4 ms·
Regarding the PDF: Why does it seem so hard to get good looking justified text? It appears to me that only (La)TeX manages to get spacing 'correct' / aesthetic
by throw0101a 6y ago
Regarding the PDF:
Why does it seem so hard to get good looking justified text? It appears to me that only (La)TeX manages to get spacing 'correct' / aesthetically pleasing (IMHO). Going from the metadata, this file was generated by "Microsoft Office Word": you'd think MS would have the resources to figure this out.
- freeone3000 6y agoOkay. So what's good looking? This is inter-word spacing with emphasis to justification without hyphenation, last line excluded. This is the standard of justified text. We can't adjust hyphenation, because hyphenation rules are a quirk of not just language but pronunciation (the hyphen goes between syllables), so it's nearly impossible to find a universal ruleset. Let's mess with some of the other things. First: why have justified text? What if we just had a ragged right-hand column, not caring where that ended up? Let's just ignore that the user asked for justified text. Or take the completely opposite approach - what if we also distributed some of the spacing in between the letters? Which of these three looks best to you: https://imgur.com/a/THB6ifI https://imgur.com/a/THB6ifI
- aardvark179 6y agoTeX does do a good job, but it is not totally unique in this, and it’s not perfect because it doesn’t know enough about glyph shapes to avoid creating rivers. The thing that TeX, InDesign, and other systems that can do really good layout often allow is hints for ways to fix otherwise difficult cases (where it might be good to hyphenate or introduce a line break). Word is in a tricky middle ground where it is ostensibly concerned with the pure content of the document (where you shouldn’t be worrying about line justification issues) but is being used to produce final output where you would expect to be providing those fix ups.
- m_mueller 6y agoSince you seem to have an eye for this, what about Apple Pages? The output of that always seemed pleasing to me.
- alkonaut 6y agoNot sure it's theoretically possible. What you can do in an interactive WYSISYG editor like a word processor and what you can do with batch typesetting program are two different things. When you edit in a word processor, you have different expectations about the interaction speed, and the locality of changes. A typesetting program can spend two seconds optimizing word spacing when you "render" the document. Word can't. It could spend those 2 seconds when you hit print - but then it's no longer WYSIWYG! It could also apply "TeX-like" typesetting changes (jumbling the spacing around in the whole document on every keystroke) but that also breaks the user's expectation.