4 ms·
Those are all very clearly quirky enough to be considered "off" by people who understand Bach's music and the classical tradition more generally. And the large
by TaupeRanger 6y ago
Those are all very clearly quirky enough to be considered "off" by people who understand Bach's music and the classical tradition more generally. And the large scale structure problem is one of the primary reasons the whole thing is so hard in the first place.
- zozbot234 6y agoBut my point is that 'quirky enough to be considered off' is a rather subjective and context-dependent POV. The main issue really is the lack of consistent structure beyond the very short term, but aside from that the music seems to replicate many interesting features of the style, and it's certainly interesting enough to be listenable. Clearly it doesn't sit within the classical tradition of composed music, but it really is quite passable as 'noodling' or improvisation.