3 ms·
Not all but too much of that description applies only to western popular music. Indian classical music (probably among the most melodically advanced in the wor
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
Not all but too much of that description applies only to western popular music.
Indian classical music (probably among the most melodically advanced in the world) doesn't use anything like the song structures you're referring to (it also doesn't use harmony).
The ease of certain kinds of music production has led to us to living in a decade (or two) of huge amounts of what I can only call "audio candy for ears trained on western popular music". There's nothing wrong with this music, but it's like eating cookies all the time, not realizing there are other delicious kinds of food out there.
- zozbot234 6y agoIndian classical music can be understood (admittedly in very broad terms) as being based on melodic elaboration of what in Western music would be the bass line (aka basso continuo or thoroughbass). The way this elaboration works is very similar to what one finds in the Western musical tradition (as clarified e.g. by Schenker), it's just applied in a very different way in terms of structure (indeed there's no equivalent to the 'lead' melody, to which diminution would be applied in Western music!), and obviously with a strong focus on a single monophonic 'line'.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI feel as if you just said "A is a lot like B, or rather A is made of the same stuff as B but built totally differently". From my admittedly not deep knowledge about Carnatic music, it would be a serious mistake to think of it as "being based on melodic elaboration of what in Western music would be the bass line". That's not how its composers and practitioners think of it, and critically, it misses out entirely on the whole concept of a raga, which defines not just a set of notes (the way a western scale does), but also their ordering when ascending and descending, and comes with a large amount of cultural attribution (evening ragas, seasonal ragas, emotional ragas and so on). What is played is not an elaboration of a line, but an exploration of the raga. If you were going to draw comparisons to western musical practice, I would think that Schoenberg's 12 tone/serial experiments have at least as much in common.
- ratww 6y agoOf course, I never claimed it was a universal description. My point was not that we should create only simple music, but rather that we should understand how simple music is created, before jumping into anything more complex than that, or even into a general solution like so many people into procedural generation seem to jump into. You need to understand the craft itself other than just understanding the theory. Musical styles are not unconstrained. If you want it to produce procedural Carnatic Music, you can replace my description of western music with the equivalent for it, like zozbot234 started doing. Then you'll have a starting point.