4 ms·
The problem with Section 230 is that nasty social media companies can use algorithms to curate the content the user sees (often without their knowledge and agai
by Nextgrid 6y ago
The problem with Section 230 is that nasty social media companies can use algorithms to curate the content the user sees (often without their knowledge and against their choice) in order to increase engagement & profit off it (including from content that is illegal or promotes illegal activities) but then use Section 230 as an excuse to get away with zero liability.
Maybe S230 should be amended so that once you start curating the information and/or profiting off it, you become a publisher and lose S230 protection?
- withPurpose9973 6y agoBook publishers and magazines aren’t held to a very serious standard these days. This isn’t the UK; free speech in the US is number 1. It’s far more fundamental than any legislation will fix. America is built on aristocratic protectionism like every other nation. Things like the Constitution allowing for copyright protection for a limited time is made effectively forever given the perspective of an average human life span. It will always end up being gamed. Personally, I’m tuning out more from consumerism and “the tech industry”. Even before covid I’d grown sick of what became circular debates over big O and comp sci 101 in tech, and routine office life. I’m learning musical instruments and writing creatively. Ditched my TV. Things like 230 are useful for big tech Corp. Not me. Let them defend it. I’m not interested in performing unpaid political lobbying for them.
- gumby 6y ago> Things like 230 are useful for big tech Corp. Actually that part of the law protects comment sections in personal blogs: you aren't liable for any comments left on your posts and spam fighting or highlighting etc (or not) of posts doesn't magically transform them into statements of yours. Spammers have reduced the value of comments on blog posts but they are still important.
- withPurpose9973 6y agoWho cares? Encrypt your message and distribute it to interested parties. You know what I’ve learned online? Human beings do human being stuff. golf clap Society doesn’t need to protect a particular form of distribution of expression. Just your freedom to express.
- pavlov 6y ago> “Things like 230 are useful for big tech Corp. Not me.” You’re writing this on a site that’s protected by Section 230. It’s useful for everyone, from the smallest blog to FB, that lets user-generated content through without premoderation. Repealing this law would mean a web with a lot more moderation, not less.
- withPurpose9973 6y agoDo not dare suppose you know where others should find value. Your subjective feelings as 1 in 7 billion are not universal truth. Why are real world laws around moderation ok but online should be different? Does that communication not have a real world effect? Yet another human pipe dream fed to the masses to empower corporations, rile the public up about government interference (never mind laws enable tech corp meddling in our lives; cognitive dissonance among smart people is a thing). And now you’re doing free political lobbying. Understand, my freedom of speech is intact without the web. Probably even more so without technology watching me at work and home. For what? Turning my lights on and off with my voice? ML applied to science and engineering are one thing. Filtering people with rough edge incomplete statistical tools (described as such by experts) is just awful on the surface of it. Pretty sure what’s good for social stability is not giving up our agency to nation state political demands. Believing that society is too big to fail. Seems every time societies do that they die. The more people it pushes aside the less internal support it has. So respectfully, I disagree.
- monsieurgaufre 6y agoYou're a publisher as soon as you put an infrastructure for users to put stuff on the net. Curating or not doesn't matter. Disclosure: personal opinion, ianal.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIn this case would you consider the telephone company a publisher too?
- monsieurgaufre 6y agoNo. I can't publish stuff on their website. They "sell" me the use of the "pipes", not what i do with it.
- tertius 6y agoIn one sense yes, but not the one that matters here.
- monsieurgaufre 6y agoAs i said, ianal and it's my own personal opinion. Others here have better expressed my views on the subject. Disruption is not always a good thing. Especially when it has large societal impacts.
- tzs 6y agoSo if I want to run a chess forum, and I remove non-chess posts, I should lose S230 protection?
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoAdd a minimum user number. Say 100k or an arbitrary threshold of substantive complaints. Either you'll be able to afford the traumatized drones in chairs, need to fundraise or get outside help. Fine solution in my book.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoWhat you're really suggesting is that moderated forums with more than 100k users and controlled by a single entity should be de facto prohibited. But then it really has very little to do with Section 230 and you might as well just call it what it is -- antitrust.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoNo, that's your assumption. A company should deal with the problems they create. They could reduce their user base, get crushed by lawsuits and regulations resulting from their reckless endangerment, gross negligence, incompetence, and/or unfettered greed. There's Also the American option of buying politicians and legislation but that's a short sighted and ethically bankrupt decision.
- 0x445442 6y agoNot a great example. The forum's purpose is so narrow and well defined that most would not care about the moderation, even if it were for profit.
- rrss 6y agoSeems like it starts to get weird if your forum gets millions of chess posts each day, and you pick the posts like "this global conspiracy is why the deep state is trying to ban chess," "how i saved my life by defeating a axe-murdering grandmaster (he is coming for your children too!)," "the 100 sexiest chess players," for the first page of your forum because those stories drive engagement and get you more clicks, and banish the other forum posts to page 103173.
- Iv 6y agoThis is not a problem with S 230 in my opinion. All these calls to order tech giants to promote specific views (even though I tend to agree with most) are extremely dangerous. I don't remember who was pointing that this all basically forced Google to have a "state department" and a foreign policy. Same with Facebook. Personally I am of the radical opinion that the source of all this evil is advertisement. I'd simply forbid it. Advertisement is the reason why social media try to increase engagement. It uses advanced manipulation techniques and recent psychological research. The net would cost people 2 more dollars per month but would be a much saner place without advertisement.