4 ms·
One of the studies found that only 5% of the athletes they studied were only children. That presumably means 95% of the athletes had siblings. Using 1999 data
by tzs 6y ago
One of the studies found that only 5% of the athletes they studied were only children. That presumably means 95% of the athletes had siblings.
Using 1999 data [1], 52% of US families had no children, 20% had one child, 18% had two children, 7% had 3 children, and 3% had 4 or more children.
That means that of children who had siblings in 1999, at least 59% had at least one older sibling, and at most 41% were the oldest sibling. If position within multi-sibling families was independent of chances of becoming a great athlete, we would expect great athletes to be more likely to be younger siblings simply because there are more younger siblings.
If we toss only children athletes in with the oldest child athletes from multi-child families, it doesn't make much difference because with only 5% of athletes being only children there simply aren't enough to tip the balance. It only brings it down to 56% have at least one older sibling, 44% do not have an older sibling.
This suggests that a better question would be "Why are only children less likely to become great athletes?"
[1] https://aspe.hhs.gov/report/trends-well-being-americas-children-and-youth-2000/pf-21-percentage-families-children-and-distribution-families-number-children https://aspe.hhs.gov/report/trends-well-being-americas-child...
- hatmatrix 6y agoIn the study mentioned in original article seems to account for this by comparing elite and near-elite athletes, and having found they had the same number of siblings. "On average, the two groups had the same number of total siblings. What mattered was whether those siblings were younger or older. The elite athletes had 1.04 older siblings on average; nonelite athletes had only 0.61." I think this ratio is greater than what you find in the general population analysis.
- 3np 6y agoAn observation is that single-child families are correlated with higher academic level as well as higher socioeconomic level. I wonder if that's a major part of the reason or if there are other more significant factors.
- violetgarden 6y agoAs an only child, my guess would be because I had no one to play with. Even if you have friends, siblings are far more accessible to go out and do something sporty with. In fact, your parents might even be telling the lot of you to go play.
- im3w1l 6y ago> Using 1999 data [1], 52% of US families had no children, 20% had one child, 18% had two children, 7% had 3 children, and 3% had 4 or more children. 52% no children made do a double take and I'm glad I did. I think the issue with your calculation is that some of the families will eventually have more children than they did at the time of measurement. So number of children is biased downwards.