7 ms·
The most interesting piece of information to me is the suggestion of Apple still going with SoC route with its Mac Pro. i.e UMA ( Unified Memory Architecture )
by ksec 6y ago
The most interesting piece of information to me is the suggestion of Apple still going with SoC route with its Mac Pro.
i.e UMA ( Unified Memory Architecture ), GPU, NPU stay intact. You are basically getting a M1XX, where M1X is the 16 CPU Core variants.
Consider the current M1, a 32 Core High Performance CPU Core and 128 GPU core would give you roughly 300W TDP Max, excluding all the memory controller and interconnect. A rough estimate is already at 500mm2+ Die Size, excluding NPU and all other bits and pieces, of course assuming the same processing node.
The Old ( Or the recent ) Mac Pro has a Maxed out system of ~910W, that is 28 Core CPU + 2 x Radeon Vega II Duo ( That is 4 GPU ).
We are back to TrashCan Mac Pro again, except it would be even faster than the 2019 Cheese Grater Mac Pro. We would have reached the thermal ceiling again, unless Apple does Water Cooling and push that TDP allowance to 400W.
Remember this M1XX is CPU + GPU TDP. For a PC system, or workstation power users are quite used to 300W CPU + 300W GPU. So I was sort of expecting Apple to be making CPU + GPU design, purely to create a monster as a successor to Cheese Grater Mac Pro. May be they have different Goal in mind, may be they think this is good enough for Mac Pro ( Which certainly is from many perspective ), and obviously iMac.
Same Design, scaling across iPhone, iPad, MacBook, And Mac Pro.
This brings me to the final point, we only have so much uArch improvement we could do, it is now all left to process node and heat dissipation of the system.
We are in the era of TDP Computing.
- an_opabinia 6y agoWell, in terms of dollars per getting shit done, a GPU on ARM that only supports Metal 2 isn’t going to get any software for it in a really really long time, no matter how fast it is, perhaps so long that better conventional GPUs will come out by then. Who do you think writes all the code for this stuff? It’s guys in tracksuits in Visual Studio C++ on Windows. The top games for iOS are also either written by a few guys in Unity or by an absolutely huge team of people porting an existing, low graphics quality PC game.
- wmf 6y agoA lot of software will end up using OpenGL->Metal, Vulkan->Metal, or D3D->Metal translation layers but it won't matter if the GPU is fast enough.
- JoshTko 6y agoApple is probably going to be first on TSMC's 3nm which will go into volume production in 2H 2022 so perhaps they can hit 300W easy.
- mciancia 6y agoI wonder if for bigger, desktop macs they will stay with ddr4/ddr5 memory sticks or maybe they will introduce something custom. I assume they won't go with mac pro with soldered, non-removable memory
- bhouston 6y ago>We are in the era of TDP Computing. Intel has been saying this for years, like almost 8 years. But this is just what non-innovator say. It is an excuse for mediocrity and failure and stagnation. There is tons of uArch improvements in Apple's chips. That is why they consistently beat even the other ARMs chips on the same process nodes. AMD also has been significantly innovating with uArch. I love the innovation we are seeing these days. We are definitely not in an TDP era (where only TDP matters! but of course TDP is important), we are in another golden age of CPU/GPU innovation and it is beautiful. Reminds me of the 1990s and early 2000s.
- kungito 6y agoDon't they beat others because they are almost always a process generation ahead like now with 5nm?
- dylan604 6y agoAt some point, the process can't get any smaller. Physics has hard rules. Once we get to that limit, improvements will have to come from elsewhere.
- colejohnson66 6y agoWe are butting up on the physical limit, but to be fair, that’s what people have been saying for over a decade, and we keep going. According to Wolfram Alpha, 5 nanometers is ~23 silicon atoms across (~2.2 Å each). But that’s also assuming they’re actually fabricating 5 nm gates - which they’re not.
- anfilt 6y agoLike if you look at the rate of down scaling it has slowed some. It's also not the size of the whole transistor it's the size/thickness of the N, P and Insulator layers that will limiting factor in FET style transistors. The oxide/insulator thickness on modern process is pretty insane. For instance for the intel 14nm++ the silicon nitride and silicon oxide layers seem to 4 to 5nm thick. -Edit- For instance here is 2 fins for from the intel 14nm++. The grains/spheres you see this image are the atoms. Some parts of the a modern transistors are even smaller than process number may let you know. https://imgur.com/a/hgeSOVV https://imgur.com/a/hgeSOVV
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gameswithgo 6y agoIf they stick with UMA, gpu performance is going to be severely limited, unless they can make the unified memory GDDR6 or something.
- ksec 6y agoI would love to know as well. I think it could be HBM2, something similar to Fujitsu A64FX [1], the problem with both GDDR6 and HMB2 is that are limited in capacity to ~64GB, or at best 128GB. Which is far from the 1.5 TB of memory the current Mac Pro is capable of. [1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/15885/hpc-systems-special-offer-two-a64fx-nodes-in-a-2u-for-40k https://www.anandtech.com/show/15885/hpc-systems-special-off...
- dylan604 6y agoWhat if you gave the GPU its own dedicated memory again?
- ksec 6y agoThen it would make sense to have the two chip separate and not on the same Die. Which is essentially what the current PC system are doing. The whole hypotheses is built on Mark Gurman's suggestion of Mac Pro using something similar to SoC like the current M1.
- dylan604 6y agoWhy? Clearly, I'm not a chip designer, so maybe it's a dumb question. If you can place GPU cores, CPU cores, Neural Engine, and RAM on the same die, why can't you then use a second bank of RAM dedicated for the GPU cores? Why would this not be considered similar?
- wmf 6y agoThere's nothing stopping a chip from having HBM and, say, DDR5 DIMM slots but that has only been done once before by a doomed Xeon Phi. It's more likely that the future Mac Pro will use Lifuka which everyone in this thread is ignoring.
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoWhile you may well be correctly reading between the lines, you are reading between the lines -- the article doesn't say anything about future "Mac Chips," as the headline puts it, definitively being SoCs. There's nothing about a unified memory architecture that requires the GPU and CPU to be on the same die, let alone requires the RAM to be in the same package as both processing units. (People may no longer remember that Silicon Graphics was using UMA in their workstations a quarter century ago!) I expect all their portables, and probably all the iMacs to be SoCs, but I'm not sure the Mac Pro -- and the iMac Pro, if it continues -- will follow that path. > We are back to TrashCan Mac Pro again... we would have reached the thermal ceiling again... This is kind of drawing new lines to read between. :) Apple almost certainly developed their current uber-expensive, trypophobia-triggering Mac Pro design knowing that they were also working on Apple Silicon processors. While it's possible they intend that whole case design to be a one-time thing, it doesn't seem likely to me -- and if that wasn't the intent, then it's also not likely they want to ship a teeny tiny Apple Silicon logic board in that huge case with the rest of the space going unused. I think they're going to do their best to make an Apple Silicon-based Mac Pro that can be upgraded and expanded. (With all respect to Mark Gurman, I think that "half-sized Mac Pro" is going to be a different product entirely if it ships, with a different branding. Mac Mini Pro?)
- spideymans 6y ago>With all respect to Mark Gurman, I think that "half-sized Mac Pro" is going to be a different product entirely if it ships, with a different branding. Mac Mini Pro? The ever illusive xMac, aka "the affordable Mac tower"
- jskajakzkjx 6y agoSomebody once said that that Apple’s business model is charging a very high markup for flash memory (currently it’s $50 per 64 GB to upgrade storage on an iPhone or MacBook). The margin on other parts is also high. The user-upgradeable Mac Pro provides an escape hatch from these expensive upgrades. Therefore the entry price has to be much higher to make up for it. An affordable tower would cannibalize Mac Pro sales by providing businesses with a cost-saving opportunity that’s too good to refuse.
- thomaslord 6y agoOne thing to note here that's a bit ambiguous in your comment - an M1XX with 128 GPU cores would still have substantially fewer GPU cores than the 2x Radeon Vega II Duo. The Radeon Vega II Due has 128 compute cores and 8192 stream processors, so that maxed out mac pro would have 256 compute cores and 16384 stream processors. I don't have any benchmarks to work off of, but I think it's safe to say that a new Mac Pro with the 32-core SoC would still be substantially far behind a current Mac Pro unless it also had a dedicated GPU.
- fomine3 6y agoI believe GPU core count between different products isn't comparable. Comparing TFLOPS would be better than core count.
- jsjohnst 6y agoAssuming linear scaling (which is not a good assumption), Apple would need 6x the number of GPU cores in the current M1 to get in the range of performance of the Radeon Vega II Duo.
- cybwraith 6y agoThis is interesting.. is the M1 chip's GPU a tile-based chip similar to other mobile/ARM SoCs? If so, that could be a problem for truly higher end graphics work as certain operations such as real time shadows, fullscreen shaders, etc are less efficient when applied on such a GPU
- webmobdev 6y agoDoes UMA (unified memory architecture) prevent anyone from also adding additional conventional RAM too (apart from what is integrated in the CPU)? Have today's SSD reached RAM's read / write speed?
- ksec 6y agoUMA has nothing to do with the RAM sitting next to CPU, which is what half of this thread is getting mixed up with. They are two different thing. So yes you could have UMA and conventional DRAM, the problem is that there are no DRAM, even with 8 Channel DDR5, capable of feeding enough bandwidth for the hypothetical 128 Core GPU. That is unless Apple decide to use DRAM in additional to HMB or GDDR5 as 2nd layer of Memory.
- webmobdev 6y agoSo is Apple's UMA similar to the nearly 2 decades old SGI O2 UMA - http://www.sgidepot.co.uk/o2/1352.pdf http://www.sgidepot.co.uk/o2/1352.pdf ?