5 ms·
I would like the people downvoting you to explain why they think it's truly revolutionary. I just went back to reread the Tom's Hardware article on the chip, th
by wpietri 6y ago
I would like the people downvoting you to explain why they think it's truly revolutionary. I just went back to reread the Tom's Hardware article on the chip, thinking I must have missed something, and I'm not seeing it.
Full credit to Apple for incrementally improving their A-series processors over the last decade until they're good enough for laptops. But I'm not seeing that this makes anything fundamentally different. Just compare the A14 with the M1, for example: https://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/compare_cpu-apple_m1-1804-vs-apple_a14_bionic-1693 https://www.cpu-monkey.com/en/compare_cpu-apple_m1-1804-vs-a...
- coldtea 6y ago>I would like the people downvoting you to explain why they think it's truly revolutionary. For one, it's the first PC chip with these kind of thermals and power combo. Second, it brings many new design decisions, from unified memory, to the SoC design, various coprocessors, etc, that have not been available in the form of laptop/desktop PCs. The last of this kind in the mass market would be something like the Amiga, which is still a very different design. Third, it's hella fast and many different things, both given its power draw, but also irrespective of it. Fourth, it makes ARM for PC computing mainstream suddenly, after decades where it was relegated to the mobile and hobbyist/specialist (rapsberry, etc) space. If that's not a revolutionary change, I don't know what you expected. A CPU made from flour with alien technology that's 1000 times faster and uses quantum bits? Yeah, they didn't make that.
- Apocryphon 6y agoLike the iPhone and iPod, it's a revolutionary entrant from the consumer point of view in terms of user experience. And like the iPhone and iPod, from a technical point of view, it's merely a very competent iteration down a natural evolutionary pathway, in a preexisting product type.
- coldtea 6y agoAnd like the iPhone and iPod it has very real innovations (in engineering) that people always underplay because "No wireless, less space than a Nomad, lame!", or "we had smartphones before, I had some Ericsson/Nokia/MS gizmo, so what's evolutionary about the iPhone?".
- Apocryphon 6y agoYou're right. At the end of the day, they're technically evolutionary, not revolutionary, which was the central conceit of this subthread. And there's nothing wrong with that. Technical evolution can lead to consumer revolutions.
- shawnz 6y agoTed Nelson: "It's possible to insist that every change is merely a small difference in degree if you do not want to see a change in kind"
- wpietri 6y agoI disagree. The iPhone was revolutionary in that it made smartphones and phone apps accessible to the mass market, unleashing a wave of change in how people live, work, and play. M1 Macs will be used basically like the previous Macs, but somewhat faster and somewhat longer without plugging in. So I don't think this qualifies as a revolutionary change.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Apocryphon 6y agoI think the M1 Macs are a precursor for a truly revolutionary (for consumers) Apple ARM computer. Whether that will be realized with the M1X/M2 next year or further on, it remains to be seen.
- wpietri 6y agoOk. I'm glad we now agree that this is not revolutionary. What's the revolution you are hoping for with future generations of the processor?
- sudosysgen 6y agoExactly how is it much better? It's not the first chip with a 15-25W TDP. When compared to other chips with such a TDP, it's incrementally faster in single core and it trades blows in multicore. It does this at a process node ahead. For very light loads, it does have a slightly better power performance than existing low power PC processors, but not by that much. A Ryzen LPP core is somewhere between the big and the small cores of the M1 in power performance in such cases. It's not the first PC chip to be an SOC, or to have unified memory, or to have many coprocessors. Literally all of those were done simultaneously, in chips of comparable performance, at the same power. It's also been a decade that we know that instruction sets don't matter. All modern PC processors use a different instruction set and translate from x86. To switch them to ARM would be a matter of adding a few extensions to expose all the functionality, and change the instruction translation stage a bit.
- coldtea 6y ago>Exactly how is it much better? It's not the first chip with a 15-25W TDP. When compared to other chips with such a TDP, it's incrementally faster in single core and it trades blows in multicore. It does this at a process node ahead. Being a process node ahead is already "much better", and IS a feat. Where are the process node ahead chips from the competitors? On top of that, it's Apple's own SoC design, it has its own GPU design and co-processors, tons of work into making speed optimizations all around (from the buses to memory handling), and came with a new OS release, a port to the new architecture, a bridge layer for iOS apps, and a perfectly capable x86 translation layer. Rosetta2 alone would be difficult to pull all for most of the industry (Microsoft failed at the same, and their ARM laptops are completely subpar to the M1 machines as well in many levels, despite costing the same or more). >It's not the first PC chip to be an SOC, or to have unified memory, or to have many coprocessors. Which mainstream PC chip in actual laptops/desktops people use has unified memory and doesn't use sockets/DIMMS? >It's also been a decade that we know that instruction sets don't matter. All modern PC processors use a different instruction set and translate from x86. That's a moot point, since they still carry all the x86 baggage in microcode, since tons of bad decisions leading to things like Spectra. ARM doesn't.
- 6y ago
- wpietri 6y agoThese all strike me as evolutionary changes. People will be doing about the same things as before. They will do them a bit faster, and not have to plug in as often. I expect revolutionary changes to overturn an existing order. E.g., the Mac was revolutionary. Smartphones were revolutionary. This is a solid and impressive evolutionary change. Kudos to them, of course. But when actual revolutions happen, I would like to have a word handy to acknowledge that.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoIt's not necessarily revolutionary, but it's not just a small evolutionary step. But either way it's just pedantic.
- wpietri 6y agoI'm glad we both agree that revolution is not the right word. I think precision in language is something that is generally valued at HN, especially when the lack of precision is marketing hype.
- shawnz 6y agoSmartphones can be just as easily trivialized into being something which lets us "do the same things as before, but faster and with less plugs". I think it is wrong to say there is a clear difference between these kind of changes. We won't really know how "revolutionary" M1 was until we see the landscape of the market in the future, but I think the simple fact of dropping x86 alone is enough to enable some major new ways of looking at desktop computing.
- wpietri 6y agoThey cannot in fact be that easily trivialized. You'd welcome to try, though if you think you can demonstrate the point. If you really believe that non-x86 laptops are what makes for a revolution, then the credit here doesn't belong to Apple. For example: https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/6/21050758/lenovo-yoga-5g-snapdragon-qualcomm-8cx-x55-arm-windows-laptop-ces-2020 https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/6/21050758/lenovo-yoga-5g-sn... or: https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/09/cnn-underscored/galaxy-book-s-review/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/09/cnn-underscored/galaxy-book-s... But personally, I'd say that those are an interesting step, but not particularly revolutionary.
- _jal 6y agoI would like people arguing the opposite to define "revolutionary". The combination of the performance increase with the power and thermal efficiency in the first release for a laptop is the sort of improvement we haven't seen in a very long time. > I'm not seeing that this makes anything fundamentally different I guess we'll see. $1000 dollars buys a lot more laptop utility than it did a month ago, and the abrupt availability of a laptop with higher performance with far better battery life than anything else on the market has certainly gotten a lot of people's attention. I'm not buying one[1], but I'm really curious to see the M2. [1] I'm really torn, the atrophy of the Unix side of the OS and the increasing lockdown has frustrated me a lot. But the option of just running MacOS as a hypervisor that happens to run Photoshop may be just fine for me... I'll decide when the current machine dies.
- wpietri 6y agoSure. To me evolutionary generally means quantitative improvements in expected dimensions. Revolutionary requires overturning some existing order. E.g., the American Revolution replaced the existing government. I'd call the original Mac revolutionary, in that it totally changed how people interacted with computers. Laptops were revolutionary. Smartphones were revolutionary. A new generation of laptop that runs somewhat longer without plugging in is not revolutionary. People will be doing the same things.
- x0x0 6y agoall day on-battery real-world heavy usage without significant compromises. In fact, not just without significant compromises, but about as fast as a laptop can go.
- wpietri 6y agoThat's a nice feature, sure. But I don't see it as revolutionary. Are there a lot of people suddenly able to live or work differently because of this?
- x0x0 6y agoFor me, a lack of constantly thinking about the battery is a big deal. I had the same thing happen w/ my phone: mine got large enough a couple years ago that it was a full 2 day battery life. So I could assume it would work all day. Same deal here. I can go (in a !2020 world) to a customer, go from meeting to meeting, etc and it will just work. edit: Also, it feels like we're transitioning from a world in which laptops are mostly / often used while being plugged in, to a world more like a phone. The default mode of operation is disconnected from a power source.
- wpietri 6y agoI agree that's an excellent step forward, but again, I'm not seeing it as a revolution. All-day batteries were always available in the Android world, so I don't think there was any revolution there. Similarly, there are plenty of laptops with all-day batteries. That list includes, but is not topped by, both M1 and previous Macs: https://www.laptopmag.com/articles/all-day-strong-longest-lasting-notebooks https://www.laptopmag.com/articles/all-day-strong-longest-la...
- x0x0 6y agoAh. I found my macs to have all day battery as long as I didn't actually really use it. So it could kind of happen, but only if I paid a lot of attention. I totally recognize this may not make a diff for everyone, but for me, it's moving to assuming the battery lasts all day w/o me managing it. :shrug: