6 ms·
It's an oddity of US politics that this is perceived as a left or right issue at all, in that one 'side' seems to have adopted the stance that police should be
by rsynnott 6y ago
It's an oddity of US politics that this is perceived as a left or right issue at all, in that one 'side' seems to have adopted the stance that police should be allowed do pretty much anything with no repercussions or meaningful oversight. Outside the lunatic far-right, this sort of thing would be condemned from all sides in many developed democracies.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoExactly. I can recall when the right was all upset about Ruby Ridge and Waco. Now that it's people they perceive to be their enemies being punished they're cool with it.
- notmarkus 6y agoWho on the "right" is cool with this? Genuinely asking.
- ojnabieoot 6y agoThe police (and their unions, and civilian voters with authoritarian pro-police ideologies) are a major political constituency on the right, one that Donald Trump had repeatedly pandered to (because he is a pro-police authoritarian). It is beyond naive to pretend “unaccountable police violence is good” isn’t a mainstream right-wing belief in 2020. > When you see these thugs being thrown into the back of a paddy wagon, you just seen them thrown in, rough. I said, ‘Please don’t be too nice.’ [Trump, July 2017] > If you see somebody getting ready to throw a tomato, knock the crap out of them, would you?Seriously, OK? Just knock the hell — I promise you, I will pay for the legal fees. I promise. I promise. They won’t be so much, because the courts agree with us too — what’s going on in this country? [Trump, July 2016] > “Sometimes they grab one guy, ‘I’m a reporter! I’m a reporter!” ...they threw him aside like he was a little bag of popcorn.” [Trump, September 2020, clearly mocking the reporter in context] So the people on the “right” who are cool with this are basically every Republican official and about 70m Americans who voted for Trump last month. Seems like a lot of people!
- Pfhreak 6y agoSurprised to see your downvotes. The police were literally started in the late 1800s to protect capital and share the responsibility of cost across all people. (In the South, they were tightly related to patrolling for slaves, in the north they were predominantly helping wealthy merchants protect warehouses and other stores of wealth.) In the decades since, the police (and their unions) have had a long, long history of right wing action. The Portland Police Bureau (PPB) is known for their 'Red Squad', which was used in the 1900s to bust up unions, leftists, and people suspected of being communists. They regularly welcomed literal Nazis into their ranks in the 30s and 40s. The stories aren't unique to Portland either. A common piece of police iconography is a Punisher skull. Police with SS tattoos are not uncommon.
- manfredo 6y agoLaw enforcement had existed for millennia, not the last two centuries. Greek polis had nyctostrategoi (literally, "night officers") that patrolled and enforced laws as early as 500 BC. And Mesopotamian city states probably had police, too. Do people really believe that professional law enforcement didn't exist until 1800 AD?
- heavyset_go 6y ago> The police were literally started in the late 1800s to protect capital and share the responsibility of cost across all people. (In the South, they were tightly related to patrolling for slaves, in the north they were predominantly helping wealthy merchants protect warehouses and other stores of wealth.) This is a correct reading of the history of policing in America[1]. [1] https://time.com/4779112/police-history-origins/ https://time.com/4779112/police-history-origins/
- manfredo 6y agoPolicing in America dates back well beyond the 1800s (let alone the late 1800s), and has it's roots in the medieval system of sheriffs and their deputies. Organized police in the US date back to the early 1600s at the latest. In fact police existed in New York back when it was called New Amsterdam: https://www.britannica.com/topic/police/Early-police-in-the-United-States https://www.britannica.com/topic/police/Early-police-in-the-... I'm serious baffled as to how people got the idea that police were created in the 1800s. Do people really believe that cities like Boston and New York existed for centuries with nobody to enforce laws?
- tshaddox 6y agoThe President referred to police brutality against journalists as a “beautiful sight.” https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-revels-in-beautiful-sight-of-law-enforcement-grabbing-journalist/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-revels-in-beautiful-sight... There are plenty of prominent Republicans explicitly supporting Kyle Rittenhouse (not a cop, but a similar event.) There are, of course, vastly more examples of explicit support for police brutality and other lawbreaking in opposition to protests.
- notmarkus 6y agoOh true, I thought the parent comment was talking about this DOH event specifically.
- 0x445442 6y agoUsed to be that way in the US too.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> It's an oddity of US politics that this is perceived as a left or right issue at all, There are several major issues like that in US politics. Why is climate change a left or right issue? Why is wearing masks a left or right issue?
- sangnoir 6y ago> Why is climate change a left or right issue? Because businesses don't want to pay/lose money on climate change action, and the "party of small businesses" endorses this view. > Why is wearing masks a left or right issue? Because the virus was seen as a political/messaging problem (rather than a public health issue) by one of the sides, therefore wearing masks was viewed as capitulation.
- dboreham 6y agoBecause some sizable proportion of humans will believe any crap they're told, provided the message is couched in terms of something they're afraid of, and the right has decided to cater to those people leaving the left with the people who like to think about things for themselves.
- lawnchair_larry 6y ago> leaving the left with the people who like to think about things for themselves. You really broadcast your ignorance and your failure to understand others positions with comments like that.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI don't believe this is a good argument. The same argument has been done endlessly for the other side. There are definitely people who believe the party line on everything. If that's the case, that could be an indication you're not thinking for yourself.
- godelski 6y agoFor what it is worth, this isn't only a problem in the US. It is just that the US only knows what's up in the US and the US news is seen by most other western countries. There's also an argument to be made that US news highlights the worst people and not the average person.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> It's an oddity of US politics that this is perceived as a left or right issue at all, in that one 'side' seems to have adopted the stance that police should be allowed do pretty much anything with no repercussions or meaningful oversight. This strikes me as the kind of characterization of other peoples' beliefs that they would find to be false, misleading, and uncharitable.
- equality_1138 6y ago>It's an oddity of US politics that this is perceived as a left or right issue at all Not that odd. One side believes in decentralized power which tends toward police doing "pretty much anything" according to their read of the situation, and another side favors reams of paperwork and regulations that may hinder effective policing. The oddity in the US is how the media convinces people to pick one side and criticize the other absolutely, rather than commit to compromise.