4 ms·
With a bit of effort it’s a solved problem, however as soon as that was sorted, developers started using snaps and flatpaks that just Do Not Care about your sys
by toyg 6y ago
With a bit of effort it’s a solved problem, however as soon as that was sorted, developers started using snaps and flatpaks that just Do Not Care about your system settings... and we’re back at square -1, because now you won’t even get consistency between Gtk apps and Gtk apps.
The Linux desktop sometimes is like a bad comedy sketch.
- p1necone 6y agoDo snaps/flatpaks really not look at your local configs? Thats... terrible. I've avoided them already anyway because they seem like wholly unnecessary (and quite significant) bloat.
- julianlam 6y agoNo, probably because that's outside their scope and so they're not allowed to read them.
- p1necone 6y agoSurely the sane thing to do security wise would be to mark each flatpak as needing config files foo and bar, and sticking those into the sandbox as well on launch. The app itself doesn't need filesystem access at runtime. Linux apps suddenly not reading standard config files on my system would be a pretty big downside.
- toyg 6y agoI think part of the issue is that technically you cannot guarantee that config files written by the system-installed toolkit can be safely used by the flatpak-shipped toolkit. This said, I think flatpak actually makes an effort to use the ones available in the user’s home folder, whereas snap just does its own thing and screw everyone else.
- sp1rit 6y agoFlatpak does respect your GTK+ Theme - but you have to either have it installed in ~/.local/share/themes or youbhave to download your theme as flatpak package aswell. But that implies that someone has to maintain the flatpak packge. While the most popular themes are available, more "niece" themes are missing. Do a `flatpak remote-ls flathub | grep --color "org.gtk.Gtk3theme"` to see all available themes. Note: I'm maintaining a theme on flathub.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoMaybe it's just me, but distro repo usually has only esoteric and metro themes, so if I want something usable, it ends up in .local.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoThey do by the way of an xsettingsdaemon (so not accessing directly) for security reasons. The obstacle instead is that they are self-contained, so they should not depend on the theme files outside their system. Hence, they will read what theme you are using and then inside their system look for a matching one.
- OJFord 6y agoWell now I've gone from not caring about snap/flatpak (only selling point seemed to be ease of install; I've never had a problem with arch & the AUR) to making mental note to steer well clear if the temptation ever began to set in.
- ghthor 6y agoYes snap is bad. Compared to the AUR qhere you can read the build script, snap is compiled by someone else and the build script isnt available to perform yourself, at least as far as I looked.
- johnmaguire2013 6y agoThe advantage here is that malware can't be shipped as part of the build process.
- jeena 6y agoI tried Ubuntu for a couple of weeks because I felt that the installation procedure for Arch would take some time for me to set up and I wanted to be up and running a bit faster. After 4 weeks and every app having so many hoops to jump through because of snaps to get them working together I jumped ship and went back to Arch and the AUR. It's just such a difference in user experience. I feel that Ubuntu is doing a big disservice with snaps (haven't used flatpack that much) to the Linux Desktop community. If it's impossible for me to understand how to use it efficiently, then there is no way in hell I will point my father towards Ubuntu.
- pmontra 6y agoOut of curiosity, which apps do you use that come packaged in a snap? My Ubuntu 20.04 tells me this: $ snap list Name Version Rev Tracking Publisher Notes canonical-livepatch 9.5.5 95 latest/stable canonical - core 16-2.48 10444 latest/stable canonical core core18 20200929 1932 latest/stable canonical base gnome-3-28-1804 3.28.0-19-g98f9e67.98f9e67 145 latest/stable canonical - gnome-3-34-1804 0+git.3556cb3 60 latest/stable canonical - gtk-common-themes 0.1-50-gf7627e4 1514 latest/stable/… canonical - snap-store 3.38.0-55-geb45541 498 latest/stable/… canonical - I think it's the bare minimum before utterly removing all support for snaps [1]. I installed everything I need either as .deb or docker. BTW, slack has a deb on its download page. I installed another 20.04 on my old laptop from 2006 yesterday because I read that its kernel would finally support again the old ATI X1600 graphic card. It does. When I run emacs and thunderbird from terminal it told me "command not found" and something along the lines of do you want to install as a snap or with apt? I run the apt commands. [1] https://www.kevin-custer.com/blog/disabling-snaps-in-ubuntu-20-04/ https://www.kevin-custer.com/blog/disabling-snaps-in-ubuntu-...
- jeena 6y agoThunderbird, Kdenlive, Darktable, Gimp, KeePassXC, VLC, Minecraft Those are the ones I remember. I needed to install them via snap because the deb packages were too old to be able to open my files which I copied over from my Arch installation.
- jcelerier 6y agoI mean, it's just back to the state of windows where even most of Microsoft's apps aren't consistent with each other
- toyg 6y agoWindows actually used to be decent and fairly consistent, but I agree that it's gone to shit in the last decade. They botched scaling to HiDpi and fragmented their UIs in the sad attempt to chase convergence with touch UIs.
- jcelerier 6y agodid it ? except win 3.1 (but then I was a small kid) I remember a huge majority of apps having their own little fancy skins in 98, XP, etc
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoThey are my last hope to get a decent UI now.
- toyg 6y agoMajority? Not as I recall it. Some, yeah - famously winamp, which made it compulsory for music players (hence generating a river of tacky UIs). But in my world the majority of apps had the good old “top-bar-menu-icons, File menu, Edit menu, etc” format.