3 ms·
It would change our understanding of history a bit. Nobody has found a proof that Fermat could reasonably have successfully proved the theorem with. People have
by jerf 16y ago
It would change our understanding of history a bit. Nobody has found a proof that Fermat could reasonably have successfully proved the theorem with. People have developed numerous false-but-tempting proofs that Fermat could have had. I believe that since Fermat never mentioned this proof again in the 30 remaining years he had to live, it is generally believed that Fermat actually realized his own error before publishing and that's why he never laid it out; he would not have had a reason to think he would need to explain not following up on a margin note.
A short and successful proof using nothing but math Fermat had would probably not rewrite mathematics qua mathematics, but would almost instantly be an astounding story for how we could have missed something like that for so long. It would itself be worthy of study to figure out how that happened!
- karamazov 16y agoThis approach is not really novel or difficult; it's extremely unlikely that something this simple would have been missed by everyone for so long.