3 ms·
I think you are making this too easy. Yes, technically it is the people's own fault. However, not everybody is a supercomputer making perfect rational decisions
by Tichy 18y ago
I think you are making this too easy. Yes, technically it is the people's own fault. However, not everybody is a supercomputer making perfect rational decisions. People look to advisors and also their neighbors and peers for orientation. If advisors tell somebody he can afford something that somebody can not afford, they are also guilty to some extent. And why does anybody have to be guilty anyway (I hate scapegoat mentality).
And why no sympathy? Be happy that you are smarter and maybe had a better education and smarter peers that enabled you to make better choices. Personally I feel that kind of luck could also enable you to feel with the less lucky ones.
Edit: I just saw your one submission to HN so far, "recommendations for investing books". So apparently you acknowledge that it is not a trivial problem. You may say that everybody is free to go buy such books. But believe it or not, depending on your environment, it may not so obvious to do such a simple thing.
Another example, to clarify what I mean by luck: occasionally you hear about "wonder investors" who started trading while in school and made millions before they came of age. But if you look closer, usually they have some family member who led them down the path of investing. To their peers, it does not even occur to get interested in investing while still in school. I say that kind of thing is luck on behalf of the young investor, not stupidity on the part of the non-investors.
- tialys 18y agoI suppose I was harsh, my intention was not to say that anyone who has debt is an idiot and could have done better, I have sympathy for the poor kid from nowhere who gets himself way in debt so he can become a doctor, or so he can do something with his life. My lack of sympathy is for those who continually make poor decisions. In the article the woman felt bad because of her medical issues and continued shopping from home even though she already had previous debts, as well as her new medical debts. I have issues feeling for a person like that. I suppose I was too broad. Her issue sounds like a pyscological one, and perhaps she simply had no one to help her, but in the end she is still ultimately responsible for her own desitiny.
- scott_s 18y agoShe is responsible, but so are we, unfortunately. Because when you get enough of these people making bad decisions, it impacts the economy as a whole. Figuring out why people are continually making poor decisions regarding debt is not about finding someone other than them to blame. It's about trying to figure out what needs to change in our system so we can avoid hurting the whole.