3 ms·
I'm reminded of the library of babel: an "infinite" library of every combination of characters. To write a book, all you have you do is "write" a book is find t
by jedimastert 6y ago
I'm reminded of the library of babel: an "infinite" library of every combination of characters. To write a book, all you have you do is "write" a book is find the correct one, already sitting on the shelf.
If you consider that basically any opinion on a subject is recorded somewhere on YouTube, then YouTube doesn't have to "write" a thing. If they wanted to make a statement, all they have to do is sort the right thing to the top.
I personally agree with section 230, but there's a fine line between curation and moderation, and it's difficult to square with the scale of the internet. There are approximately 500 hours of video uploaded every minute on YouTube. That's 30,000 every hour, or 720,000 hours every day. No matter how infinite YouTube's resources might be, there is simply no way to human moderate all of it.
Do I think YouTube is toe-ing the line between moderation and curation effectively? Honestly, no. For myself, maybe, but not for the internet as a whole. But I don't think removing section 230 is the way to fix it.
- tertius 6y ago30,000 hours of video per hour. That's not that much. We can do a lot with speech to text as a starting point. And you can easily detect if speech to text isn't working very well. And for those that are graphic you can do image detection. It's not out of reach.
- jedimastert 6y ago> We can do a lot with speech to text as a starting point. And you can easily detect if speech to text isn't working very well. > And for those that are graphic you can do image detection. It's not out of reach. YouTube does both of those things already. How well is it working out? Honestly, surprisingly well. But many, probably most, would argue not nearly enough, especially if you're legally liable for every frame of that video
- tertius 6y agoI'm just arguing that it's not as big of a problem as some make it seem.