3 ms·
The objective of the government is not just to ensure that one or even two companies have infrastructure reaching most or all rural areas, but to ensure enough
by simonh 6y ago
The objective of the government is not just to ensure that one or even two companies have infrastructure reaching most or all rural areas, but to ensure enough players in this field to establish a genuinely competitive market for pervasive rural internet access. The FCC has decided that without this subsidy there would not be enough companies offering enough access to enough areas to meet their mandate.
Given this goal, it’s simply unreasonable to deny funds to a company that has already set up that access, but only grant funds to new entrants. That clearly screws over the existing companies, which now can’t afford to compete on price with the new government funded entrants.
The only way to establish a level playing field and not penalise companies that already invested heavily is to give the grants regardless of past investment. Then you can genuinely allow the competitive market to establish fair and competitive prices for these customers. Free market principles should in theory ensure that this price competition should recoup a significant proportion of the subsidy costs for consumers and tax payers.
- iptrans 6y agoI think you have misunderstood the purpose of RDOF grants. The RDOF grants are not there to establish competition. RDOF grants exist purely for some company to provide broadband service where there is none. If anything it's funding a local monopoly.
- simonh 6y agoIf that wee true, since Starlink will reach everywhere, they would only need to fund Starlink. In fact the OP would be correct and no subsidy would be needed since Starlink is already being built.
- iptrans 6y agoI am glad we agree, me being both the one you are replying to and the OP you are referring to. For the avoidance of doubt, here's the link to the FCC RDOF auction and the relevant quote: "... Rural Digital Opportunity Fund to bring high speed fixed broadband service to rural homes and small businesses that lack it." https://www.fcc.gov/auction/904 https://www.fcc.gov/auction/904
- simonh 6y agoCould be I'm taking an overly rosy view of what they're up to.
- wmf 6y agoIt sounds like the FCC took a beauty contest approach to this funding so ISPs promising gigabit took 90% of the money and Starlink got what was left.