8 ms·
> Then the work doesn't get completed on time! Do you realise in some fields work not getting completed on time could in some cases cause people to die? Somet
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> Then the work doesn't get completed on time!
Do you realise in some fields work not getting completed on time could in some cases cause people to die?
Sometimes there is an emergency, and a professional saying 'sorry nope on vacation your fault for not having enough people to cover every eventuality' just isn't reasonable.
- CalRobert 6y agoIt is reasonable. The buck stops somewhere. If you're on call sure but there are rules around that. Don't guilt people who happen to have lifesaving jobs for taking vacations.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Don't guilt people who happen to have lifesaving jobs for taking vacations. In many cases taking that job means accepting you may be forced to come in and work. Often called 'unlimited liability' for example. If you can't accept that, then leave the job to someone who can. > The buck stops somewhere. In this case apparently it's fine for it to stop with a dead person.
- notreallytrue 6y ago> In this case apparently it's fine for it to stop with a dead person. People that do a job where they can save lives accept the fact that saving lives is not granted. People don't die because someone is slacking. Do you realize how stupid that sounds?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> People don't die because someone is slacking. Not sure where you read this argument?
- notreallytrue 6y agoThat's a terrible apology... Free time is a right If someone dies during your free time it's not your responsibility Besides: US have the worst life expectation of the whole west. You should ask yourself why.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> That's a terrible apology... I'm not apologising for anything. I never said anything about 'slacking'? Just confused where you got this idea. > If someone dies during your free time it's not your responsibility This isn't reality - look at how people criticise presidents who are golfing during a national crisis where people are dying. > US have the worst life expectation of the whole west This article is about the EU isn't it? What's the US got to do with it? > You should ask yourself why. I don't know why the US does anything. Why do I need to explain it?
- notreallytrue 6y ago> ook at how people criticise presidents who are golfing during a national crisis where people are dying Isn't the job of a president to handle crisis? The job of a doctor is not to prevent any death, just those that they can prevent during their work hours. > What's the US got to do with it? Because they are the champions of working non stop and yet their results when it really matters (you brought up saving lives) are worse than anybody else
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Isn't the job of a president to handle crisis? Do you think he stops handling the crisis at 5pm? No? Why do you think not?
- notreallytrue 6y agoI think that if you look closely inside yourself you'll find the answer. Hints: how many presidents any country has? And who put them there? Do they send CVs and get selected after a black board interview where they have to invert a binary tree?
- Majestic121 6y ago> Do you realise in some fields work not getting completed on time could in some cases cause people to die? I'm sure there are jobs where this is true. I'm also sure it's not for 99.9% of people here.
- dbetteridge 6y agoOf course its reasonable... It may not be the decision people will make, it may be an ethical quagmire etc etc but you can't just expect people to keep working past their limits forever. There need to be reasonable bounds.
- aranelsurion 6y agoSounds like a poorly built strawman you have there. How often do you believe people get asked to work extra hours to save lives in imminent danger? 1 in 10000? This law would cover other 9999 cases.
- theshrike79 6y agoIf there is an actual emergency, there are clear rules of escalation. The issue is escalated through different support levels up to the on-call person, if they can't handle it then MAYBE people are bothered during their vacation. Or if production breaks at 1600 on a friday night, I can maybe work extra hours to solve the issue if it looks like I'm essential to solving it. It just means that I'm coming later on monday to make up for the hours.
- notreallytrue 6y ago> Do you realise in some fields work not getting completed on time could in some cases cause people to die? It doesn't work like that. > Sometimes there is an emergency, and a professional saying 'sorry nope on vacation Why are they relying on someone that is on vacation in the first place? Are firemen supposed to not go on holiday ever during their work life? That's simply the symptom of very bad management and on a larger scale of a very disfunctional society.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Why are they relying on someone that is on vacation in the first place? Sometimes there are only so many people who can solve a problem and society can't afford to have an excess number of them sitting around doing nothing in case there is an emergency. > Are firemen supposed to not go on holiday ever during their work life? Firemen, police, politicians, military, are all subject to getting recalled from leave if there is an emergency and they are needed to prevent life being lost. Nobody ever said they can't ever go on leave. > That's simply the symptom of very bad management No it's reality! Look at how many people criticise presidents who are 'golfing' when there is a crisis and life is being lost. Some people just need to be able to respond no matter what.
- notreallytrue 6y ago> Sometimes there are only so many people who can solve a problem That's a very small subset of the entire workforce. Maybe one in a million or less > No it's reality! It's not. > Look at how many people criticise presidents who are 'golfing' when there is a crisis and life is being lost. They are right. The president is not a salaried worker, it's the president.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> The president is not a salaried worker, it's the president. He works. He draws a salary. What do you think the difference is? Why can't the Vice President delegate out of hours? Because that's not realistic? Well there you go... sometimes it's not realistic.