2 ms·
> Uh, you can absolutely be pollution neutral. You can be carbon neutral, and I don't buy for one microsecond that there are 0 technologies that could filter so
by rayiner 6y ago
> Uh, you can absolutely be pollution neutral. You can be carbon neutral, and I don't buy for one microsecond that there are 0 technologies that could filter soot from smokestacks. In fact, we could recapture all of it.
You said “pollution” should be banned. That includes a whole lot more than soot. And no, you can’t recapture “all” of the soot from a smokestack. Filtering particulates out of flue-gas stacks is a whole field of engineering. And that’s just one source. PM2.5 is produced by a huge variety of human activity: https://www.pca.state.mn.us/air/sources-air-pollution-most-impact-health https://www.pca.state.mn.us/air/sources-air-pollution-most-i.... The dominant source is actually residential wood burning.
> If you read about the history of pollution, you'll see that the "informed tradeoffs" is a complete fairy-tale. It's mostly ignorance and abuse of the poor by the wealthy (who put polluting factories in poor areas like West Virginia).
I focused on environmental policy in law school. It is absolutely about informed trade-offs, within an economic framework. Equity is one part of policy, but the field is not “mostly” about that. Of course that aspect of it gets a lot of press, because it makes for easy narratives for liberal arts major journalists who have trouble with science and economics.
- zug_zug 6y ago>> Of course that aspect of it gets a lot of press, because it makes for easy narratives for liberal arts major journalists who have trouble with science and economics. Wow, hah, that's mighty condescending and laughably misinformed. I think perhaps you're the one who should read a little more about the science. In short, the history of pollution is - people invent something with 0 thought given to side effects (e.g. smoking). Side effects turn out to be very bad. Company maliciously hides all evidence, and tries to manipulate data/researchers (usually fairly successfully). Only after decades and decades of fighting does the scientific consensus prove that yes, secondhand smoking, lead exhaust, air pollution, PFOAs, microplastics, hundreds of (now-revoked) pesticides, pthalates, etc was even worse than everybody thought, and the policies are adjusted after massive suffering. That's why your fairy-tale about legal tradeoffs crumbles under the gentlest scrutiny. Because these policies around air-pollution predate any meaningful research on the health effects of this pollution. Just off the top of my head, here's an article from last year of PM2.5 as a potential cause of depression [1]. Nobody knows yet how many more indirect and damaging effects from various types of pollution are yet to be discovered (from PM2.5 or otherwise). 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6447209/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6447209/