7 ms·
> The data that each smart meter will transmit will be validated and certified by the blockchain, so as to be able to unequivocally guarantee the savings obtain
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
> The data that each smart meter will transmit will be validated and certified by the blockchain, so as to be able to unequivocally guarantee the savings obtained at a
certain point in time
Block chain doesn't validate things happening in the real world (energy saved, KWh consumed) only auditors/inspectors can do that. The data from the smart meter can always be faked before it goes to the blockchain network.
Have I missed something? I'd be inclined to give Woz the benefit of the doubt on most things but I don't get what blockchain gives here apart from marketing BS - for which its a year or two behind the times?
- greenkey 6y ago> a year or two behind the times How exactly? I agree with you that use of blockchain on its own is not fully secure, but that can be mitigated for the most part through the same sorts of proof-of-work and proof-of-stake mechanisms and entities that Etherium, etc. use. with adjustments. This might be exactly the time for Woz and co. to get into this given that there are others handling those problems, right?
- codetrotter 6y ago> I agree with you that use of blockchain on its own is not fully secure, but that can be mitigated for the most part through the same sorts of proof-of-work and proof-of-trust mechanisms and entities that Etherium, etc. use. None of that does anything to prove that the energy consumption data you are submitting is true.
- greenkey 6y agoThat’s what proof-of-work and proof-of-stake are about. I’m saying that the problem has been solved and would need to just be applied to this use case.
- pjc50 6y agoNope: those only apply to elements on the blockchain, not elements in the real world. You'd need proof-of-not-work for a real energy efficiency business.
- cocktailpeanuts 6y ago> That’s what proof-of-work and proof-of-stake are about Nope. No amount of "proof of X" will help if you put false data on the blockchain in the first place. They will do a great job securing the false data though. Good luck with that.
- deepGem 6y agoYou've hit the nail on the fundamental issue. Authenticity check at the Physical -> Digital touch point. Some efforts such as digital KYC for banking are able to solve this because the process involves a government issued identity, so the authenticity of the physical -> digital transmission is sort of embedded into the physical asset itself. Tampering the physical asset can be quickly reverified using several of the asset parameters (photo, DOB etc). For aspects such as meters or constantly changing physical data, I am not sure if it will ever be possible to ensure the authenticity of physical -> digital touchpoint. Is this something an embedded processor can help resolve ? In essence eliminating the possibility of fake data emerging from the meters ?
- grive 6y agoIndeed this is the crucial part. Usually a company will not generate its own energy. Depending on the country, the infrastructure is sometimes publicly owned and managed. Maybe the physical -> digital touchpoint here could be outside the boundaries of the company. The energy grid should report those numbers as references, to subscribers agreed upon by the company for example. There it could be certified by the government. Or something like that? Edit: Well of course now there would be an incentive to burn petrol to run turbines and generate locally, then turn them off to capitalize on a high in the energy efficiency security market...
- hef19898 6y agoSame problem with supply chains. There is still the need for a trusted party at the beginning of every block chain with a physical component to assure physical and digital data are the same.
- deepstack 6y ago* only auditors/inspectors can do that * exactly. Everytime with this smart meter comes up, this is the crucial thing that just doesn't make sense. No replacement for "auditors/inspectors"!
- cloudhead 6y agoGive the smart meter a private key protected in hardware, give the chain its public key, and you can now verify things.
- thomastjeffery 6y ago> protected in hardware That's the fallacy of DRM. There's no real way to keep data from a user.
- cloudhead 6y agoSo given a locked iPhone, you are able to extract its private key?
- dfgdghdf 6y agoExactly. Why do software engineers (myself included) so often confuse what is possible with what is practical?
- craftinator 6y agoWe do that because our job in general is to ignore current practical limitations. The line between practical and impractical changes based on what we make; the job is all about creating solutions that either make a goal more practical, or improving the efficiency of a standing process. This isn't just a problem with software engineers, but most engineering disciplines. It's impractical to transport logs hundreds of miles for processing, until we create a system that can do it efficiently. It's impractical to keep detailed records of billions of transactions, until we set up a database and reporting infrastructure that can handle that load.
- hannasanarion 6y agoNo, but you are able to hook another device up to the battery so that the iPhone is wrong about its own power usage and phones home with incorrect values.
- 6y ago
- short_sells_poo 6y agoMaybe it's badly worded. It could mean that the history is cryptographically resilient against tampering in the future. Ie once your meter submits a reading, it becomes part of the blockchain and cannot be tampered with. Is this really that useful though?
- intotheabyss 6y agoThis is called the oracle problem, and it's a very real problem and why I'm incredibly skeptical of "supply chain" blockchain applications.
- dredds 6y agoThis is why i had hopes for AI blockchains as the data and trained models or functional algorithms could be verifiably provable as increasing usability/productivity/efficiency etc. You could still say your device/robot didn't improve, but if you continued using the models or algorithms then that would be noticeable. You would have to know they were still being used though, so you would need a time-sensitive encryption that calls home to activate, and if used in multiple instances you'd know that too. But reverse engineering the encryption to get the secret sauce sounds like a workaround. It could be made difficult for average folk, but not impossible. The real advantage would be micro/nano-payments and fee-less transactions since the device is the "miner", ie. by not using BTC/ETH etc. At the end of the day a subscription model is probably easier.
- howlgarnish 6y agoAI blockchains? Encryption that calls home? Wut?
- dredds 6y agohttps://github.com/steven2358/awesome-blockchain-ai https://github.com/steven2358/awesome-blockchain-ai (works in progress, some more like app stores)
- castlecrasher2 6y agoIs there a single case of a blockchain-enhanced service where the end result is provably better than a centralized system? I'm cynical given that every case I've seen so far has turned out to be rubbish, though admittedly I'm not heavily in that space.
- 6y ago
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoScientists in industrial research labs are often required to keep journals, and sometimes get them signed periodically from others, so that in case of legal issues (usually patents), there is a clear paper trail. This is not a foolproof method, and multiple people can conspire to change the journals at a later date. However, it is a better system than where people don't do this. Don't think in binary. Think, whether this system provides better validation/certification than where auditors/inspectors come by at the end of the year to check records. Perhaps, it's harder to systematically cheat the system if you have to announce your data to the world daily, then if you wait till the 11th month, and cook your books so everything works out. I doubt this removes the role of auditors/inspectors, but it might supplement them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dfgdghdf 6y agoYou are right in the strictest sense, but I think blockchain is still interesting here. With a blockchain, there is a tamper-proof public record of who submitted what, and that can make disputes through a good old fashioned legal process more streamlined later on.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- inquirerofsorts 6y ago> Have I missed something? The first chapter of the whitepaper? [1] There's two sides entering a contractual agreement around energy consumption. [1] Section 1.2 - https://efforce.io/WP_ENG_V1.pdf https://efforce.io/WP_ENG_V1.pdf
- nebulous1 6y agoRight, but that's the "traditional" E.S.Co system. It doesn't explain how the Benefitting company gives value to token holders, it just says they pay the E.S.Co.
- cryptica 6y agoYes I also think this is not the best way to use blockchain because sensor data can be faked one way or another. The best way to connect blockchain to the real world is by using human psychology and so I think the best use case is still cryptocurrency. You can use crypto to build communities around a shared incentive, this in itself is an extremely powerful feature which doesn't get anywhere near enough attention considering that every idea these days relies on shared incentives in order to succeed.
- throwaway894345 6y agoAs usual, this marketing page is quite vague, but I'm reading it as the cryptocurrency equivalent of existing carbon offset markets. Both require auditors to validate the offsets, but Efforce just handles the market side.
- d33lio 6y agoI'm waiting for the tidal wave of people who think that a "trusted enclave" will fix this problem and can never be exploited or cracked... [0] [1] [0] https://www.theregister.com/2019/02/12/intel_sgx_hacked/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=facebook https://www.theregister.com/2019/02/12/intel_sgx_hacked/?utm... [1] https://blog.quarkslab.com/attacking-the-arms-trustzone.html https://blog.quarkslab.com/attacking-the-arms-trustzone.html
- puranjay 6y agoAll this makes me think is that the 2020 crypto bullrun is starting. Prepare for more "celebrity" tokens, BTC swelling past ATH followed by a massive crash that takes out a majority of the current 550 tokens on CoinMarketCap, and countless other DeFi tokens on Uniswap