4 ms·
"Peak oil" is a term of art (sort of). It has a precise meaning, which is that as demand continues to increase, supply decreases sharply and suddenly, with very
by pc86 6y ago
"Peak oil" is a term of art (sort of). It has a precise meaning, which is that as demand continues to increase, supply decreases sharply and suddenly, with very little or almost no warning at all. Price explodes by several multiples more-or-less overnight. Demand hasn't increased, it's decreased. Supply hasn't decreased sharply. Neither condition was met.
"We don't need as much oil anymore because of a worldwide pandemic" is certainly an interesting development but we don't just get to call it "peak oil" so that people who were wrong 15 years ago can suddenly feel vindicated.
- undersuit 6y agoI don't know how you can say it has a precise meaning and then you define a meaning different than Wikipedia. Is it precise for you? "It is often confused with oil depletion; however, whereas depletion refers to a period of falling reserves and supply, peak oil refers to the point of maximum production."
- ben_w 6y agoSounds to me like one follows the other?
- mindslight 6y agoI agree this is how it was originally defined 15 years ago. But I feel sometime more recently (5-7?) it morphed into the idea that the price of renewables sets a cap on the price of extraction. So rather than the price of oil exploding, demand for it at its regular price point would fall. Now does a year of pandemic slowdown indicate an overarching trend? The article tries to make that point, but crises always bring out the prognosticators.
- undersuit 6y agoGotta disagree before Peak Oil was the buzzword it was Hubbert Peak Theory and his curves from the 1950s. And while it may not be 15 years ago, some of earliest edits to Peak Oil on Wikipedia from 2007 state: >the core of peak oil theory: peak oil does not mean that we will run out of oil, or even that we will cease to make major oil discoveries, but rather that we will be unable to maintain current levels of oil production. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Peak_oil&diff=992634609&oldid=127757546 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Peak_oil&diff=992...
- mindslight 6y agoYou didn't say anything that disagrees with what I said - I agree that is the original definition. I've just since heard the definition morph a bit into talking about the demand falling. You're free to argue that's an abuse of the term, but I'm just pointing out why there seems to be such a disagreement.
- undersuit 6y agoSorry I got the ordering of replies confused? If you agree with pc86, this is what the problem is: "It is often confused with oil depletion; however, whereas depletion refers to a period of falling reserves and supply, peak oil refers to the point of maximum production." We need to come to an agreement on the word peak oil? I'd rather use a written source, like the Wikipedia article mentioned way up this thread.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoThat sounds like "cliff oil" the threshold after which supply suddenly falls away.