3 ms·
That’s incorrect. The H1 visa is by its terms a temporary work visa of limited duration: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H-1B_visa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H
by rayiner 6y ago
That’s incorrect. The H1 visa is by its terms a temporary work visa of limited duration: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H-1B_visa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H-1B_visa. It was created in the 1952 INA. In the 1990 INA, it was split into the H-1A and H-1B, but continued to be an non-immigration visa, as distinguished from immigration visas introduced in the 1990 statute: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Act_of_1990 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Act_of_1990
“Dual intent” is the “administrative fiat” I was talking about. Both the 1952 and 1990 INA define an H-1 worker as an alien “who is coming temporarily to the United States to perform services.” Non-immigrant intent is a prerequisite for the category. Since the 1952 Act, the INS adopted a fiction of dual intent to turn the H-1 visa into a de-facto immigration visa. However, the State Department didn’t recognize dual intent. When an H1 visa holder filed an immigration petition, the State Department treated that as signaling intent to immigrate, in violation of the H1 terms. When the visa holder travelled, they risked not being allowed back in the country, causing significant hardship.
With the INS having backed Congress into a corner, the 1990 INA included a narrow solution to eliminate the specific hardship and maintain the status quo. But it didn’t change the fundamental nature of the H1 visa as a temporary immigration visa. It’s still a temporary non-immigrant visa in the statute, as distinguished from immigrant visas which are also in the statute. The committee’s legislative history for the 1990 INA makes clear that Congress was just kicking the can down the road and alleviating that specific hardship without reconceptualizing H-1B as an immigrant visa:
> The difficulties encountered by those seeking temporary admission who have also expressed a desire to immigrate at some time in the future have caused severe personal hardship as well as inhibited frequent travel to the United States for business purposes. This has been particularly onerous for the beneficiaries of H and L visas. The Committee [on the Judiciary] sees no useful purpose in denying temporary entry to the United States for business purposes because of an inability to show that a residence abroad will not be abandoned. Such presumption of immigrant intent in particular circumstances creates purposeless, but often insurmountable, barriers for the prospective employee and the employer. For all categories of nonimmigrant visas (including the H and L), the bill provides that the filing of an immigrant petition cannot be a factor in determining whether an alien intends to abandon a foreign residence. The Committee notes, however, that the consular officers may rely on other evidence indicating the possibility of overstaying a visa, such as records of past visits to the United States.
If the H1-B was “meant as a path to permanent residence” the whole “dual intent” thing would be meaningless. The only reason you need “dual intent” is because the law still requires H1-B holders to have non-immigrant intent. It’s a kludge to deal with the fact that Congress can’t actually muster the votes to create a real skilled immigration system.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> “Dual intent” is the “administrative fiat” I was talking about. Except that while the term "dual intent" is a term of art which doesn't appear in the statute, the exception from the rule requiring no immigration intent for non-immigrant visas for visas in the H-1 category (from which exception the H-1B1 is now also excepted, putting it back into the no-immigration-intent category) was also part of the 1990 INA that created the H-1B. While there are categories where you might argue dual intent exists by administrative fiat rather than statute (IIRC, that's the practice with P nonimmigrant visas), its absolutely not the case with V, H-1 (except H-1B1), and L visas, which are explicitly statutorily excluded from the no-immigration-intent rule. > Since the 1952 Act, the INS adopted a fiction of dual intent to turn the H-1 visa into a de-facto immigration visa. Possibly true between 1952 and 1990, but since 1990 the H-1 has been a visa which explicitly, under statute law allows for immigration intent. To the extent that there was an administrative usurpation involved, it hasn't been an issue since the middle of the George H. W. Bush Administration, and, moreover, its never been an issue for the H-1B, which was created at the same time as the explicit statutory dual intent rule.
- tptacek 6y agoAs an aside, this whole debate has been super fascinating, but I'm a little confused as to why it matters. What major difference does immigration intent have on the economics of importing tech labor?
- damnyou 6y agoI think there's a good argument to be made that you should have to make your mind up about staying permanently after a few years. There is a lot of value in having people set roots in a community long-term.
- tptacek 6y agoThat's kind of my thought? At the point where you're, like, both stably employed and committing to raise a family here, I no longer care at all about your immigration status. I feel like I must be missing something.