2 ms·
But this review process had never been used for introducing comments of this sort to a paper ever before. Plus, there was no suggestion of change, just retracti
by whimsicalism 6y ago
But this review process had never been used for introducing comments of this sort to a paper ever before. Plus, there was no suggestion of change, just retraction.
- lokar 6y ago> But this review process had never been used for introducing comments of this sort to a paper ever before How do you know that?
- pseudalopex 6y ago"My submissions were always checked for disclosure of sensitive material, never for the quality of the literature review."[1] "In all of my time at Google AI, I never heard of pubapproval being used for peer review or to critique the scientific rigor of the work. It was never used as a journal, it was an afterthought that folks on my team would usually clear only hours before important deadlines. We like to leave peer review to the conferences/journals' existing process to weed out bad papers; why duplicate that work internally?"[2] [1] https://twitter.com/le_roux_nicolas/status/1334601960972906496 https://twitter.com/le_roux_nicolas/status/13346019609729064... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25307456 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25307456
- lokar 6y agoHuh. When I was there I certainly saw review for quality / novel ideas.