4 ms·
Rail construction is more expensive because the loads are way higher - axle loads of 22-25 metric tons are common (https://www.forschungsinformationssystem.de/s
by mschuster91 6y ago
Rail construction is more expensive because the loads are way higher - axle loads of 22-25 metric tons are common (https://www.forschungsinformationssystem.de/servlet/is/325055/ https://www.forschungsinformationssystem.de/servlet/is/32505...), trucks are half to a third of that (usually 8t/axle, legal limit in Germany are 10t). The forces on the rails are also greater especially if higher speeds are involved - trucks here have a limit of 80 km/h and buses 100 km/h, whereas trains reach triple that.
- Symbiote 6y agoBut Hawaii is building a light metro system, with speeds of around 110km/h and an axle weight of about 10t (or less, I don't know how many axles there are). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honolulu_Rail_Transit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honolulu_Rail_Transit
- hijp 6y agoI don't know what the axle weight is but each car weighs 32.6 metric tons and travel in trains of 4-cars, the top speed is 88kmh (48kmh average). https://planning.hawaii.gov/wp-content/uploads/HART-presentation.pdf https://planning.hawaii.gov/wp-content/uploads/HART-presenta... https://www.honolulutransit.org/inform/rail-facts#gsc.tab=0 https://www.honolulutransit.org/inform/rail-facts#gsc.tab=0 *edit - decimal
- mschuster91 6y agoYou got the units wrong - 72.000 lbs is ~32 metric tons. Assuming carriages with two separate axle pairs that's 8 tons per axle, if two adjacent carriages share one axle pair a 4-carriage train has 5 pairs / 10 axles in total for a load of 128 tons it's 12.8 tons/axle. Still, neither is something to take lightly (pun not intended), and I guess that building elevated makes construction a good chunk more expensive.
- hijp 6y agoWhoops, missed a zero when putting it into google perhaps. Here's the Hitachi Rail page with the trains, looks like four per car. http://italy.hitachirail.com/en/honolulu_381.html http://italy.hitachirail.com/en/honolulu_381.html So at 8 tons per axle its still within OP's truck limit. Anyway I'm just kvetching because our 20-mile light rail is taking 22-years to build, is half complete, and a billion dollars over budget (as of now).
- alistairSH 6y agoMore expensive than tunneling under the Atlantic?