5 ms·
That would essentially force people to buy two devices - one for receiving content to display and a second to display it. All your solution does is shift the pr
by onion2k 6y ago
That would essentially force people to buy two devices - one for receiving content to display and a second to display it. All your solution does is shift the problem on to the receiving device. It wouldn't fix anything, and at the same time it'd increase the cost and complexity for the user (by a very small amount admittedly).
- nitrogen 6y agoDecoupling allows competition and places control in the hands of the user.
- bootlooped 6y agoDidn't the user already exercise their control by choosing to buy a smart TV? And I don't think many people would say there is a lack of competition between TV manufacturers.
- nitrogen 6y agoAs is constantly brought up in these threads, there is often no dumb TV option available with higher end panels, and all of the TV vendors are incentivized to be equally evil.
- bootlooped 6y agoI just don't think it's an issue for the majority of consumers. If you went up to random people on the street and ask whether they would rather have a smart TV or non-smart TV, I think mostly you would get dumbfounded looks of "of course I want the one with more features built-in".
- nitrogen 6y agoBecause that's a manipulative question. The true question is "Would you rather have a TV that spies on you, runs slow, stops working after a few years, and sends pictures of everything you watch to some other country, or a TV that does none of those things and lasts 10+ years?"
- bootlooped 6y agoHow is it manipulative? "Smart TV or non-smart TV" is the most vanilla, agnostic way I can think of to ask the question. Once you start adding pros and cons you muddy the whole thing, and all the pros and cons you have added conveniently lead to your preferred answer. Don't you think it's more manipulative to build a one-sided argument into the question?
- chrisrhoden 6y agoYes, but the argument goes that someone selling a device specifically for receiving content may see you as a customer of that service primarily, rather than as a means to subsidize the cost of the display or device. Not sure how that plays out in practice, but not a distinction without a difference.
- kzrdude 6y agoBut the media box device can be replaced more readily.
- ponker 6y agoThe second device can be as cheap as $17 known as a “Streaming Stick” and treated as a throwaway component.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bo1024 6y agoYes, and there are a lot of good reasons for that! The two functions become obsolete at different rates, and people have different needs for each of them, so it's the right place to put an abstraction layer. When I buy a computer monitor, I can pair it with any computer I want. I can upgrade the graphics card or processor independently of the monitor. I'm not locked in to a particular computer based on the features of the monitor I want. TVs should be the same. It could be as simple as a USB stick you plug in the back.
- slg 6y ago>The two functions become obsolete at different rates The implication here is that the connectivity tech goes obsolete quicker than screen tech. That has traditionally been true, but has it been over the last 5 years or so? We don't even have to get into the specific display technology. Just from a feature perspective, there has been a lot of innovation in screens including 4k, HDR, and high refresh rates.
- hakfoo 6y agoAnd the dominant broadcast standards are still 1080i 60Hz with no extra dynamic range. A large amount of new content is still targeting that. Aside from over-the-air, I suspect that most cable/satellite operators are offering that service level, at least without premium fees. Since the end of the digital-TV transition, the TV industry has been throwing a lot of stuff at the wall trying to find something that stuck. There's no clear "it becomes a paperweight" factor to make us all go out and replace newish sets right now. Remember the 3D TV trend? Or the year when everyone brought out curved sets, and then went back to flat? Smart TVs are another variation on that theme, with the added benefit for manufacturers that their lowest-bid tech and changing third-party service requirements will leave you with a set where half the hard-coded service buttons don't work and the other half are unusably slow to depress you into buying a new set in three years. I expect the next real ecosystem change will be when ATSC 3.0 becomes a workable thing. Then you'll actually be able to offer 4K/HDR with an array of content without the caveat of "external game console/PC/streaming service required." I'd be a bit hesitant to get a new set until then just out of the risk you ended up with something not fully compliant (I'm thinking of those first-gen 4K LCDs that wouldn't accept a 60Hz input)
- ouid 6y agoOK, here's how you make a smart TV, essentially. Take a dumb tv with some ports attached to it, plug a chromecast into one of the ports, and then pour epoxy over the whole thing. Your argument is that this adds value to the chromecast dumb tv pair, despite being a fundamentally destructive operation.