3 ms·
This is true. And the research raised an important point which was worth discussing. But it seems, based on the totality of the information, that Google receive
by rayiner 6y ago
This is true. And the research raised an important point which was worth discussing. But it seems, based on the totality of the information, that Google received an ultimatum demanding that it take particular action with respect to the issue. That’s going beyond an ethics researcher’s role.
- kenjackson 6y agoThe ultimatum was about the review process and not the paper per se. I do think the ultimatum was a bad idea, but I don’t think I’d fire an employee over one. Id just tell them no, on their demand. That said a blind internal review process that apparently blocked a paper for the first time in Googles history probably deserves more explanation than simply “we will take your resignation”.
- sontek 6y agoThey didn't fire her. She said "I will quit if you don't meet these demands" and they were unwilling to meet the demands. If she didn't threaten to quit, I can't imagine they would've done anything other than tell her no. But she gave them an ultimatum and they chose which side they would be on.