4 ms·
I think of placing a zillion cameras in public places as nothing less than automation of human work. Instead of hiring a million agents to record what the popul
by Someone 6y ago
I think of placing a zillion cameras in public places as nothing less than automation of human work. Instead of hiring a million agents to record what the population is doing, you hire one programmer to automate that data collection process.
Totally different? Yes, but it shows that scale can affect whether something is OK to do or not, at least for some (I accept that people watching the streets can be useful, but also have my doubts about doing that at scale, whether by cameras or by hiring a million agents)
With both cameras and copy-pasting web content, there’s the issue what you do with the data. If, for example, I start scraping all the articles on a newspaper’s web site, publish them on a web site, adding my own ads, most people would think that shouldn’t be legal.
If you agree, we’re now haggling over the price (https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/03/07/haggling/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/03/07/haggling/). That’s where things get difficult, but I think the entire spectrum from white (scraping for this goal is fine) via grey to black exists.
- narag 6y agoIf, for example, I start scraping all the articles on a newspaper’s web site, publish them on a web site, adding my own ads, most people would think that shouldn’t be legal. Publishing? Ads?
- fakedang 6y agoRepublishing, duh.
- narag 6y agoOK, let's reformulate that: would people be opposed to just scrapping or to the illegal republishing and adding ads? Another similar trick: "If someone will block ads and then murder the publicist and burn his house, most people would find that it should be illegal".
- fakedang 6y agoAdvertising isn't some zero-sum game that suddenly makes you lose because you happened to see it. Republishing is - the original publisher loses out on the value of his publication because that means either reduced ad revenue or reduced subscription. I'm guilty myself of reading republished articles, but it is a loss for the publisher.
- narag 6y agoI hope you realize that what you wrote isn't related to my point at all. It's fine, but why put that as an answer to my comment is beyond me.
- cxr 6y agoWeird take, but I see this sort of thing show up a lot, so let's give it a shot: > If, for example, I start scraping all the articles on a newspaper’s web site, publish them on a web site, adding my own ads Using a Q-Tip to murder someone is illegal. We don't have special laws against it—it's just that murder is illegal, we have criminal punishment for murder, and the ordinary machinery of the courts and the law is sufficient to handle any instances of murder by Q-Tip. Because it being done with a Q-Tip is the least important part. If you're scraping and republishing someone else's content, it's not the scraping part that's the problem.