19 ms·
There are three different discussions happening all at the same time, which is muddying things. 1. Was the treatment of her research in internal review reasona
by UncleMeat 6y ago
There are three different discussions happening all at the same time, which is muddying things.
1. Was the treatment of her research in internal review reasonable?
2. Was terminating her employment reasonable after she sent the (now public) email to the women-and-allies brain listserv?
3. Was the end of her employment at Google a resignation or a firing?
To me, (3) is by a wide margin the least interesting part of the story and all of the discussion here is missing the point entirely. Whether she was fired or resigned has zero bearing on whether (1) and (2) show reasonable or unreasonable actions.
- visarga 6y agoFor what it's worth, I have read the abstract of the paper and discussions around it and I have seen more than one person rate it as not very interesting. Why is all this fuss about a paper restating common knowledge? For example, they say datasets need to be filtered for bias, and that large models consume ... duh ... a lot. We already know that, where's the new shiny architecture for fair modelling? link to abstract and discussion - https://old.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k69eq0/n_the_abstract_of_the_paper_that_led_to_timnit/ https://old.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k69eq0/n_t...