5 ms·
It’s not just the U.S. A problem report once lead me to discover that the Spanish company Telefónica cached DNS results for years longer than the TTL. My error
by acdha 6y ago
It’s not just the U.S. A problem report once lead me to discover that the Spanish company Telefónica cached DNS results for years longer than the TTL. My error monitoring also picked up content injection (prior to HTTPS) and DNS hijacking around the world.
Before going with the conspiratorial take note that Mozilla shipped DoH early and both Microsoft and Apple implemented it. Untrustworthy ISPs are a real problem even if Google deservedly gets suspicion about their motives. This isn’t another AMP.
- syshum 6y agoAt this point Mozilla is just the Non-profit Arm of Google, They do what google tells them.... and DoH is absolutely designed to get around network based security and filtering, both for Ad's and other reasons.
- acdha 6y ago> At this point Mozilla is just the Non-profit Arm of Google, They do what google tells them You can just say you don’t follow this closely. Mozilla is not perfect but they do push for privacy, with an increasingly limited amount of negotiating power. > DoH is absolutely designed to get around network based security and filtering, both for Ad's and other reasons. This is similarly reflecting a poor understanding of the situation. DoH can’t get around network filtering - if you block packets, there’s no magic trick to bypass it. It’s great for preventing ISPs from tampering with traffic or monitoring activity (this will also require eSNI to complete) but it’s not giving an attacker any capability they didn’t already have. If you’re concerned about security you’re fooling yourself if you don’t have endpoint management and some level of network segmentation and egress control. Attackers have hard-coded DNS servers, C&C endpoints, etc. for decades.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoDoH absolutely can get network filtering: if I block port 53 outbound to control DNS queries within my network, DoH (and other tunneling technologies) is bypassing my network filtering of DNS.
- shawnz 6y agoBy the same logic HTTPS is bypassing your network filtering of every service which happens to have an alternative available over HTTPS. So do you block HTTPS?
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoI’ve been thinking about installing a proxy with my own root for this reason.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shawnz 6y agoI would not want to use your network if that was the case, and I wonder if you similarly would use someone else's network if it was configured like that. I don't think network operators who provide access to the Internet can realistically expect to control what their users do on the Internet, unless the network operator is also the administrator of those workstations.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoMaybe, but my rule is: my home network, my rules. I can’t really do this invisibly anyways: any device I don’t control will get certificate validation errors.
- syshum 6y agoThe problem here is even the device owner is not the "administrator" of the device as we have lost ownership rights, locked behind EULA's, Patents and copyright The point of the original story is "your" meaning a device you own, is ignoring your network controls it is highly unlikely that the TV manufacturer is going to allow me to install my own custom root certs to inspect their traffic to HTTPS, so yes DoH and other things are a threat to network security, because if the TV become compromised I have limited administrative controls to prevent it other the blocking it completely which is a poor response to the problem DoH is a solution in search of a problem that can be solves in better more user friendly ways
- mindslight 6y agoYour technical description doesn't really respond to the meat of the critique of DoH, which is that it prevents the technique described in this article - transparent proxying for all traffic of a certain service, in this case DNS. The problem is that your relationship with your network devices is logically the same as a totalitarian country's/company's relationship with their citizens/users. So any protocol that prevents censorship/surveillance by ISPs also impinges upon bona fide network administrators. Corporate networks have the same dynamic, although there are few tears shed when it becomes harder for them to tamper with users' traffic. The right answer is to make sure devices that have any Internet access run code you control. The root of the problem here is buying a "smart" TV, hooking it up to the network, and then expecting to tame all of its user-hostile anti-features by policing its communication. The only way to use black box IoT devices is to remove all general Internet access from them, allowing communication only with hosts you do control. For instance I've got a network of tp-link bulbs that are all controlled from a Home Assistant instance, and they never have and never will get a packet out to the larger Internet.
- acdha 6y agoMy point was simply that DNS was never an effective measure. Corporate operators don’t need it since they can configure proxies and install endpoint monitoring, but the people building untrustworthy IoT devices or malware can’t be relied upon to cooperate. I agree that the core problem here is blocking egress entirely – and that’d be a good area for home routers to add UI polish so you could easily allow your TV to hit Samsung.com if there’s an update you need before turning it back off. Unfortunately that’s going to be a losing game for many devices and that really hits at the root cause: we need strong regulation controlling privacy because trying to stop a well-funded company with purely technical measures is almost always a losing game.
- mindslight 6y agoWell DNS has been a pragmatic measure for quite some time. I've definitely seen jailbreaks of embedded devices that start off by MITMing DNS to proxy all traffic. DoH is changing that, and I can see how that's annoying. > hit Samsung.com if there’s an update you need Why would you need an update? Updates are mainly necessary for security, which you don't need if the device isn't on the Internet. If the device doesn't have all the features you expect out of the box, return it within the return period. There's a small corner case where an update could carry significantly increased functionality, but it seems easier to ad-hoc address that down the line rather than plan for it. Carelessly doing updates is a good way to break your device. > Unfortunately that’s going to be a losing game for many devices I don't see how it's a losing game if you play it correctly. Fine grained policing of types of traffic is a losing game, but wholesale denying transit isn't. There is little difference between my network of tp-link bulbs and a local modbus network.
- hackerfromthefu 6y agoDenial is not just a river in Egypt Follow the money .. watch the actions not the words
- acdha 6y agoYou mean actions like the Mozilla engineers advocating for users in standards groups or industry coordinating teams? Or the ones building privacy-oriented features? You’re going to have to make a more substantial argument to get anywhere with this.
- skinkestek 6y ago> At this point Mozilla is just the Non-profit Arm of Google, They do what google tells them.... As someone who has used (and still use Firefox) continously since around 2005 it surely feels that way sometimes and some of the decisions I see would make much more sense to me if I knew top management was somehow in Googles pocket. (That said 1. for my workflows I still consider Firefox the best browser. 2. switching would only make it even easier for Google. 3. I always hope something will change and Firefox will become really really great again or someone will fork it.
- inetknght 6y ago> some of the decisions I see would make much more sense to me if I knew top management was somehow in Googles pocket. Consider. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation#Google https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation#Google [1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/15/21370020/mozilla-google-firefox-search-engine-browser https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/15/21370020/mozilla-google-f...
- wolco2 6y agoThey are in google pockets for 95% of revenue. But I think as a browser with a smaller market they join things and change things to be like everyone else. There was a recent change to facebook picture albums that lazily loads pictures as you scroll. In large albums this grinds to a halt after a few pages and each scroll takes 30 seconds to load the next set of images. Chrome handles this smoothly. For social media I had to switch to chrome. Firefox is still better for privacy and I use it when I can even though it feels like it's slowing down after each upgrade.
- 153791098c 6y ago> 3. I always hope something will change and Firefox will become really really great again or someone will fork it. Abrowser (from trisquel) is what firefox should have been. Best fork out there imo.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. Of which I presume you have lots to share with the HN community?
- will_pseudonym 6y agoFor anyone else not in the know, "DoH" means "DNS-over-HTTPS" Here's an article from November 19, 2020 about the rollout and some of the criticisms/backlash: https://www.zdnet.com/article/fearing-drama-mozilla-opens-public-consultation-before-worldwide-firefox-doh-rollout/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/fearing-drama-mozilla-opens-pu...
- topranks 6y agoCan you link to the results of your study?