3 ms·
> Edit: The person replying to me about the H1B not being dual intent from the beginning is wrong. I have receipts. The H1B was introduced in the Immigration Ac
by rayiner 6y ago
> Edit: The person replying to me about the H1B not being dual intent from the beginning is wrong. I have receipts. The H1B was introduced in the Immigration Act of 1990.
The statute doesn’t say anything about “dual intent.” That’s an administrative fiction. Under the actual law, the H-1B is a “nonimmigrant” visa status for temporary workers.
The status is defined in Section 1101(a)(15), which describes various “classes of nonimmigrant aliens.” See: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1101 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1101
In that same provision, subsection (H)(1)(b) defines the status as a worker “who is coming temporarily to the United States to perform services” in a “speciality occupation.”
The provision you quote doesn’t create some concept of “dual intent.” It simply says that someone shall not be presumed to have immigrant intent just because they file an adjustment of status petition. Why would that even matter? Because H-1B still requires nonimmigrant intent!
If Congress had designed H-1B to be a pathway to permanent residency, it would say that in the statute. Instead what happened is that for 40 years the executive branch abused the H-1 program to turn a temporary immigration visa into a de facto permanent immigration system. Congress didn’t want to blow up the status quo, but also couldn’t get the vote to create a real system for permanent immigration of skilled workers. The 1990 INA doesn’t even use the words “dual intent” or anything like it. Congress did the minimum it needed to address the situation where State Department was barring H-1 holders who has filed an immigration petition from re-entering, because that’s all they could get the votes for.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> The statute doesn’t say anything about “dual intent.” V, L and H-1 (including H-1b, but excluding H-1b1) nonimmigrant visas are explicitly, by statute, excluded from the rule requiring nonimmigrant visa holders to lack immigrant intent; Immigration and Nationality Act Sec. 214(b), as amended, codified at US Code Title 8, Sec. 1184(b). "Dual intent" isn't an administrative fiction, its a term of art for the nonimmigrant visa categories excluded from the generally applicable requirement for having (and demonstrating) the absence of immigrant intent. Its true that there are some visa categories where "dual intent" is applied adminstratively rather than from a clear statutory rule, but V, L, and H-1 (except H-1b1) visas have explicit statutory allowance for dual intent. > If Congress had designed H-1B to be a pathway to permanent residency, it would say that in the statute. But...it does say that in the statute. > Instead what happened is that for 40 years the executive branch abused the H-1 program to turn a temporary immigration visa into a de facto permanent immigration system. Whether or not H-1 may have been abused that way between 1980 and 1990 (the first 10 years of your "40 year period") [See EDIT below], the exemption of H-1 and L visas from the no-immigration-intent requirement has been express in statute since the Immigration Act of 1990, so for the last 30 years the behavior you complain about has been strictly as directed by statute. References: Summary: http://www.americanlaw.com/dintent.html http://www.americanlaw.com/dintent.html Current codification and history: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1184 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/8/1184 [history of amendments, including text added by the 1990 amendment at issue, by clicking "Notes"] [EDIT: The H-1B can't have been abused between 1980 and 1990, while I checked when the H-1B was added to the exception from the no-immigration-intent rule, I didn't check when the visa category itself as added, which was at the same time in the INA of 1990. So, no, it was never abused as a route to immigration, it has always explicitly allowed that use in the statute. Conceivably, the unsplit H-1 could have been abused between 1980 and 1990, though.]
- xyzzyz 6y ago> V, L and H-1 (including H-1b, but excluding H-1b1) nonimmigrant visas are explicitly, by statute, excluded from the rule requiring nonimmigrant visa holders to lack immigrant intent; The US Code Title 8, Sec. 1184(b) has nothing to do with the "dual intent" thing. What happens there is that people on visas like B2 are _presumed_ to be immigrants, and need to actually argue that they are not in front of consular officers in the embassy and the immigration officers at the border. The holders of V, L and H visas are exempt from this, and they are presumed non-immigrant by default. However, contrary to what you say here, L and H visa holders are still required to lack immigration intent. The dual intent rule stems from completely different piece o US code, see the section 205 of Immigration Act of 1990: > (h) The fact that an alien is the beneficiary of an application for a preference status filed under section 204 or has otherwise sought permanent residence in the United States shall not constitute evidence of an intention to abandon a foreign residence for purposes of obtaining a visa as a nonimmigrant described in subparagraph (H)(i) or (L) of section 101(a)(15) or otherwise obtaining or maintaining the status of a nonimmigrant described in such subparagraph, if the alien had obtained a change of status under section 248 to a classification as such a nonimmigrant before the alien's most recent departure from the United States.'. This is the source of the dual intent doctrine. Note what it says: it says that application for permanent residency shall not constitute evidence of an intention to abandon a foreign residence. The reason it says so is because prior to that, such application has in fact been used by Department of State to presume immigrant intent on behalf of H1 visa holders, and to deny them entry. This is the "legal fiction" rayiner is talking about: H1B visa holders are still required to have no immigration intent, and while the US Code Title 8, Sec. 1184(b) frees them from the presumption that they do have one and requirement to prove that they do not have it, the dual intent doctrine was still necessary in order to bar government agencies from concluding that they intend to immigrate based on their application explicitly saying that they intend to immigrate. > But...it does say that in the statute. No, H1B is still a non-immigrant visa, see section 1101(a)(15) which defines the non-immigrant visas. > the exemption of H-1 and L visas from the no-immigration-intent requirement has been express in statute since the Immigration Act of 1990, so for the last 30 years the behavior you complain about has been strictly as directed by statute. Right, the amended statute doesn't make it actually illegal, but still the whole procedure is based on legal fiction of not concluding immigrant intent where there obviously is one.