8 ms·
It remains interesting to me that space exploration yields so much excitement when we have an essentially unexplored alien world with alien creatures right here
by bmitc 6y ago
It remains interesting to me that space exploration yields so much excitement when we have an essentially unexplored alien world with alien creatures right here. I have little idea why reaching a dead, likely lifeless, planet is more exciting than the ocean. Additionally, better understanding the ocean would better prep us to be able to properly explore planets and moons.
- fxtentacle 6y agoIt might be as primitive as people naturally preferring to sit on a high place and looking down.
- rowanG077 6y agoCalling ocean creatures alien is wrong. They aren't alien. The interest in space travel is simple to me. We can possibly learn about real aliens. We can also ensure humanities survival even in the event that the Earth is completely gone. Studying the ocean is just mostly about learning some semi interesting biology and mostly boring geology.
- ncmncm 6y agoOther humans are aliens. It is all a matter of degree. Octopods are about as alien an intelligence as we have on Earth. It is easy to imagine less-alien outsider aliens "X is just mostly..." is a reliable way to begin a falsehood.
- hermitcrab 6y agoThey are alien in that they are adapted to a totally different environment to us. But not alien in that they are a branch off the same tree of life as we are. If you are interested in finding out more about octopus evolution and intelligence I recommend: " Other Minds: The Octopus and the Evolution of Intelligent Life" by Peter Godfrey-Smith. "My octopus teacher" on Netflix is also well worth a watch.
- jsperson 6y agoI concur - the thing is that Mars is often spoken of as a "lifeboat" for humanity. It will take an awful lot of hard and determined work for us to ever make Earth less hospitable than Mars. Similarly it will take centuries of hard and determined work to ever make Mars as good as the worst possible Earth. Short of a full on nuclear war (small, but nevertheless non-zero probability) we're better off improving what we've got. Note, I'm only addressing the "lifeboat" justification, I still think sending folks to Mars would be cool as hell.
- eckmLJE 6y agoAn awful lot of hard and determined work for humans to make Earth less hospitable; a brief moment of whimsy for a large asteroid
- thaumasiotes 6y agoNot really; a large asteroid is fundamentally incapable of making Earth less hospitable than Mars. For example, it would need to be so large that the impact blew away the entire atmosphere.
- CapitalistCartr 6y agoIt doesn't need to make it just like Mars, to be as inhospitable. An asteroid big enough to crater to the mantle, sending out massive waves of lava and darkening the sky for years would do. It might wipe out all humans on Earth. Of course, unlike Mars, Earth would recover. Not that humanity would care.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> It doesn't need to make it just like Mars, to be as inhospitable. An asteroid big enough to crater to the mantle, sending out massive waves of lava and darkening the sky for years would do. No, it wouldn't. That would make the Earth much less hospitable than it is now, but still much more hospitable than Mars. > It might wipe out all humans on Earth. This is not evidence of being less hospitable than Mars, since humans cannot survive on Mars. Even at the worst point of this disaster, human life would be easier on Earth than on Mars under normal Martian conditions.
- mindfulplay 6y agoIt makes no sense to colonize Mars or any other planet other than a pure show or an escapist mentality. Human beings as a species have shown the inability to even cohabit a 5 square mile space peacefully let alone colonize other worlds. Better to stay here and explore and study the wonders of nature. We have yet to even understand how a simple protein evolves to produce all this wonderful life and consciousness and brains....
- verroq 6y agoDon’t you realise the entire point of leaving is because we can’t cohabitat here?
- dwaltrip 6y agoIf we wait until life is perfect on Earth, then we will never leave. It is literally the entire universe out there that is waiting to be explored :)
- Razengan 6y agoThe Expanse is pretty fun look at how humans will manage to fuck shit up even after we have a 100 different worlds to live on.
- birdsbirdsbirds 6y agoYou don't even have to go to the ocean. We still don't know how humans work.
- rlonn 6y agoyeah, we should probably never research anything but our own noses, until we know exactly everything about them
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoThat's a hilarious description of my meditation practice.
- jonshariat 6y agoThe more I learn about the healthcare system through my wife (a nurse), the more I marvel at how much we don't know about our own bodies.
- Razengan 6y agoYou can study each other's bodies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- flyGuyOnTheSly 6y agoEvery time I go on vacation I visit a local brewery. There are over 10 massive breweries local to where I live, and I have never even considered visiting a single one of them. Same typically goes for the using/living near a beach and using/owning a pool.
- wait_a_minute 6y agoThe biggest problem with these types of issues is that they make it a false dichotomy. We don't need to decide between space exploration and ocean exploration. We can do both. Space exploration is a paltry fraction of a percentage of our total spending as a species. Not to mention that innovations derived from space exploration do end up in applications here on earth.
- bmitc 6y agoMy sentiment or lament is not a false dichotomy. I didn’t present it as only two options. It’s more that most act like there’s only one option. Of course we can do both, but we don’t. In fact, we are actively harming the ocean. > Not to mention that innovations derived from space exploration do end up in applications here on earth. That’s part of the bias towards space. Plenty of innovations derived from other large technological developments and projects end up in unanticipated applications. This effect is not unique to space technology development and is not necessarily a strong argument for its funding. A huge swath of modern technology comes from defense spending. Should we increase the defense budget? Again, my comment was more of a lament in the way treat and view the ocean.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoFalse dichotomy; but anyway, the deep sea is just about as inhospitable as Mars. Nobody living there long-term, not without a huge investment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Razengan 6y agoIt remains interesting to me that space exploration is always seen as an "either-or" for some people. "Why go to the moon when people are starving in Africa??" "Why go to Mars when there are weird creatures in the sea??" What the heck.
- cmdshiftf4 6y ago>I have little idea why reaching a dead, likely lifeless, planet is more exciting than the ocean. I agree with your sentiment but as best I understand, the race to get to Mars is i) to provide redundancy for the species should things turn further to shit here, by our own hand or not ii) we are in somewhat of a race against time to escape our own solar system before our sun burns out, and Mars is a milestone in that venture