5 ms·
The real details are buried in the article. Dealerships were required to either spend at least $200K on charging stations and other upgrades, or they could take
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
The real details are buried in the article. Dealerships were required to either spend at least $200K on charging stations and other upgrades, or they could take a buyout offer for $300K to $1 million.
About 17% of total dealerships took the deal. I assume many of those were already declining and chose the convenient exit option instead of doubling down on their already declining dealership investment in the middle of a pandemic.
> The buyout offers ranged from around $300,000 to more than $1 million, the people familiar with the effort added. About 17% of Cadillac’s 880 U.S. dealerships agreed to take the offer to end their franchise agreements for the luxury brand
- santiagobasulto 6y agoThis is why I read the comments first. Thanks for doing my homework.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- NullPrefix 6y agoOnce there's enough comments reading the actual article becomes pointless
- ngcc_hk 6y agoWow, that is what most of us do in good sites like HN. The signal to noise level is way beyond normal. Thanks all.
- exabrial 6y agoThat doesn't really make a good headline
- VectorLock 6y agoUsing dealerships to build a charging network is a nice idea. The knock on benefit of getting car owners to your dealership more frequently and hopefully selling more cars.
- thatfrenchguy 6y agoThey’re probably level 2 chargers so that when you buy the car, it’s actually at 100% battery. Hyundai does this.
- heisenbergs 6y agoThat's a terrible idea from a user perspective. All of ionity and tesla's superchargers are in urban or shopping areas that allow you to quickly buy some food, go shopping or go to a bathroom in a respectable location. I personally would have zero interest in going to my car dealership as their locations are typically far away from anything urban or of interst.
- greenkey 6y agoSame here, I avoid them when I can. It won’t be too long before the gas stations are fast chargers, though- I give it 20 years.
- mrtnmcc 6y agoSimply replacing gas stations with chargers is a step back in electric's flexiblity. They don't need large underground storage tanks and special zoning. I think gas stations will simply vanish, and chargers will stay next to useful places like businesses, grocery stores restraurants, malls, etc.
- whitexn--g28h 6y agoThis is true in Urban markets, but in more rural areas the gas station is the grocery store and the restaurant. It will probably help those businesses by giving bored drivers a reason to come into the business and spend.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoNow the trunk is auto drive (which is less problematic for long running one that is train service in nature), the business model has to be rethink.
- ramenmeal 6y agoNot really all that buried, I was able to read that portion without a WSJ subscription.
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoBut clearly intentionally left out of the headline, which is the real problem
- krrrh 6y agoA regulation requiring headlines to reflect article content would solve about half of the problems caused by social media.
- nordsieck 6y ago> A regulation requiring headlines to reflect article content That is literally asking the impossible of journalists. Unless the headline is as long as the article, there will always be some nuance from the article left out of some headlines.
- emmelaich 6y agoBut too often the headline is contrary to the article, like this. The headline suggests some animosity towards electric cars where no such animosity is in evidence.
- imgabe 6y agoYeah, I also read that part and got the distinct impression that the journalist is deliberately trying to misinterpret some facts to push their preferred narrative (electric cars not that great, Tesla overvalued). Maybe that's true, maybe it's not, but I don't think the fact that 17% of Cadillac dealers can't afford a $200,000 upgrade supports that hypothesis all that well.
- azernik 6y ago
- slo0pjohnb 6y agoThe article’s title had my bias going: I visualized a bunch of dinosaurs named Tony banging their fists on their desks exclaiming, “I ain’t selling no electric cars!”
- unreal37 6y agoAlso in the article, > Most dealers who accepted the buyout ... sell only a handful of Cadillacs a month.
- jorblumesea 6y agoMakes sense. People already struggling or on the way out take the deal and exit the game.
- alexgartrell 6y agoIt’s common for dealerships to hold several franchises too. So they wouldn’t even necessarily be struggling, just reacting to Cadillac performing worse than Toyota, for example
- avree 6y agoAlso in the article, >Most dealers who accepted the buyout also own one or more of GM’s other brands—Chevrolet, Buick and GMC...
- qppo 6y agoI'd like to see the ratio as a percentage of domestic Cadillac sales
- Aeronwen 6y agoCadillac has something like 970 US dealers and sold roughly 129,000 cars last year. Half the dealers sell under 50 cars a month. That's 970 dealers after culling 400 Cadillac dealers during their bankruptcy, btw.
- nathanvanfleet 6y agoBuried as in not in the title of the article? That info was in the 3rd paragraph
- rmason 6y agoIt is rather odd. Most dealers selling a handful of cars took the GM buyout in 2008. Perhaps they spent the couple of hundred thousand dollars back then and things didn't turn out as well as they hoped? Spoke with my local Ford dealer who knows that I am interested in one of the Mustang EV's. He showed my the two chargers and shop tools they were required to buy to sell the Mustang EV. I think he said it was around $40K plus the cost of a week or two training off site. I wonder what GM is doing that triples that cost?
- bluGill 6y agoWhen a dealer sells one of any car they have a list of replacement parts that the manufacturer requires they buy (and keep in stock for a few years), along with training for the mechanics (not all, but at least one needs training in anything specific to the car). Thus the first sale of any loses money. They make it up with more sales over time. Actually many lose money on new car sales, but make it up on parts and maintenance.