11 ms·
I'm less cynical about this as a concept. Would you feel differently if, say, Apple hired a "Privacy Watchdog", with a long history of activism on the topic? S
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
I'm less cynical about this as a concept.
Would you feel differently if, say, Apple hired a "Privacy Watchdog", with a long history of activism on the topic? Someone you could trust to speak out if something was amiss.
If the person is later fired, that's a sign that something is wrong at the company. But if they stay, and have generally good things to say, that's a sign the company can be trusted.
I do think this is a good system!
- ghaff 6y agoIt's a difficult type of role. See the NYT getting rid of its public editor/ombudsman.[1] I'd actually have trouble seeing Apple hiring someone like that given how tightly they control external messaging/speaking/etc. It's really hard for execs, including but not limited to PR, to have worked really hard on getting some message/narrative accepted by the media/analysts/etc. and then have a high profile employee on social media or in a major publication saying it's sort of B.S. even as an occasional thing. ADDED: It doesn't make it "right" for them to storm into their boss' office and demand said person be fired but it is at least an understandable human reaction. I think anyone who takes that kind of role has to understand they'll be a lightning rod, feel passionate about it anyway, and understand they may well eventually set off a tripwire and be fired in a very public and humiliating way. [1] https://www.thedailybeast.com/why-the-new-york-times-fired-its-public-editor-in-favor-of-a-reader-center https://www.thedailybeast.com/why-the-new-york-times-fired-i...
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> I think anyone who takes that kind of role has to understand they'll be a lightning rod, feel passionate about it anyway, and understand they may well eventually set off a tripwire and be fired in a very public and humiliating way. Oh, absolutely—that’s practically a part of their job description!
- derbOac 6y agoAnd yet here everyone is, discussing whether or not Google is secretly racist, with protest petitions involving 1000s of signatures. I had never heard of the name of Gebru before but now I have. I'm not meaning to take sides here, and I think what you're saying needs to be kept in mind in understanding this, but it's hard for me personally at least to not see this in terms of some diversity-speech Streisand effect.
- albntomat0 6y agoI think that works if there's a clear way to distinguish the hypothetical privacy watchdog leaving/getting fired due to issues with the privacy program, versus leaving/getting fired for other reasons. Making that distinction, imo, seems to be the core disagreement with the current Google issue, at least among all of us commenting on the outside.
- zepto 6y agoIt seems like that is always going to be a problem, since if the person is getting fired critiquing the thing they are there to critique, the company will always have a huge incentive to present another explanation.
- albntomat0 6y agoI think we agree on the difficulty here. I believe the reverse is also true: if the person is fired for a legitimate, non-watchdog reason, they have an incentive to say the firing was due to them bring up privacy/ethics concerns.
- chishaku 6y agobelieve Google vs believe a solitary worker (female, black, known political agenda)
- alisonkisk 6y agoWhat's your point? Jeff Dean is a solitary worker (male, white, known political agenda).
- pinewurst 6y agoWhat is his political agenda then, if you know it? (Possession/absence of Y chromosome/melanin does not constitute such.)
- stjohnswarts 6y agoThis is probably like hiring the EFF (by Apple) to help with privacy ethics, it is 100% guaranteed that they'd be fired in time :) . EFF are idealists, Apple is a pragmatist, so eventually they would part ways, it's inevitable. Hopefully google and she both learned something from it.