4 ms·
>> A cross functional team then reviewed the paper as part of our regular process and the authors were informed that it didn’t meet our bar for publication and
by YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago
>> A cross functional team then reviewed the paper as part of our regular process and the authors were informed that it didn’t meet our bar for publication and were given feedback about why. It ignored too much relevant research — for example, it talked about the environmental impact of large models, but disregarded subsequent research showing much greater efficiencies. Similarly, it raised concerns about bias in language models, but didn’t take into account recent research to mitigate these issues.
Plain English translation: she didn't present the results of her research in a light that favours the company's goals.
Once in a while someone posts an article on HN about academia and how doing a PhD is badly paid with few opportunities for stable employment. Then the comments will wonder why people still bother with academia.
Well, this is why. Because, as a rule, if you are a researcher in academia you won't be asked to retract your research because it makes someone look bad.
- ggreer 6y ago> Well, this is why. Because, as a rule, if you are a researcher in academia you won't be asked to retract your research because it makes someone look bad. If your results go against current dogma, or if they reveal an uncomfortable truth, your paper will be rejected for spurious reasons every time you submit it. A recent example from Glenn Geher[1]: > I have published more than 100 academic pieces in my career to date. I've pretty much been through it all. > From this context, I will say that the most difficult paper that my team (the New Paltz Evolutionary Psychology Lab) and I have ever tried to publish was a paper on the topic of political motivations that underlie academic values of academics. That's the pushback you get for researching political motivations in academia. It's much worse if your ideas directly connect to social policies. If your ideas are particularly heretical (or you engage in good faith with heretics), you'll have your life threatened by violent mobs. This has happened to Allison Stanger, Bret Weinstein, Jordan Peterson, and many others. 1. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/darwins-subterranean-world/202011/politics-in-academia-case-study https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/darwins-subterranean...
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoFrom the article you cited: >> Each rejection came with a new set of reasons. After some point, it started to seem to us that maybe academics just found this topic and our results too threatening. Maybe this paper simply was not politically correct. It looks like the only reason to believe the reasons for rejecting the paper were political is that it was rejected by many venues. Note that having different reviewers give different feedback is par for the course. Personally, I don't think this is serious. Having one's paper rejected, stings, but it happens to everyone and all the time. There's no reason to see hidden motives behind it. The paper not being very good is sufficient explanation. Not that it doesn't happen for papers to be rejected because they threaten a reviewer's work. But to claim that the entire academic establishment is threatened by a paper and that's why it was rejected? Sounds a bit far-fetched.
- dig1 6y ago> if you are a researcher in academia you won't be asked to retract your research because it makes someone look bad. Not entirely accurate (worked in academia). If your research makes someone look bad or have a chance to jeopardize financing, usually you won't get a chance even to send the paper, because it will be shut down in your research center by either your mentor or other peers. Sound mentors are well connected with publishers, and even if you somehow send it under the radar (which will be the end of your research career), someone will call either your mentor or management for confirmation. > she didn't present the results of her research in a light that favours the company's goals. The same is happening in academia, but let's not open Pandora's box :)
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoThis is not my experience. As a PhD student I've already had a (strong) disagreement with my thesis advisor about whether to submit a paper or not. My advisor thought I shouldn't, I thought I should. In the end, I submitted it and it got rejected and that's where the whole affair stopped. Actually, I really can't think of how my advisor would tell me not to publish a paper, except to suggest that it's not ready for publication. But perhaps, as is often the case in these conversations, we're talking about different "academia"'s? I think there are differences between fields and between different countries' institutions in the same field etc.
- njanirudh 6y agoIn your case there is no/less PR after effects
- visarga 6y agoI bet your papers have math and you know, neural nets in them. This paper was just prose, mostly non original claims, it basically says - this thing is dangerous, that thing has negative effects, offering no solution, just drawing attention to issues, let's say an issue inventory. Then it follows that it's more of an ethics paper than ML, and should be judged by the standards of ethics papers.
- beervirus 6y ago> Because, as a rule, if you are a researcher in academia you won't be asked to retract your research because it makes someone look bad. It would be great if this were true. But it isn't. https://medium.com/@leej12255/the-threat-to-academic-freedom-from-academics-4685b1705794 https://medium.com/@leej12255/the-threat-to-academic-freedom...
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoThe article you publish is attempting to assign various incidents of forced retraction to political prejudice, but I don't see how any of those cases "makes someone look bad", as per my comment. Mostly, I see in the article an attempt to engage in the usual online culture war, but I can't say what is reported in the article is making me concerned about academic freedom. To be honest.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> as a rule, if you are a researcher in academia you won't be asked to retract your research because it makes someone look bad. I have experienced exactly that, in academia.