4 ms·
For me the point at which DEC screwed up was in not embracing Unix+, around 1985. If they had done so, then there wouldn't have been a time when everyone had to
by dboreham 6y ago
For me the point at which DEC screwed up was in not embracing Unix+, around 1985. If they had done so, then there wouldn't have been a time when everyone had to buy Sun hardware to run Unix. There would instead have been a choice, and many DEC shops would never have converted to Sun. Commentators saying, as the article does, that it was all about the rise of the PC are wrong. PCs were useless toys at that time. Of course DEC may have done down later just as Sun did, in the X86-64 take over.
+I know: Ultrix, blah blah...but seriously no Ultrix wasn't embracing.
- nobody9999 6y agoIt goes back to well before 1985. In fact, Ken Olsen explained DEC's Unix "strategy" very clearly back in 1984: "One of the questions that comes up all the time is: How enthusiastic is our support for UNIX? Unix was written on our machines and for our machines many years ago. Today, much of UNIX being done is done on our machines. Ten percent of our VAXs are going for UNIX use. UNIX is a simple language, easy to understand, easy to get started with. It's great for students, great for somewhat casual users, and it's great for interchanging programs between different machines. And so, because of its popularity in these markets, we support it. We have good UNIX on VAX and good UNIX on PDP-11s. It is our belief, however, that serious professional users will run out of things they can do with UNIX. They'll want a real system and will end up doing VMS when they get to be serious about programming. With UNIX, if you're looking for something, you can easily and quickly check that small manual and find out that it's not there. With VMS, no matter what you look for -- it's literally a five-foot shelf of documentation -- if you look long enough it's there. That's the difference -- the beauty of UNIX is it's simple; and the beauty of VMS is that it's all there." -- Ken Olsen, president of DEC, DECWORLD Vol. 8 No. 5, 1984 And I can, in fact, verify that what Olsen said about five-foot shelves of manuals too. And VMS was (and OpenVMS still is) an impressive operating system, some features of which the Unix/Linux ecosystem is just gaining parity with. That said, It was commodity microcomputer hardware that doomed DEC, not it's faint hearted support for Unix, IMHO.
- dboreham 6y agoWe're literally _still_ fighting this battle between VMS and Unix. E.g. WSL2.
- Spooky23 6y agoHe was right... Enter Windows NT.
- icedchai 6y agoOne of the first multi-user systems I had access to was VMS. I'm still fond of it, and have an Alpha in my collection, running OpenVMS. And he's right. I remember working at a company that had a wall of VMS documentation. It was amazing.
- mtVessel 6y agoI worked in a VAX shop early on. We had an intern who was pushing Linux on us. He said to me, "Sure, VMS is great, but the downside is you need a wall of manuals." My reply was, "Downside? That's the UPSIDE! You can get an entire wall of manuals for it!" I still feel that way.
- ScottBurson 6y agoWow, what functionality did it have that took all those pages to document? Can you offer any examples of things it could do that Unix couldn't?
- icedchai 6y agoUltrix was lacking compared to SunOS. It only supported static binaries and needed more disk space as a result. Licensing was weird. Open source stuff didn't always "just work" and compile out of the box like it did on Suns. In the early 90's through the dot-com crash, everyone wanted Suns. Still, DEC did some awesome stuff... The Alpha was amazing. I worked at a mostly DEC shop for a while. They had a lot of VMS systems, but when it came to Unix, they went with Sun.
- DrScump 6y agoThey had real UNIX System V R2 (at least - R3, maybe?)) deployed by 1990 at the latest. GTE Mobilnet had their usage tracking running on whatever the biggest VAX was at the time. I had to fly to Bothell in August 1990 to diagnose a problem with Informix not playing nicely with DEC's bleeding-edge disk array controllers.