6 ms·
Looks like anyone wanting to invade is in for a rough patch, but maybe modern tech renders these types of things worthless. Considering what a rough time the U
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
Looks like anyone wanting to invade is in for a rough patch, but maybe modern tech renders these types of things worthless.
Considering what a rough time the US (and Russia) has had in Afghanistan, I suspect they'd still be fairly effective.
- speeder 6y agoThis made me remember something about castles... I was wondering, how useful are ancient castles in modern battles? Armchair generals all over the planet kept prattling about them being useless because modern weaponry is awesome and all... Then I went to look properly: 1. Kerak de Chevaliers, yes, that one crusader castle, was occupied during the Syrian war, and gave a hard time to the enemy outside, the castle worked exactly as intended, even with modern weapons. 2. Ditto to a bunch of other castles in some past wars. 3. A fortified monastery gave enemies a hard time in WW2 in Italy, I forgot its name now. 4. Not exactly "ancient castle", but a "star fort" in France was captured in the opening days of Battle of Verdun, in part because the french leadership believed castles to be outdated and didn't garrisoned it properly... the result was that the attempts to retake the fort resulted in 100.000 casualties on the French side before they succeeded. 5. Also in Verdun there was a smaller fort, the commander of that fort was old and the military ordered him to retire for medical reasons, he refused and basically "kept" the fort as his own, with a small garrison, the old guy and his small garrison fought fiercely against the invading Germans and caused 3000 casualties to the Germans before they lost.
- samizdis 6y ago> 3. A fortified monastery gave enemies a hard time in WW2 in Italy, I forgot its name now. Monte Cassino? See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Monte_Cassino https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Monte_Cassino
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI'll tell you. This[0] is a hell of a photo. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Monte_Cassino#/media/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_101I-577-1917-08,_Monte_Cassino,_Fallschirmjäger_mit_Granatwerfer.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Monte_Cassino#/media...
- MeinBlutIstBlau 6y agoA castle gives you a hard time when you only have a gun. If the military has aircraft, missile launchers, and artillery, they'll be flattened before any fighting occurs. Plus it's a pretty easy target.
- hutzlibu 6y agoFrom Wikipedia about Monte Cassino "On 15 February American bombers dropped 1,400 tons of high explosives, creating widespread damage.[6] The raid failed to achieve its objective, as German paratroopers then occupied the rubble and established excellent defensive positions amid the ruins. "
- gonzo41 6y agoThose were unguided bombs. Modern artillery and mortars will just slowly wear down a static target like that. From a safe distance as well.
- hutzlibu 6y agoAnd that comes for free? It binds ressources. Lots of them. You even write "slowly". Meaning fortification is still effective. While the enemy artillery is busy bombing stone, your troops can attack other targets from from other angles.
- engineer_22 6y agoThat's right. But civilians believe the US air force is omnipotent.
- tosseuthansia 6y agoit was still 1400 tons of high explosive. Monte Cassino was reduced to rubble. The entire monastery was reduced to ruble and had to be rebuild from the ground up. Also, the US did have artillery at the time, which is bloody precise. It didn't matter, the Monte Cassino was a meat grinder for the Allies. Anyway, why dredge WWII era stuff? The US got spanked in Afghanistan by an irregular militia with bolt action rifles. And their tactic is simple as it is brilliant - negate the advantage of air raids by fighting as close to the enemy as possible.
- throw1234651234 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citadel_of_Aleppo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citadel_of_Aleppo This ancient fortification was the only thing the Syrian army held in the city for months, if not years. It functioned exactly as an ancient fortress did - providing high ground, spotting enemy movement, safety of supplies, etc. Another recent example is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Battle_of_Donetsk_Airport https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Battle_of_Donetsk_Airpo... This was NOT fortified, but allowed concealment, and was held through heavy bombardment, offering a tactical advantage. Yes, US/Russia/China could pound it into the ground, but that takes a LOT of ordinance. Btw, WW II is FULL of these examples. I think the misconception comes from the fact that "modern weapons" - jets, radars, comm sites, missiles, etc cant be "secured" in these facilities. This is true. But that doesn't mean they can't be held through heavy bombardment and house mortars, snipers, ATGMs, small supply caches, etc.
- nix23 6y ago>Considering what a rough time the US (and Russia) has had in Afghanistan, I suspect they'd still be fairly effective. That was the whole plan in WW2, take the army back to the mountains leave the city's and flatland to the enemy, then start Guerilla warfare and protect the big Mountain Fortresses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Redoubt_(Switzerland) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Redoubt_(Switzerland)
- iguy 6y agoAlso, viewed from the other side, the point of taking Switzerland would have been to have easier transport across the alps, Germany-Italy. But with all the bridges & tunnels blown up, this benefit would be lost. In other words, I think the Swiss wanted to tilt the cost/benefit calculation for invaders, not only by increasing the cost, but also by reducing the benefit. (Much the same game-plan seems not to have worked for Afghanistan, though. High cost, zero benefit, lots of invasions.)
- hutzlibu 6y ago"In other words, I think the Swiss wanted to tilt the cost/benefit calculation for invaders, not only by increasing the cost, but also by reducing the benefit. " And that worked, as for sure germany did not wanted a neutral power in the middle of their empire, but due to cost/benefit the plan of invading was always pushed back till the war was over. So this was also the plan for a potential cold war escalation.
- mhh__ 6y agoIf you want to defeat the Swiss, and keep in mind what kind of enemy would want to do that, just start carpet bombing where the actual people live. That and they only have about 25 aircraft that could realistically do any good air defense work. The idea that the US would struggle against Switzerland is predicated on them not doing that, because they would've had to found a reason to invade in the first place.
- bbojan 6y agoEach building in Switzerland has an underground air raid shelter. So you wouldn't be able to kill too many civilians this way. And once you've destroyed all their aircraft, their SAMs are free to shoot an any target that's flying. The idea is that the USA (or any other power) would struggle to occupy Switzerland, not to obliterate it from the face of the Earth. No country could defend against that, not even the USA.
- cookieswumchorr 6y agoi am afraid, these times are over with the advance of drone technology, look at the last Karabakh conflict. it's not just the US anymore, but lots of countries can use affordable drones an operate without much human or economic loss. Whereas the side practicing mountain guerrila tactics will have to abandon all civil economic activity, and still lose lives (you cannot stay in shelters all the time)
- cookieswumchorr 6y agoas if they had perfect reason for their previous invasions
- btbuildem 6y agoThey protect themselves from the US by being banker to a lot of their dirty money.
- rscho 6y agoDelaware...
- hutzlibu 6y agoEven though you can nuke (allmost) anything, fortified bunkers are still (the most) effective fortification. There is lots of massive stone protecting them after all, you have to blast through. Which can be done, but is still a massive effort. Unless you really know (and guard) all the exits and control the surface, how could modern tech render them useless? For primitive caves(targeting Taliban), I believe there was a weapon developed where shockwave (and gas?) would kill anyone inside, but if you have multiple blast doors and air filtration inside, you still have to cut or blast your way inside. And fighting in an enemy underground network is not something any soldier would look forward to. So I guess the modern way to take the swiss bunkers out, would be a) really scout them out b) target critical infrastructure (bunker breaking bombs) c) destroy all the exits or d) infiltration with commando troops or e) blow up the whole mountain
- 082349872349872 6y agoHäh? I think the modern way to take swiss bunkers out is to go around them: drive the Franc up to economy-killing levels, and tell the SNB they'll get cut out of the global financial system if they even attempt to defend reasonable exchange rates.
- engineer_22 6y agoYou can take my money but you can't take my homeland.