7 ms·
Google removes some IAC browser extensions for 'policy violations'
- sbarre 6y agotl;dr - Multi-billion-dollar ad-serving corporations aren't getting along.
- cma 6y agoUnclear from the article: what is IAC, and what did their extensions purport to do?
- spartas 6y agoIAC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAC_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAC_(company) Your second question is valid though
- naringas 6y agoIn my own worldview companies such as this as at this point autonomous entities made from money and owned by other money. This is the stuff that skynet is made from. This particular one seems noxious, but there are others which do make useful stuff, e.g. Kraft? Nestle? DuPont? P&G? come to mind.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 6y agoThey sure do a lot of disparate things. Is the issue with only one or a few of the areas in which they are involved? Surely vimeo, the daily beast are uninvolved in this?
- ma2rten 6y agoI think it's mainly ask.com
- notatoad 6y agoIAC was at one time Google's largest single advertising customer. Detail of the complaint from the wsj article linked above: > Many users of IAC extensions expressed agitation, the audit found. “Tricked into installing it and can’t delete it,” said one user in a review on the Google Chrome store, which the audit called representative. “DO NOT INSTALL” warned another. “IAC’s business model appears to rely almost exclusively on unintentional installs,” members of the Chrome safety team wrote in the audit. Of special concern in the audit were ads that IAC ran against search terms such as “how to vote,” “vote by mail” and “voter fraud.” Users who clicked on the ads didn’t get voting-related information, the audit found. Instead, their browser home pages were reset to MyWay, and the separate, IAC-owned Ask.com toolbar was installed on those users’ browsers, the audit found. The audit found that IAC continued to run such ads even after Google told the company to stop.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eznzt 6y ago>“Tricked into installing it and can’t delete it,” said one user in a review on the Google Chrome store How is that possible? Or are we simply looking at someone who doesn't know how to use her computer?
- michaelt 6y agoI haven't used Windows in many years, but back in the day adware would get itself bundled with native applications' installers - for example, you download and install Java on Windows, they try to trick you into installing a toolbar. Once your adware is installed as a native application, you simply install two copies, each of which immediately reinstalls and restarts the other should it get removed/stopped.
- int_19h 6y agoThis is a Chrome extension - they're supposed to be sandboxed, and unable to pull such tricks. If it really couldn't be uninstalled from the installed extensions list in Chrome, I'd love to know how they did it.
- d3nj4l 6y agoThe WSJ article has a lot more details: https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-spars-with-barry-dillers-iac-on-misleading-marketing-practices-11607267157 https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-spars-with-barry-dillers...
- andreareina 6y agohttps://archive.is/F0J8C https://archive.is/F0J8C
- altdatathrow 6y agoWhen will they remove the many extensions owned by SimilarWeb that harvest and sell personal browsing history?
- for_i_in_range 6y agoIf you own IAC stock, I’d recommend selling as soon as market opens tomorrow. Watch. Barry Diller’s hidden secret to wealth is IAC’s Adware division (called “Mindspark”. Basically Ask Toolbars to trick unsophisticated masses to install browser extensions). IAC and Google, until now, has had a backroom relationship and contracts to turn a blind eye towards Adware and Deceptive Advertising. That’s the summary.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- huac 6y agoper WSJ that division is less than 5% of IAC revenue and shrinking. it would be surprising if there was more than a 2-3% move attributable to this news, which would bring you all the way back to, um, thursday's share price. also, this price action should be incorporated into the opening auction, so really you should sell before the market opens, not when it opens
- for_i_in_range 6y agoWonder how much Profit, though. Since there’s only upfront cost and then a massive long tail collecting Google Revenue for 3-4 years the unknowing and unsophisticated user keeps it installed (all profit at that point). Chrome uninstalling would be quite the disruption to their cash cow. In the words if George Carlin (may he rest in peace), “Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that.” The second half are who this part of IAC’s profit thrives on.
- mike_d 6y agoLess than 5% of direct revenue, but it is used to drive tons of traffic to their other properties. IAC buys random up and coming websites/apps/etc and turns the firehose of traffic on them.
- ballenf 6y agoGiven IAC’s strong DIY home repair and cooking properties, I’d say they’ll continue to be strong through lockdowns.
- donor20 6y agoThis was one of those situations where there MUST have been a lot of cash flowing to google - because the IAC business in this space was straight scam behavior. Homepage hijacking and all the usual goodies. For all the highly paid data scientists google paid, they somehow thought IAC's business in this space was consumer positive when every metric must have been screaming that it was user unfriendly. For me a lot of stuff people complain about google don't make sense, removing subdomains from URL bar, I can see the argument for safety there. But this was straight google funded crap. I wish some of the enforcement focused more on this type of stuff - straight forward google funded anti-consumer behavior. I wonder what made google decide to finally cut off the crapware. Instead we are told google can't cut of the absolute trash from IAC because it would be anti-consumer / anti-competitive to do so. Regulators have their heads on totally backwards in this space. Why don't they go hard after the crap that clearly and obviously hurts users (there is so much of it).
- judge2020 6y agoI'd be surprised if data science was ran on the chrome web store/extensions in any medium/large capacity. The report abuse feature doesn't seem to work, maybe unless X% downloads report it triggering some internal alarm for an intern to go try out the extension (maybe on an airgapped chromebook).
- MattGaiser 6y agoDoes Google have people looking at Chrome extension data? It seems almost like a zombie project for them. It carries on, but next to no resources seem to be allocated to it.
- donor20 6y agoThe issue is not the extensions per se, but the partner revenue. "I'm extremely pleased to announce the extension of our 14-year relationship with Google," said Joey Levin, CEO of IAC. "We've generated nearly $10 billion in revenue to date through the life of our partnership, and this extension makes clear that we have plenty more to deliver. Google's search and search advertising products remain the strongest in the world, and we believe that this renewal puts us in a solid position for the years ahead." Does google have data scientists looking at ad revenue? For sure. How that revenue is generated is a core business, and there is no question they had metrics on quality of that traffic which would be the first hop before landing on the ad. The idea they thought this was all quality organic traffic - no chance. I get regulators are cracking down, but the fake reviews, fake shopping sites and now these fake ad revenue generators don't deserve regulatory protection. Fair point on the extensions side though.
- floatin 6y agoAs a desktop support person I have removed so many of this companies toolbars and adware over the years all I can say is thank you.
- imhoguy 6y agoThey own Ask.com adware? If yes then probably baning them from store may not do much as I think the extension is sideloaded in most cases, plus there is also search provider set as default. Back in the day Java runtime installer was spreading it at massive scale: https://images.techhive.com/images/article/2013/07/java-ask-toolbar-100047090-gallery.png https://images.techhive.com/images/article/2013/07/java-ask-...
- ripdog 6y agoSurely Chrome has the same protection that Firefox has against unattended sideloading of addons?
- hyperdimension 6y ago> Java runtime installer ...is how a little-known Google employee named Sundar Pichai rose to fame in the company by bundling Chrome.
- bisRepetita 6y agoIf the search/advertising and the browser businesses were independant, then making those decisions would be easier. Now, there may not be a browser business without a search/advertising one.