3 ms·
"Appeal to Authority" is a crap fallacy (or maybe a crap name for a fallacy). "Appeal to hierarchy" might be a better description. Otherwise going to a doctor
by raverbashing 6y ago
"Appeal to Authority" is a crap fallacy (or maybe a crap name for a fallacy). "Appeal to hierarchy" might be a better description.
Otherwise going to a doctor for a sickness, or hiring an engineer to build a house would be fallacious as well.
(And give the amounts of PhDs that are incompetent or just crazy in areas they should know better is astounding but I digress)
- viraptor 6y agoIt's... Either badly named or applied without nuance. It's not about situations like "they're an expert on X, therefore I trust their opinion on X". Instead it's for "they're an authority on something, therefore if they have opinion on X, I should trust it".
- thedanbob 6y agoIt’s not a crap fallacy, it just doesn’t always apply. It’s a fallacy only in the case that you are trying to establish a strictly logical argument (in the mathematical sense). “You should do this because that expert said so” is a rational argument, not a logical one.
- BaronSamedi 6y agoYour are conflating what is practical with what is true in logic and argumentation. It is practical to accept our doctor's diagnosis because we trust that the medical system produces competent doctors and because of constraints on our time. If you claimed that a diagnosis must be true because it came from a doctor then you would appealing to authority.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]