4 ms·
(Having not read any of this). Isn't Google committed to be net carbon neutral/negative? If so, does the claimed extra electricity usage matter?
by xnx 6y ago
(Having not read any of this). Isn't Google committed to be net carbon neutral/negative? If so, does the claimed extra electricity usage matter?
- nullc 6y agoSeems so: https://sustainability.google/commitments/ https://sustainability.google/commitments/
- xiphias2 6y agoThe paper should have been probably focused on the title only, because the CO2 usage looks like a publicity stunt. She also didn't subtract the amount of CO2 saved by improved productivity by getting better search results.
- ardit33 6y agoYep, it feels very disingenuous.... It is like someone complaining that google map uses x, amount of energy, yet the old alternative (printing maps, and getting lost) was much worse CO2 wise.
- lern_too_spel 6y agoDoes OpenAI? Does the rest of the industry? Everybody is training larger and larger models, with research groups competing on who will be the first to scale up to some number of parameters. It seems obvious that this would be something an ethicist would be interested in researching to figure out what the impact will be and start discussions about how to offset it.
- CydeWeys 6y agoGoogle isn't the only player in the AI field. The paper is about the entire field in general, not just what Google is doing. And plenty of the other companies in the field have not made similar pledges. The total amount of electricity being used so far for training models does not yet move the needle in a significant way, but the point of the paper is that it's currently growing in an unbounded exponential fashion. And you know how exponential functions work.