3 ms·
> my home state of California – where GOP opposition has been virtually eradicated – single-party dominance has failed to resolve basic governance issues. I’m
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
> my home state of California – where GOP opposition has been virtually eradicated – single-party dominance has failed to resolve basic governance issues.
I’m sorry but what? Sure, CA is blue on a national map in national elections but it’s a very reddish purple for any smaller statewide analysis. As is my state (WA), and all other “safe” blue states. And while I can’t claim to be intimately familiar with local CA politics, when I do follow the local goings on they’re very similar to here: at every layer of government where the GOP is electorally disadvantaged, they still find ways to have outsized influence. And in these blue states, they often achieve that by undermining the platforms of their D rivals and sewing doubt in the platform’s merit. Essentially trolling as politics. But it’s surprisingly effective.
CA’s ballot initiative system is often called out, because you can pass a new measure and defund it in the same go. Well, WA doesn’t have quite the same system but we have it staggered by ballot cycle, and yeah. It’s chaotic. Every time we decide we want to do something as a state, someone comes along and says “boy it would be great if the tax system (we quietly keep in place to make it painful for you) didn’t make you feel pain for this thing, do you wanna vote for a few more dollars in your pocket?” And of course people want a few more dollars in their pocket.
It’s a mistake to think anywhere is safe from this. We can’t pay for anything anywhere. Because some people would rather hold it hostage for their advantage.
- purple-again 6y agoI think we are doomed to this forever by human nature. As a thought experiment ask yourself what you think would happen in the following scenario: We enshrine the two party system into law but allow all Americans to chose their party freely each year. You no longer pay taxes or receive services from the government but from your party instead. Do you think this would lead to harmony where the half of the country that wants high taxes and many services would join the D party and the half that wants low taxes and few services would join the R party, all living side by side in harmony? Or do you think this would lead to total chaos where the people with money to take (IE money to spend on services for themselves) all join the R party and the people without money to take all join the D party looking for services they can’t provide to themselves. I would say it’s pretty obvious what would happen but then again my world view is a bit cynical and of course not the only one. I would say it’s exactly what has happened to our system without needing the thought experiment to make the incentives obvious.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoBillionaires are overwhelming pro-Democratic party politics, and most of them are even in favor of genuine "big government". They understand which side their bread is buttered on. [ EDIT: turns out I was wrong. Billionaires are not overwhelmingly pro-Democratic party. They are, however, roughly split between Democrats and Republicans, which does more or less the same work in disproving the claim implicit in the parent's rhetorical thought experiment. ] Your thesis doesn't hold.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Billionaires are overwhelming pro-Democratic party politics, and most of them are even in favor of genuine "big government". The data on political contributions by billionaires isn't really consistent with that. https://americansfortaxfairness.org/billionaire-politics/ https://americansfortaxfairness.org/billionaire-politics/
- roenxi 6y ago> I’m sorry but what? Sure, CA is blue on a national map in national elections but it’s a very reddish purple for any smaller statewide analysis. So I'll cheerfully admit a near total ignorance about Californian politics, but I see a 29:11 and 61:18 Democrat majority in what looks like the state parliament [0]. The wiki link also mentions "The Democratic Party currently holds veto-proof supermajorities in both houses of the California State Legislature.". I didn't actually think it was possible to see such majorities in an large, healthy, wealthy democracy, but obviously I've reassessed that now. Intransigent minorities can do a lot, but it seems like it would be a real challenge to push back past against that sort of majority. California is going to be a pretty fair representation of what would happen if the Democrats gained a 60% across board majority in US federal politics. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_State_Legislature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_State_Legislature
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I didn't actually think it was possible to see such majorities in an large, healthy, wealthy democracy, but obviously I've reassessed that now. It's probably not, at least , California’s electoral democracy isn't healthy; California's major parties (and this particularly impacts the Republicans) aren't completely free to align themselves as they would independently for competitive purposes because they are affiliated with national parties that have the kind of financial relationships with them and their campaigns that would be illegal for foreign parties if California was independent. > California is going to be a pretty fair representation of what would happen if the Democrats gained a 60% across board majority in US federal politics. It's really not, because California and the Federal government aren't structured similarly. The feds do t have as much detail of government tied up in the Constitution that the legislature can't amend on its own. The feds don't have citizens reserving the powers of recall, referendum, and initiative. The feds don't have a higher Constitutional bar for tax increases than passing a budget. And the kind of electoral lopsidedness that occurs in CA wouldn't be nearly as stable on a federal level; those no outside party to kowtow to that constrains major parties fromm competitive realignment.
- roenxi 6y ago
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Sure, CA is blue on a national map in national elections but it’s a very reddish purple for any smaller statewide analysis. No, it's not. It's true that it has very large Republican land areas, but like the country at large these areas are mostly the sparsely populated ones. Since the national Republican Party began radicalizing during the Clinton Administration, the California Republican Party has been increasingly uncompetitive.
- bitwize 6y agoDemocratic governor, Democratic legislature. They have a hammerlock on state politics.