4 ms·
The motivation is to know the truth and to focus on interventions that can help. Note this study gives us no information on whether taking vit D before you bec
by Herodotus38 6y ago
The motivation is to know the truth and to focus on interventions that can help. Note this study gives us no information on whether taking vit D before you become sick helps or not, it cannot answer that. I think there is very low risk of taking a Vit D supplement.
What it does do is give doctors more confidence that making patients take another pill when they are already sick in the hospital won't do anything to help them. This saves unnecessary costs, possible side effects (albeit high dose Vit D is still relatively harmless), and patient comfort (when you are as short of breath as some severe covid patients even taking pills and eating can be a challenge).
There are many supplements that people very strongly believe help covid without good evidence beside vitamin D, why shouldn't we take all of them all the time? There are people and doctors who are passionate about the potential benefits in covid for: ivermectin, Vit C, Vit D, Zinc, famotidine (AKA Zantac) and hydroxychloroquine.
At some point we have to actually look at the data.
- emerged 6y agoThe affect of the title seems to encourage dropping your daily dose of vitamin d, even though as you say it doesn’t conclude that is the best advice. Maybe my criticism is subtle but it seems important.
- ac29 6y agoThe title states no result or conclusion. The actual conclusion might discourage people who decided to supplement that it has no effect (and indeed it may not), but it doesnt comment on that either, merely stating: "Vitamin D3 supplementation does not confer therapeutic benefits among hospitalized patients with severe COVID-19" (emphasis mine).