5 ms·
I'm interested in how this impacts the actual movies. I expect them to get much longer. I also expect this will free directors to cover topics and material th
by sandworm101 6y ago
I'm interested in how this impacts the actual movies. I expect them to get much longer. I also expect this will free directors to cover topics and material that might not be appropriate for theatres. What people are willing to watch when in public is different than what people may be willing to watch in their own homes. I expect that Disney will have to run parallel focus groups, possible resulting in slightly different versioning between the streaming and in-theatre content.
Dune is a good example. Dune has for decades been viewed as the quintessential impossible story to ever put on screen. It was done best as a miniseries, and even then it wasn't complete. But an open-ended streaming option not subject to theatre/TV time or content constraints? There is potential for very interesting content.
- gwbas1c 6y agoI prefer miniseries. Netflix had the extended version of "The Hateful Eight" broken into a four episode miniseries. I loved it! Now that I can only watch adult movies after the kids go to bed, I had to watch the original "The Hateful Eight" over two nights. The miniseries was much easier to watch, and didn't require compromises for running length. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/apr/27/quentin-tarantino-hateful-eight-netflix-miniseries https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/apr/27/quentin-taranti...
- WalterBright 6y ago> Now that I can only watch adult movies after the kids go to bed Just invite them in telling them that it's educational, and they will run away and not go near your TV room.
- scott_s 6y agoWhat you're talking about is already happening, but we still call them "tv shows." A great recent example is The Queen's Gambit. It's adapted from a novel, which "normally" would become a movie. But instead it became a 7 episode miniseries, which allowed for much more character development than a 2-hour movie. Game of Thrones is the obvious example of something that also could have instead been several movies. I think what we're discovering is that movies, as a medium, are for narratives that can be told in under 3 hours. If your narrative requires longer, or you just want to be able to have more time to develop characters or worlds, it's better to create a show.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI loathe the new format where there’s an extra hour or two of fluff to pad Netflix’s statistics about how much content they have. Although I guess it existed with old style TV too to enable them to sell more ad time. There’s character development, and then gratuitous time wastage. At least we can skip past it nowadays, or just opt out of watching it. Pendulums swing from one extreme to the other, as always.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago"fluff" padding is much worse than "can we get an extra season or three out of this show", IMO. [ EDIT: d'oh, I meant to write this in reverse, as "fluff padding is much less bad than .... oh well. ] I prefer stories to be told that already have a beginning, middle and end at their outset, not just some fingers-crossed "we might get 5 seasons, we can decide how it unfolds once we get to season 3" stuff that has dominated way too much TV. Granted, the purely episodic shows (e.g. Star Trek, LA Law and the like) are immune to this, mostly. But give me more True Detective, where the story ending is known before they even start filming, and the only question is "do we get to try another story?"
- lotsofpulp 6y agoDefinitely, I like to know the writers have the whole story mapped out prior to even starting the show before investing time into it. I got burned once by Lost when I was much younger, and hope to not make that mistake again.
- toyg 6y agoLost was a microcosm of everything that is wrong with the traditional network-tv system. And it’s a shame, because some of the storytelling was remarkable.
- wombatpm 6y agoLost I can forgive. Magic Island answers a lot of questions. Battlestar Galactica on the other hand? Cylons had a plan my ass.
- danso 6y agoI don't know if Dune would be the best example. Have the producers said that they plan on using the year delay to continue making real changes to the movie? My impression was that Dune was essentially ready to go this year, and doing a re-edit to take advantage of TV's lack of time constraint isn't necessarily ideal or feasible. I agree that Dune as a book has enough content for a TV miniseries. But if they barely finished shooting before covid shut things down, it's not as if they can in early 2021 attempt expand the scope of the story they hoped to tell. I would argue the "Snyder cut" of Justice League might be a better example, but that's also an extremely weird and bespoke situation. That is actually being released as a 4-episode mini-series. Even though HBO has budgeted $70M for additional shooting and production, presumably most of the cut will use what Snyder shot back in 2017. I'm unclear how much he shot back then was then cut when Joss Whedon took over. Snyder being who he is probably had wanted to do a 3+ hour movie for the original release, and may have actually shot most of those scenes.