3 ms·
This was interesting to me: "But there is no hard requirement for papers to actually go through this review with two weeks’ notice. Numerous papers are approve
by tyingq 6y ago
This was interesting to me:
"But there is no hard requirement for papers to actually go through this review with two weeks’ notice. Numerous papers are approved for publication submission without meeting this “requirement”: an internal analysis shows that just under half of the papers submitted to PubApprove are done so with a day or less notice to approvers."
That doesn't show that 2 weeks notice isn't required. It just shows that some papers make it through the process very quickly. Perhaps those that don't have much controversy associated with them. That doesn't seem unusual to me, and doesn't seem to prove anything. It also seems curious that they didn't talk about how long that other half did typically take. Min/max/average would have been helpful.
Note that I have no idea if Dr Gebru was wronged here. Just noting that the above passage seems inconclusive to me.