4 ms·
One unfortunate dangling problem with the historical nomenclature is this: "scales have modes" This is wrong. A scale is an interval series. A mode is an i
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
One unfortunate dangling problem with the historical nomenclature is this:
"scales have modes"
This is wrong. A scale is an interval series. A mode is an interval series. There is no difference between them.
It just so happens that there are ways to permute some interval series to generate others. Because western music is so focused on the interval series we call the major scale, people noted that you can permute this into a series of other interval series. But none of those interval series (Aeolian, Phrygian, Lydian etc) "own" or are the basis for the others: they are all related by permutation. You could just as easily say "Modes of the Phrygian scale" and you would still be referring to the same set of interval series.
- fenomas 6y ago> This is wrong. Modes are (typically) permutations of scales. The fact that a permutation of a scale is also a scale doesn't mean it's wrong to say that scales have permutations.