3 ms·
Under this definition, presumably a house flipper doing all their own decorating would be petit bourgeois (applying their own labor to their own capital), while
by michaelt 6y ago
Under this definition, presumably a house flipper doing all their own decorating would be petit bourgeois (applying their own labor to their own capital), while a senior manager earning $500,000/year at Google would be proleteriat (selling their labor for wages)?
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Under this definition, presumably a house flipper doing all their own decorating would be petit bourgeois In the economic analysis on which the traditional class distinctions are based, the homes owned transitorily by a flipper would seem to be (well, aside from the land component, which is also not capital) a very expensive raw material, not really capital (they aren't tools used in the course of producing goods for sale.) So this is certainly a point where there could be different opinions, but, sure, that's probably arguably correct. > while a senior manager earning $500,000/year at Google would be proleteriat (selling their labor for wages)? A senior manager earning $500,000/yr at Google is likely investing quite a bit of that, and likely has been during the series of highly-paid jobs they had prior to becoming a senior manager, and very often would fit the alternate petit bourgeois pattern discussed in the parenthetical in GP, where a significant fraction of their gains are from ownership (indirectly through financial instruments) of capital, though they also have significant income from selling labor. But, sure, it's possible for them to just be a highly paid member of the proletarian intelligentsia.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoSomeone making $500k/year at Google probably also gets a healthy chunk of Google stock.