9 ms·
I'm always amazed at how often cops approach every day tasks with weapons drawn. Reading the article (and being aware of the ongoing story) there's no indicatio
by godelski 6y ago
I'm always amazed at how often cops approach every day tasks with weapons drawn. Reading the article (and being aware of the ongoing story) there's no indication (to me) that there would be any hostility facing the officers. Thus it is easy to draw a conclusion of threat escalation from the police towards a citizen (if this is the wrong conclusion to draw then the police need to do a lot more work to justify their actions and explain why they thought there was a threat, because right now no one should buy that). This is unacceptable gun behavior in any environment and goes against conventional training (I'm sure there are gun users here or people who at least shot in the boy scouts or something). I mean officer #2 even appears to have his finger on the trigger (officer #1 doesn't). There's a rule "never point a weapon at something you do not intend to destroy." Pointing a weapon at a person indicates they are willing to destroy (kill) that person. This is unacceptable in non-violent cases where there is not an equal force against them. I just can't imagine the training they get. It makes me feel like Surviving Edged Weapons[0] is, at least in spirit, used. [1]
I've seen a lot of people with bad trigger control and not knowing proper gun safety, but I've seen it far too often from police. The acceptable level of this for police is zero and it isn't even close to that.
[0] This is a cult classic for "Bad" movies: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4ZpyKSmgdE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4ZpyKSmgdE
[1] From what I've seen, it does still seem like they do similar training that is highly fear based. As in "you could die at any second. It is you or them" and does not reflect the reality that being a cop is relatively safe. At least that narrative is not in the public domain. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-06-23/how-dangerous-is-police-work https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2020-06-23/how-da...
- Benjammer 6y agoMost police academies subject trainees to hours of video footage of cops getting ambushed by people with guns, and drill into them that any situation can turn deadly in an instant. They are hard-wired to think that they can lose their life in any second in any interaction with any citizen no matter what the circumstances.
- StillBored 6y agoRight, and that is why the "more training" argument I've heard some use as an alternative to the "de-fund the police" doesn't hold water. My own experience working near a lot of police early in my career led me to believe that the majority of the training instills a "us vs them" attitude in the police, and it carries through to everything they do. Combined with the constant bombardment of stories about the tiny percentage of cases where someone is actually violent and the results are predictable. Frankly, i'm of the opinion that the vast majority of cops shouldn't be carrying lethal weapons into the average traffic stop or whatever other activity is basically 100% safe outside of infinitesimal number of cases which go violent. After all, by pulling over, the person has basically already yielded to their authority.
- GVIrish 6y agoI think that's an argument for better training or a complete rethinking of training. More of the wrong training will just result in bad behavior getting more entrenched. Related to that point, defunding may actually have the opposite of the intended effect. You may actually have to spend more money to increase accountability, change culture, and improve the quality of policing.
- StillBored 6y agoYes, you can probably rework it, but as another comment noted its entrenched culture at this point. So, even if a cadet gets out of training with good habits/attitudes those can change very quickly when they start working with the more experienced officers. I'm sure it can be done, but it will likely take a zero tolerance level of push-back like has happened with sexual harassment in the corporate world to solve the problem. And I don't for a moment consider most police forces to be underfunded. The lions share of most city budgets are the police force, and it goes to buying armored cars and helicopters, and "benchmark city" ratios of police/citizens. And where I live the armored car gets used once or twice a decade, and in all cases so far could have probably just called the larger city an hour away and borrowed theirs as was done 15 years ago before the purchase. Some how we survived for a century with far less police, and outside of the crime wave of the 1970/80's which were likely caused in large part by other things, were generally safer too. That "crime wave" seems like it would have solved itself without the huge ramp up of police funding we now have today, although the tough on crime people like to attribute it to that. A large part goes to fighting the failed drug wars. Which in turn feeds into the massive prison populations we have now, the largest part of which are there for non violent crimes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- senectus1 6y agoWhen you give a cop a hammer and only a hammer they will view every problem as a nail. This is what Defund the Police is about. Its not about getting rid of cops, its about providing the right resources and tools and staff for the type of job they have.
- bitwize 6y agoAgain, "defund the police" is a motte and bailey argument: its activists will claim it's all about reform, but once they have your attention and know they won't be substantively debated, watch that word "defund" turn quickly to "abolish". And no solutions will be forthcoming about how to deal with criminals.
- giantg2 6y agoFunny enough, training is expensive and most of the issues are from a lack of training. I think removing funding will only make things worse.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoIt's not necessarily a 'lack of training' so much as 'money spent on irrelevant training instead of what they need'. Either police departments can agree that not all members of the police need to carry guns and be trained to shoot, and redirect training funds from weapons to de-escalation and assistance - or we must move the funding away from the police department to a different department that will do so.
- giantg2 6y ago"...or we must move the funding away from the police department to a different department that will do so." And then you still have armed police without training.
- rsynnott 6y agoThere seems to be a weird attitude in the US that the police are some sort of independent entity, and the most the state can do is reduce its tribute to them. This is a really odd approach, and doesn’t really have a parallel elsewhere; successful police reform had generally involved changes of leadership, independent misconduct commissions, and increased consequences.
- implying 6y agoI'd imagine that in this case, as in many others, it is purely punitive. The state just likes reminding 'troublemakers' of its monopoly on violence.
- godelski 6y agoIf this is the case (I'm not saying it is or isn't), then that is more akin to gestapo tactics and should not be even remotely acceptable by anyone in society. More so those on the right who often draw analogies to the Soviet Union.
- slg 6y agoIf you are surprised by these tactics, there are hours and hours of video you should watch from peaceful protests that have occurred over the last 6 months.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoFiery but peaceful protests, right? Or, the correct, non-orwellian term: violent riots.
- godelski 6y agoSurprised? No. Trying to not make a left or right comment? Yes.
- slg 6y agoFair enough. I would have liked if the state shouldn't use violence punitively was just an American stance rather than a left or right one.
- frabbit 6y agoHonestly this seems like a bonkers denial of reality: the State is exactly the embodiment of the use and monopoly of violence. Pretending otherwise is ignoring hundreds of years of empirical data.
- BurningFrog 6y agoGun ownership is very common in this country, and anyone on the other side of any door can have one. So I can get that part. Pointing a gun, loaded or not, at someone else should be a serious crime though! And there probably is, but cops can safely break most laws.
- m463 6y agoFlorida makes it very easy to own and conceal a handgun. I guess that leads to both politeness, and caution.
- psychometry 6y agoHa! It leads to verbal confrontations escalating to murders instead of fistfights.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- spacedcowboy 6y agoThat's not the real relationship tree. Mass gun ownership leads to fear. Fear may lead to politeness and caution, but only because of the fear. It may also lead to a 'fight or flight' type response, and things might escalate quickly beyond where anyone wanted them to be... If you want to structure society around fear, that is (I guess) a country's prerogative, but it's not something I (as a non-American) would ever support.
- virmundi 6y agoYou have made some lovely statements. You have nothing to back them. They will play well here. This coming from a person who lives in Florida and has a carry conceal permit.
- dboreham 6y agoThis hasn't been my experience fwiw as someone who moved from a non-gun country to the US. To be honest where I live (Montana) guns really aren't a problem. At least not the kind of problem that makes it a win to require Democrat candidates to support additional gun control measures. I think it's not unrealistic to imagine that we could completely dispense with the crazy Republicans if only democrats would drop gun control, it's such a wedge issue. Imagine that: Trump would never have happened, in exchange for not pursuing gun laws that probably wouldn't have achieved anything.
- mschuster91 6y ago> I'm always amazed at how often cops approach every day tasks with weapons drawn. That is IMO a side-effect of the (from an European POV) absolutely mind-boggling, ridiculous sentencing of criminals in the US. Here in Germany, when a drug smuggler gets caught, they can expect four, five years behind bars. Not worth to shoot the cop that just stopped your car full with meth and make a life sentence out of it for murder. In the US however? Decades, sometimes centuries behind bars. Given that perspective, it does make sense for a criminal to shoot that traffic cop - the chance to get away and escape a death in prison is non-zero. Add to that the fact that there are more guns than people in the US, plus extremely lax carrying laws, and "stand your ground" laws. The result are (rightfully, I have to admit) afraid and thus extremely trigger-happy cops. If the US wants to get rid of trigger-happy cops they have to get the gun problem and sentencing under control first.
- linuxhiker 6y agoYes, and we voted Biden in as President. (No I didn't vote for Trump)
- fountainofage 6y agoEh, don't side with cops. They have no legal obligation to do anything. They know this. So they pick their battles where they know they can kill a few people and get away with it. When it comes to actually having a chance at saving lives, they run away and hide, and get rewarded for it. See the recent-ish school shooting in Florida where the on-duty cop ran away like a baby and let children die. Brian Miller. Still has his job. No one gives a shit. Cops in the US are cowards who don't deserve to arm with a super soaker.
- ajkdhcb2 6y agoThose cops are choosing to be the enforcers of the laws/sentences which you are suggesting are unjust.
- nmfisher 6y ago> In the US however? Decades, sometimes centuries behind bars. Given that perspective, it does make sense for a criminal to shoot that traffic cop - the chance to get away and escape a death in prison is non-zero. Three-strikes sentencing can also exacerbate this - escalating minor drug possession to potentially life-ending prison sentence.
- taurath 6y agoHalf of what police are trained to do is violence-based. And we need people like that, for violent situations. But we don’t need that for a /TON/ of basic situations. We have armed warriors giving speeding tickets and expecting them to not be warriors. Where are the administrators who aren’t the warriors?
- imglorp 6y agoIn that vein, there's actually an experiment in progress where cops are not always dispatched but instead a paramedic and social worker are sent. Turns out they can resolve many issues. https://www.denverpost.com/2020/09/06/denver-star-program-mental-health-police/ https://www.denverpost.com/2020/09/06/denver-star-program-me...
- mxcrossb 6y ago> "Ms. Jones refused to come to the door for 20 minutes and hung-up on agents. After several attempts and verbal notifications that law enforcement officers were there to serve a legal search warrant, Ms. Jones eventually came to the door and allowed agents to enter," Plessinger said. "Ms. Jones' family was upstairs when agents made entry into the home." It’s weird too, because on one hand you have them being patient and restrained, on the other they decide to pull their guns out.
- giantg2 6y agoPerhaps they viewed her uncooperative nature as the residents preparing for conflict. It's possible they wouldn't have drawn their weapons if the residents complied immediately.
- Kye 6y agoIt's possible they wouldn't have been so hesitant to open the door if cops didn't have a reputation for shooting people with no consequence. The people with actual power in this situation have the greater responsibility.
- godelski 6y ago> The people with actual power in this situation have the greater responsibility. This cannot be stated enough. It seems in our general conversations that whenever there is a tribal component to the discussion that this responsibility shifts when it aligns or disaligns with your tribe. I've always been a firm believer that you can complain about those in other tribes, but it is your responsibility to hold those in your tribe to a higher bar. After all, you don't have a voice in the tribe you don't belong to and your tribe isn't perfect and can always seek to improve. And there should never be a question about a person in a position of power being held to a higher responsibility than an average person. No one should be getting a pass on this, inside or outside of your tribe.
- giantg2 6y agoThat's not really logical. If you think you'll get shot for no reason, then surely you would think that your chances of getting shot will go up with non-compliance.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoI'm not amazed, because police are put in completely unknown situations with people they've never met, and know absolutely nothing about. People's public personas really aren't a guarantee that they'll act a certain way on their property, especially when they are not doing something voluntarily. Combine that with the fact being that gun ownership is a Constitutional right--that means the chance that anyone can have a gun is above 0. And various attributes of anyone that might determine whether or not someone is about to retaliate are extremely unknowable without long observation times. There's no possible way to quickly ascertain someone's proclivity to violence, agitation level, emotional state, number of guns they really have on hand, willingness to use them, etc. People will act differently outside of a public setting like work, on a TV show, etc. So as long as guns are as easily available as they are currently, it's not unreasonable to expect a law officer to start the interaction in this way which is a manner that protects the officer the most.
- thinkloop 6y ago> a manner that protects the officer the most I doubt this is true. To me it is clear that their demeanor and behavior increases the liklihood of escalation and an incident.
- maxerickson 6y agoThe chance that anyone can have a gun is above 0 everywhere, it's a meaningless statement. Sure, the chances are higher in the US than just about everywhere else, so why not just say that. It's totally unreasonable for the officers to act this way, and I don't think it's particularly obvious that escalating to guns drawn makes them any safer. Maybe it does, but maybe it turns them into a threat in the minds of the people they think they are protecting themselves from.
- godelski 6y ago> So as long as guns are as easily available as they are currently, it's not unreasonable to expect a law officer to start the interaction in this way which is a manner that protects the officer the most. I don't think it is as simple as this. While one should train for the worst possible scenarios one also has to be aware what to reasonably expect. Like the source in my original comment notes, being a police officer is relatively safe. Given those statistics an officer should not view every situation as deadly. Though it is fine for them to be on high alert. It is still something that is often drilled into people during gun training that you should not point a weapon at something you do not intend to destroy. That is rule #1. Officers need to understand that by erring on the side of weapons drawn is equivalent to escalating any given interaction. Is that the mode of failure we want to have in police?
- jameslk 6y ago> I'm always amazed at how often cops approach every day tasks with weapons drawn. Reading the article (and being aware of the ongoing story) there's no indication (to me) that there would be any hostility facing the officers. Invading someone's home isn't an every day task. Most people don't like that. And since this in the US where potentially anyone could easily have a gun, some will take the opportunity remove the invaders of their house by force, especially if they aren't aware or sure it's the police. [0] But anyway, I'm not sure why police should even be the focus of this thread. They're just doing their job. The bigger issue I see here is the police have been called to take care of an issue that shouldn't require police. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Castle_doctrine EDIT: I'll just add since I'm getting downvoted to oblivion for saying something that could slightly be viewed as remotely favorable to police: It's sad to see this topic hijacked from the focus on Rebekah Jones, where there's an actual interesting story here about her work being potentially surpressed, to some unrelated topic about how much force police should use. Something that has been talked about ad nauseam across HN already, and yet this (at this time) is the most upvoted comment.
- giantg2 6y agoMany warrants are served everyday. I would say it's an common task from a LEO perspective, but not from a citizen's perspective.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asdff 6y agoPolice have to announce their presence. You would think also just from common sense and context that this was something that could have been done with one officer politely knocking on the door, knowing there is a zero percent chance that there would be someone hold up with a gun trained on the other side of the door in this instance. I mean it's not like this data scientist was some drug lord or arms dealer with a history of resorting to violence. The guns were for theatrics and nothing more.
- Cyph0n 6y agoInvading someone’s home with an assault team is unnecessarily aggressive. Police in the US are armed to the teeth, so it’s no wonder they overcompensate with aggression. Of course, if they received a tip or confirmed that someone in the building is armed and dangerous, then that’s a different story. But simply going in with guns drawn in every single situation is simply unacceptable.
- keithnz 6y agowhen you insist as a population to the right to have guns, then you have to be prepared that people need to treat you as if you have a weapon and, at times, will make mistakes. It's one of those weird rights that people want so they can "defend" themselves, but actually makes society as a whole a lot more dangerous.
- HungryRobotics 6y agoThe training is a huge one. Patriot act on Netflix (clearly 100% unbiased and best news source ever) even talked about exactly that. His joke was to the effect; imagine airplane pilots spending 90% of training learning how to use the ejection seat and a couple hours learning to fly
- fortran77 6y agoFor a person like this, can't they direct her to step outside where they can pat her down and then do the search? Without their guns drawn?
- fountainofage 6y agoBut the chance of getting away with killing a few people becomes non-existent if you actually try to do something sane.
- an_opabinia 6y agoI sort of don't want a comment like this, that isn't relevant, at the top. Like you can briefly say you empathize with her position and that obviously the police are misbehaving. But what we all really want is the Republicans to pay for suppressing data, because obviously Florida is in much worse shape than anyone wants to admit, it couldn't be any other way, so whose head will roll for the inevitable cover-up, and if not, why was such a cover-up lawful?
- p5a0u9l 6y agoI agree. And the responses so far indicate either cynicism or justification. Neither is useful imho. Police _are_ overly militarized and overly aggressive. We should be able to have a conversation in a healthy democracy about appropriate rules of engagement and escalation. Personally, I think it can be traced directly to the failed war on drugs. and indirectly, to the wars on terror creating both an excuse and a market for police weaponization.
- thepasswordis 6y agoThe police went through the house with their weapons drawn because they had a search warrant that was being ignored. They spent almost half of an hour politely requesting that these people allow them to carry it out, and these people refused to comply with what amounts to a legal court order. A functioning state requires that the state has a monopoly on violence. If you are ordered to allow the police to seize some of your property, and you refuse, force will be escalated within the limits of the law until you the property is taken. That is a good thing. If the police show up at your house with a warrant, COMPLY WITH THEM. You aren't going to win a physical battle against them because, again, they have an ultimate monopoly on violence and the only way to change that is going to be the creation of a new state.
- kyleblarson 6y agoGive a bunch of high school bullies a few hours of training and all the 'tacticool' gear they want (vests, drop leg holsters, armored vehicles, ar's etc) and it's hard to imagine any other result. Poor muzzle discipline, innocents (and dogs) killed, the list goes on.
- btilly 6y agoI mean officer #2 even appears to have his finger on the trigger (officer #1 doesn't). There's a rule "never point a weapon at something you do not intend to destroy." That's horrible. And should be grounds for firing the cop. I'm not sure how many on HN have shot a gun. But if you've got a qualified instructor, before you are even allowed to TOUCH the gun, you need to memorize the 4 basic rules of gun safety. 1. Every gun is always loaded. 2. Never point a gun at anything you're not willing to destroy. 3. Keep your finger off the trigger until you're ready to fire. 4. Be sure of your target and what's behind it. The second cop failed the last 3 rules. Was he willing to destroy the children? Was he ready to shoot when he put his finger on the trigger? Was he sure of his target and what's behind it? Given that the answer is no, he shouldn't be allowed to handle that gun. He's a danger to the public, and a liability to the police department.
- rascul 6y agoIn my opinion, police should be held to the highest standard. It seems like they're held to the lowest.
- heavyset_go 6y agoPolice are often the highest paid employees on a government's payroll. They get to retire with a full pension after only 20 years of working, and they often make as much as, or more than, software engineers do. The strong-arm of the state needs to be held to a high standard.
- btilly 6y agoOn the flip side, I had a friend who was a homicide cop in NYC. By the time he retired, he was broken by the things he'd seen and dealt with that nobody should ever see or deal with. He got a nice pension, but he earned it.
- seunosewa 6y agoWhat kind of things did he see? Can you give the two worst examples?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- discordance 6y ago* American cops
- sneak 6y ago> I'm always amazed at how often cops approach every day tasks with weapons drawn. Reading the article (and being aware of the ongoing story) there's no indication (to me) that there would be any hostility facing the officers. It's less amazing when you start to realize that police are cowardly and most are dumb enough to think that having a gun out will protect them. It's currently a side life goal of mine to get the IANA to assign me acab::/16.
- jariel 6y ago"that there would be any hostility facing the officers" From [1]: "Plessinger said Jones refused to answer the door for 20 minutes and hung up on agents. Jones eventually let the agents into the home, she said. Her family was upstairs when agents entered, Plessinger said. The 31-second video Jones posted on Twitter shows agents entering her home with their guns drawn. Jones tells the officers that her husband and two children are upstairs as they direct her outside of the house. One of the agents points his gun toward the stairwell. An officer shouts, “Police, come down now.” As the video ends, Jones yells, “He just pointed a gun at my children.” The video does not show any children, or agents pointing guns at any children. FDLE said agents didn’t point guns at anyone." ... There's a couple things missing from your comment: 1) The person refused to answer the door for 20 minutes, which is definitely a form of resistance and an indicator of possible problems, at which frankly, SOP probably kicks in and 'guns are drawn' at the point of entry. 2) The cops deny pointing guns at anyone, including children. So frankly, that seems very reasonable. While all of the journalists seem to want to recount only one side of the story, and only even part of it - is frankly deeply troubling, and it's misinformation of a serious kind. Right now we are getting really spooked about 'someone' misinforming American about election results, and attacking the integrity of the press, so I'm perennially amazed that journos want to avoid the important details that provide context. Finally, remember there's SOP (standard operating procedure). There are a lot of guns in America, and people are pretty violent in general in terms of trying to get away, or to assail cops in the process. Most warrants served are probably not for 'hacking' rather more violent actions, and there may very well be established SOP about when to draw and not. If the incident basically amounted to: 1) No answer at door 2) Cops enter with guns draw, point only upstairs urging people to come down. Then it's completely reasonable. Obviously, nobody should be pointing guns at regular people for white collar crimes, but as usual, all this might have been avoided if the individual answered the door and 'used her words'. Also, the 'big story' here is the possibility of someone being harassed for whistle-blowing, which is disconcerting, but that's not so much relevant when worrying about the specific facts of an altercation. [1] https://www.sun-sentinel.com/coronavirus/fl-ne-whistleblower-search-warrant-20201207-rapzkgm7fnbujlhwzadunciigu-story.html https://www.sun-sentinel.com/coronavirus/fl-ne-whistleblower...