3 ms·
Counterpoint: smart TVs are great. My LG has replaced almost every other thing that used to be in my media room. It is my streaming music box (I can target it f
by jeffbee 6y ago
Counterpoint: smart TVs are great. My LG has replaced almost every other thing that used to be in my media room. It is my streaming music box (I can target it for casting from my favorite iOS app, and I can use the interface on it for browsing my home network storage if I want). It has Netflix, Amazon, YouTube, Hulu, Disney, Vudu, Google TV, and every other damn thing on it. It has voice search, so I just say the name of the show I want to watch and it finds and displays which apps have that in their catalog. It also has a web browser so I can just watch anything I want. I can start a video on YouTube on my phone and later transfer it to the TV (I can do this from either device). I can cast any tab from Chrome to my TV.
I say these TVs are just the right amount of smart. Maybe there are worse ones (I imagine, having once owned a Sony Playstation, that the software on a Sony TV is atrocious) but LG WebOS is brilliant.
- mszcz 6y agoSeconded on the LG WebOS. Hated smart/dumb TVs (Toshiba, Samsung, Sony) until I stumbled onto LG's WebOS. Speedy, works as expected, has most of the streaming apps. I thought the MagicRemote mouse thingy is going to be a gimmick but it's suprisingly nice to use. Oh, and the checkboxes to disable some of the spying are buried on an industry-standard level of assholeiness, so that's good.
- kgwxd 6y agoAt some point, most of those things are going to stop working but the screen will still be perfectly fine. What are you going to do with it then?
- mlyle 6y agoI don't know-- plug a $30 Chromecast or Roku into the back and keep going?
- jeffbee 6y agoSeriously this thing has four hdmi ports and even a composite video input. It is the superset of dumb TVs.
- kgwxd 6y agoExactly, and it will be just as easy to use. Why bother with the "convenience" in the first place? Why was all the time wasted designing and producing the built-in stuff in the first place? Why make more stuff to maintain for no gain? When the built-in stuff breaks it will either get in the way or stop the thing from working all together. Why? Just why? There has been no sane answer given to that simple question since this smart tv thing started.
- mlyle 6y agoYou need to have a moderately big processing complex to do various kinds of tasks in the TV anyways (scaling, HDMI negotiation, temporal interpolation, audio, etc). Decoding video is not any significant additional BOM cost (mostly just the network interface), and it is more convenient and nice for a significant fraction of users.... plus it allows the manufacturer access to additional revenue streams (e.g. getting some pennies for bundling Netflix).
- canofbars 6y agoMy samsung tv was connected to the internet which let it auto update and now the basic ui like volume changing is incredibly slow. Its super painful to just switch between hdmi devices.
- ouid 6y agoNo, this is a stupid point. You should always prefer a factored product, no pun intended. All of these "problems" are easily solved by buying a dumb tv and hooking a computer up to it. That way, if you ever need a TV without a computer hooked up to it, you can just separate them.
- jeffbee 6y agoYou've got the whole process the wrong way around. First you decide on the software that you want, and then you choose the hardware to run it. I want LG WebOS and there's only one platform on which it runs. Plugging some PC into the same panel without the software doesn't get me there. In fact, I'm sure it would be an endless mess suitable only for people whose time has no value.