6 ms·
Wow, that's crazy, it actually works -- just tried out the sample videos in QuickTime on my 2016 13" MBP (P3 gamut, running Big Sur) and confirmed working. Bas
by crazygringo 6y ago
Wow, that's crazy, it actually works -- just tried out the sample videos in QuickTime on my 2016 13" MBP (P3 gamut, running Big Sur) and confirmed working.
Basically: if I set my display to ~75% brightness and open the video, the whites in the video are 100% brightness, way brighter than #FFF interface white on the rest of my screen.
But if I increase my display brightness to 100%, the whites in the video are the same as the interface white, because it obviously can't go any brighter.
If I decrease my display brightness to 50%, the whites in the video are no longer at maximum 100% brightness, maybe more like 75%.
But it's also kind of buggy -- after messing around with system brightness a bit, the video stops being brighter and I've got to quit QuickTime and restart it again for effect. Also, opening and closing the video file makes my cursor disappear for a couple seconds!
I'm wondering if it switches from hardware dimming to software dimming when the video is opened and closed, and if that switch has to do with the cursor disappears. If it is, though it's flawlessly undetectable in terms of brightness -- the interface white and grays don't change at all.
Interestingly confirming it: taking a screenshot of the video while screen is at 75% brightness show massive brightness clipping in the video, since it's "overexposed" in the interface's color range. But taking a screenshot while screen brightness is 100% shows no clipping, because the video is no longer "overexposed" to the interface.
I'm just so surprised I had utterly no idea macOS worked like this. I'd never heard of this feature until now.
- Budabellly 6y agoIf you pop open Digital Color Meter app (macOS system util), are there any differences between the whites in the video and the #fff interface whites?
- dreamer7 6y agoJust tried this on my Macbook Pro. It was easier to just go to YouTube and search for HDR videos than downloading the sample in the article. Digital Color Meter shows both UI white and video white as exactly #fff despite the video white being much brighter! Even at full screen brightness, the video white was noticeably brighter
- cmroanirgo 6y agoFTA > The operating system is complicit in this trickery, so the Digital Color Meter eyedropper shows “white” as 255, as do screenshots.
- Budabellly 6y agoThanks, apologies for missing that. I wonder if other measurement tools (e.g. Adobe color picker) are also fooled by the OS in this case.
- Androider 6y ago> it's flawlessly undetectable in terms of brightness -- the interface white and grays don't change at all. In order to pull this off, you need to know exactly how many nits bright the display is, as well as having complete software control of the actual hardware brightness. On Windows, you have neither. Enabling HDR mode completely throws off your current colors and desktop brightness and you have to reset both your physical monitor settings and dial in the new desktop white point with a software slider Microsoft buried in the advanced HDR settings (that almost nobody knows how to use) to hopefully be somewhere in the vicinity of what you had before. When it comes to display technology, having vertical integration is a huge benefit. Look at high-DPI: state-of-art on Windows in 2020 is nowhere near as good from a software implementation or actual user experience point of view as it was on day 1 when Apple introduced Retina MacBooks back in 2012.
- tesseract 6y agoMac OS has also had system-wide color management and calibration (ColorSync) since the early 90s, part of its legacy of being the preferred platform for desktop publishing. On Windows the systemwide "color management" basically consists of assigning a default color profile that applications can choose to use - which is generally only done by professional design/photo/video software, and not by the desktop or most "normal" apps.
- antiterra 6y agoThe desktop and most windowed apps definitely do use the systemwide color management. The main issue in the past has been whether apps correctly remap image colors based on the image’s tagged (or lack of) profile. It was broken on Macs too but these days isn’t that much of an issue. (see the edited preface to https://cameratico.com/guides/web-browser-color-management-guide/ https://cameratico.com/guides/web-browser-color-management-g... )
- formerly_proven 6y agoWindows color management is pretty much just a folder where ICC files go to die. Everything needs to be done by the application. Nothing is color managed by default. This alone makes HDR displays (which aren't sRGB in HDR mode) less than worthless on Windows. The situation is identical on Linux, which copied the Windows approach.
- janci 6y agoI don't get it. Are they compressing the range of SDR display for SDR content so that HDR content can now use the full SDR range of SDR display? As in "we crippled your SDR display so that you can more enjoy the HDR content and buy an expensive HDR display to be back at the normal SDR range for SDR content"?
- crazygringo 6y agoNo, at least not on my Mac. Nothing's crippled, don't worry. If my screen is already at 100% brightness then there's no HDR effect. 100% brightness is true 100% brightness, the max capability of my backlight. The only difference is that if my screen is at less than 100% brightness, the HDR content can be brighter than the rest of the screen because it has the headroom. Does that make sense?
- no_op 6y agoOn conventional LCD displays you are presumably losing some contrast in SDR content here, because running the backlight brighter to allow for this will also elevate black. The rumor mill suggests Apple is planning a move to Mini-LED displays with thousands of local dimming zones, which would handily address this.
- janci 6y agoNot only contrast, but also the gamut. If display is capable of 255 levels of color and you remap 255 to e.g. 128 to leave the rest for HDR you have only half of the possible colors available for SDR. Or how is this supposed to work?
- no_op 6y agoThe feature only works on P3 displays, so gamut when displaying UI (which I'd assume is nominally within the smaller sRGB space) likely isn't an issue. Also, per later comments, this feature only kicks in when you're actually viewing SDR content, so there's no downside (even contrast) in everyday use.
- atlantis_ 6y agoAm I missing something? The innovation is to ... dim LEDs so that full brightness is... more than 100%... https://youtu.be/4xgx4k83zzc https://youtu.be/4xgx4k83zzc
- tambourine_man 6y agoYou can dim the whole OS expect the video being played. This can’t be done anywhere else at this point. That video can have a very bright sky, for instance. You can have a bright sky and a blinding text box or neither in other OSs. It’s also a very bright display in its own right, with 1600 nits vs the 300-400 of a regular one. And 1,000,000:1 contrast as well.
- brianpan 6y agoHDR specifies a brightness. Apple is playing HDR videos at the proper brightness when the rest of the OS might be turned down. https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/08/03/what-hdr-hdr10-and-displayhdr-are-and-what-they-mean-to-apple-users https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/08/03/what-hdr-hdr10-an... That plus P3 gamut means a video playing on a display is closer to what a filmmaker intended. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DCI-P3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DCI-P3 What's cool is: 1) 4-year old Macs have become HDR laptops and 2) the implementation is subtle- you get full brightness in the HDR video without having the rest of the UI blast to full brightness.
- sp332 6y agoInteresting, the article says that screenshots look fine. Are you using a third-party capture tool?
- grishka 6y agoSo is this the reason why they removed the glowing apple on newer macbooks? Since it was powered by the backlight, it'd give that trick away real quick.
- Mayzie 6y agoThey removed it because the screens were getting too thin, and in bright conditions you could start to see through it - leaving a brighter blob in the middle.
- jiggawatts 6y agoI have a Dell UP2414Q, which is a wide-gamut 4K monitor with a relatively high 375 nits peak brightness and 10-bit input. It's not technically HDR, but if I view HDR videos with it in SDR mode with the brightness turned up to maximum, there is definitely a bit of an "HDR effect", similar to what Apple has achieved. However, under Windows, without support from the operating system, this doesn't really work. The colours are shifted and the brightness of the content is way too low. Microsoft could add something similar, but this is a company that thinks that colour is a feature in the sense of: Colour: Yes. We're approaching 2021 rapidly. I suspect we'll have to wait to 2030 before Microsoft gets its act together and copies even half of what Apple has in their display technology now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]