3 ms·
> Eliminating 230 doesn’t eliminate free speech, it eliminates centralized socialization. How is it any less eliminative for decentralized services? If you hav
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Eliminating 230 doesn’t eliminate free speech, it eliminates centralized socialization.
How is it any less eliminative for decentralized services? If you have a private moderated forum (e.g. HN), or even a small one with only 5000 users, that's still more than enough to attract spam and trolls. So the small forum operator deletes the spam and the trolling.
If that makes them responsible for everything everybody says on that forum, first of all, they're screwed. People will post some liability-inducing material while the forum operator is on vacation and they'll get thrown in jail for hosting it. Small forum operators don't have the resources or the risk tolerance to put up with that, so they'll fold, and leave the huge centralized ones to pick up their user base.
Worse, to avoid the liability the ones that remain will over-censor. We already see this with the DMCA. Even transparently fraudulent takedowns are typically executed anyway because it's not worth the risk if you're wrong or the resources of proving you're right. Web forums aren't courts; they aren't a valid entity to be making complex lawful speech determinations in an accurate way, and they won't, so instead they'll do something despicable.
But you also can't use forums that don't moderate at all, because they're immediately overrun with spam and trolls.
The actual problem with these centralized entities is not that they do moderation. It's that they're centralized. Break them up.
- 0x445442 6y ago> How is it any less eliminative for decentralized services? Not speaking for the parent here but I think you called out a distinction; private. There's a difference between running a private, not for profit, Mastadon node where anyone who signs up presumably knows what the forum is about versus Twitter who pitched their company to investors as merely a platform for people to tweet. Nobody is upset with Twitter moderating content that violates existing Federal Law, but they were never meant to be a moderating like a Mastadon node on the private side or even like a sub reddit on the public side. Again, looking at Reddit, most don't have an issue with moderated content on the sub reddit, the issue is when Reddit removes entire sub reddits because THEY don't agree with the content. BTW, I think Justice Thomas' recent remarks have made Twitter and Facebook take note because he hinted that the misrepresentation to investors was the attack vector, not the 1st Amendment.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Not speaking for the parent here but I think you called out a distinction; private. In this context "private" just means privately operated. A Mastadon node is still publicly available. But I can kind of see the distinction you're getting at, and it's especially clear with Reddit. If you have a sub which is moderated by the users, there is no longer any call for the corporation to do any moderation whatsoever, because it's already being handled in a decentralized fashion (each sub has its own independent moderators). You don't need the corporation itself to do any moderation at all, and so anything they do there is unnecessary and unwelcome. The question is how to draw that line. You essentially want decentralized moderation even when there is centralized hosting. How does that look when you apply it to e.g. Facebook?
- cwhiz 6y ago> How is it any less eliminative for decentralized services? If you have a private moderated forum (e.g. HN), or even a small one with only 5000 users, that's still more than enough to attract spam and trolls. So the small forum operator deletes the spam and the trolling. That’s not decentralized. That’s just small. With decentralized services there is no entity to sue. It would be like trying to sue a torrent. You can’t. Imagine Chase Bank vs Bitcoin. If you want to se Chase Bank, you can. If you want to sue Bitcoin you go pound sand.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhat is the analogy supposed to be for the moderators then? You have a decentralized service, hosted on IPFS or something. You can't sue the service, but that was never the issue. Nobody is calling for liability on AWS for hosting a forum moderated by somebody else. It's the moderators that Section 230 is protecting. And even if you use decentralized hosting, to have moderation the moderators still have to exist, do they not?
- Isinlor 6y agoThere is always an entity to sue, because legal and organized business activity is taxed and requires legal entities. If you hide your commercial activity from taxation, you will be dealing with law enforcement sooner or later, depending on scale. For example, I can sue all companies that make operation of Bitcoin possible, including exchanges, miners, individual and organized Bitcoin users. So, to repeat: Technical implementation details are irrelevant because legal business happens between legal entities.