies) is a thing?
- bromonkey 6y agoNo, they haven't changed in my experience.
- cozzyd 6y agoThe login nodes on our cluster (UChicago) can reach uptimes over a hundred days (which my tmux sessions love). Seems like the kernel was last updated in May. $ uname -r -v 3.10.0-1127.8.2.el7.x86_64 #1 SMP Wed May 13 10:45:47 CDT
- shiftpgdn 6y agoI think that's because HPC users are largely non-technical developers. We changed a DHCP schema at one point and had a bunch of angry academics in the IT office because their Matlab scripts were broken. Many of them had been hard coding IP addresses into the code itself.
- bayindirh 6y agoNot much, but in our setup the image is not something which can evolve or change over time. This practice has some very practical reasons though. Scientific applications can be very picky about the libraries they use or need, down to minor version since the results they produce are very, very precise. Even if not very accurate, you need to know the inaccuracy. An optimization in a math library can change this and, it's not something we want. Also program verification and certification generally includes versions of the libraries used. Piecewise upgrades are a no go too. Your cluster generally can't work well in heterogeneous configurations (due to library mismatches) and draining a node is not a straightforward task (due to length of the jobs). If your cluster has a steady stream of incoming jobs, reducing resources also means queue bloat and recovering it is not easy sometimes. If you want to drain the whole cluster, it takes almost 2-3 weeks so, you lose ~1 month of productivity. When you start an empty cluster to churn its queues, its saturation takes time so, it doesn't go to 11 directly. Also, worker nodes are highly isolated from the user's point of view. No users can log-in, only known people submit jobs, etc. Unless there's a rogue academic trying to do nefarious things, the place is pretty safe and worry-free. In past 15 years, we got two rootkit infections due to a server which can be world-accessible by design. Other than that, nothing ever got infected. At the end of the day, this approach has some valid reasons to be alive. It's not that we're a bunch of lazy academics who refrain from applying good system administration practices. :D Addendum: The images generally get updated when new hardware is added, since new processors tend to work better with newer kernels. Also sometimes we bit the bullet and update all the cluster at once. XCAT helps a lot in this space. If your image is sane, you can install batches of 150+ servers in 15 minutes while sipping your coffee.
- kergonath 6y agoMy thoughts exactly. All our workstations and small-ish clusters run CentOS (we don’t maintain ourselves the large clusters so these are not our problem). It’s going to be a huge pain.
- pjmlp 6y agoI was at CERN when ScientificLinux was created, back then it was actually based in Red Hat, there was no CentOS.
- bayindirh 6y agoWe also used it a lot back in the grid days. :)