3 ms·
> If someone says "if you don't fix this thing I will look for work elsewhere" that doesn't mean that you can say "I accept your resignation." I think you'll f
by BeetleB 6y ago
> If someone says "if you don't fix this thing I will look for work elsewhere" that doesn't mean that you can say "I accept your resignation."
I think you'll find from a legal standpoint, it does.[1] At least I know that they teach in negotiations courses that any time you make a counteroffer, the original offer is legally null and void. So if I give you an employment offer that is good for 30 days, and you counter the following day with a higher salary, then I legally can say "No, and we will not hire you" (i.e. the 30 days clause became invalid once you gave me a counteroffer).
This isn't exactly the same, but we are at least taught to treat it similarly.
Also, she didn't merely say "I will look for work elsewhere". She said something to the effect of "Let's meet to decide my end date." There's a significant difference.
[1] Although being an at-will job, the legality is rather moot.
- zorpner 6y ago> I think you'll find from a legal standpoint, it does. In fact, it specifically does not: https://cuiab.ca.gov/board/precedentdecisions/docs/pb39.pdf https://cuiab.ca.gov/board/precedentdecisions/docs/pb39.pdf
- GauntletWizard 6y agoThat’s about whether pay is owed. I’m certain that Google did not simply stop paying her checks, but told her to go home and that the remainder of her employment would be paid out. I suspect that’s enough for the law to agree that she was terminated voluntarily.
- sjg007 6y agoIt's pay and also unemployment benefits if necessary.
- pseudalopex 6y agoYou can't be certain unless you handle payroll for Google. A manager told it was effective immediately and mentioned her final paycheck.
- ballenf 6y agoIn that case an employee gave a resignation date of 11/15. Employer cut off the employment two weeks early and court ruled that it shouldn't be considered a resignation, but instead a termination by employer. What's the parallel between those facts and the dispute here? Just not seeing any applicable precedent.
- sjg007 6y agoYeah accepting a resignation effective immediately is a firing, especially when companies ask for 2 weeks notice.
- pseudalopex 6y agoShe gave a date or implied she intended to. Google cut off her employment immediately.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> In that case an employee gave a resignation date of 11/15. Employer cut off the employment two weeks early and court ruled that it shouldn't be considered a resignation, but instead a termination by employer. > What's the parallel between those facts and the dispute here? That it's, at best for Google, the exact same thing, except that Google gave Gebru, in writing, an explicit, non-resignation reason for the early separation, making it even less disputable that it was a firing and not merely accepting the (disputed) resignation? Paraphrased most favorably to the Google management narrative, Gebru said “do X or I will conduct discussions around setting a date on which I will resign” and Google management said “we accept your resignation and, further, based on an internal group e-mail you sent after this dispute started which we find unacceptable, we are ending your employment immediately.”
- worker767424 6y ago> Although being an at-will job, the legality is rather moot. The only interesting implication is unemployment, but if it's a termination, Google might tell the unemployment office it was for insubordination.
- totalZero 6y agoThe difference between being fired and resigning isn't moot, even in an at-will job where the employer can fire you without cause or explanation. How/why you departed can affect your severance, unemployment insurance, and other financial considerations. In some industries, it may also affect the report submitted to an industry regulator.