3 ms·
Why is "motte, less demonstrated" that they are poorly researched badly written stereotype? At least when it comes to clothing, the blog author does indeed demo
by watwut 6y ago
Why is "motte, less demonstrated" that they are poorly researched badly written stereotype? At least when it comes to clothing, the blog author does indeed demonstrate that.
> We’re not here to ‘cancel’ ASOIF..." but let's write a 3 part series wherein it "is going to become increasingly apparent that at least effective research was not done" where he will "... treat Martin’s words much more charitably than they probably deserve"
There is no contradiction in two. It is completely absolutely valid to criticize research and clearly comment on the whole "nomad cultures are nothing like this" aspect of GoT as a super popular fiction - whose fans indeed do claim "it was like that".
"Cancelling" refers to censorship. You cant cry censorship just because someone politely criticized something. However, writing 3 part series on something being inaccurate or even completely shitty (which author did not done) is not cancelling.
Also, author criticized other aspects of GoT a lot previously - notably Jamie military activities. It is not just about Dothraki.
- rendall 6y agoThe author is expressing an opinion using cherry-picked details: an excerpt from an offhand LiveJournal comment and 2 sparse descriptions from the book. That plus loads of speculation presented as fact. "The Dothraki were based on demeaning stereotypes as evidenced by their clothing choices" is unconvincing Historically inaccurate: sure. Granted. Motte. Demeaning stereotype: Let's take an offhand comment, load it with unsupported meaning, link it with Historical Inaccuracy, call it demeaning. Boom. Bailey. Edit: responding to your edits > * "nomad cultures are nothing like this" * He cherry-picked ways that the Dothraki are different from horse-riding, raiding cultures and labeled this demeaning. Did he talk about ways that Dothraki culture is similar to horse-riding, raiding cultures? No, he did not. It's All Wrong and Bad > * Cancelling" refers to censorship. You cant cry censorship ... * You literally just redefined a word that I used and argued against this new, less defensible, dumb position. Don't do that. > * Also, author criticized other aspects of GoT a lot previously ... * Not sure what that has to do with this article being a motte and bailey. I'm sure his other articles are marvelous.
- praestigiare 6y agoThe author spent significant time explaining why they chose to address that livejournal excerpt, and the context in which they were addressing it. They did not present speculation as fact, they presented facts (historical information, photographs, and quotes from the material) and suggested an interpretation of those facts.
- rendall 6y agoThis is the motte. "It's just historical inaccuracy. Surely you cannot object to correcting the record can you?" Now defend that the historical inaccuracy is a demeaning stereotype.
- jcranmer 6y agoReducing a culture to a single point of reference should self-evidently be a demeaning stereotype. If you need more evidence, I'll point out that in the specific case of making the defining characteristic being bad-ass warriors, that implies that when the bad-ass warriors get their asses kicked (by modern militaries), you are implying that they no longer have any redeeming qualities worth caring about.
- jessaustin 6y agoThis is not logical. These characters are fictional, and they have been vaguely identified with roughly a third of the premodern cultures I've ever heard of. Emphasizing their prowess in war and also illustrating them facing difficulties in war is just a trope. "The Worf Effect", to be precise. [0] It doesn't say anything about the Huns or the Turks or the Sioux or anyone. Even telling a story about the actual Huns and how they were great at war but also they lost some wars wouldn't be demeaning. You might not have heard, but war is generally horrible for everyone involved. [0] https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheWorfEffect https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheWorfEffect
- rendall 6y ago> Reducing a culture to a single point of reference should self-evidently be a demeaning stereotype. Let's grant that premise! You are correct! What does that have to do with the Dothraki, a fictional nation? Remember, the bailey is "The Dothraki is a demeaning stereotype" The motte is "The Dothraki is historically inaccurate." or "The Sioux have endured demeaning stereotypes." These are both true and uncontroversial. The essayist even seems to take umbrage that the Dothraki armor looks nothing like Sioux buckskin! Would he take umbrage if they looked alike? You betcha he would. The truth is, GRRM's throwaway comment notwithstanding, the Dothraki serve an analogous role to ASOIF narrative as the Huns, Vikings, Kazakhs, Barbary pirates and Mongol raiders did to European history. Are you and the essayist seriously arguing that these ancient peoples are somehow demeaned by the freaking Dothraki?