7 ms·
> Why does it need to be in a container that degrades in 300+ years? Because there's no other cost-effective material we've invented that keeps the prosciutto
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Why does it need to be in a container that degrades in 300+ years?
Because there's no other cost-effective material we've invented that keeps the prosciutto airtight (so it doesn't dry out in hours), won't puncture/rip easily, holds up to shipping+stacking, and is transparent (to examine for fat percentage, slice thickness, etc. -- always essential for meats and veggies).
Can you provide a material that does all that but starts degrading after 60 days? If you can, you stand to make a lot of $$$.
Obviously, the main alternative is having someone slice it at the deli counter for you, but that means you could only ever buy prosciutto at places with a staffed deli counter, including the 15-minute wait for the deli counter if you're going grocery shopping at the end of a regular workday...
- hairytrog 6y agoThe ham itself will protect it, wrapped in Aluminum foil or even a hemp bag for shipping. The packaging is simply an artifact of people not wanting to buy a whole ham and wanting it presliced, which is perhaps an artifact of the fact that most people in the US will heat the majority of their meals by themselves and do not like to prepare meals. Sad.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 6y agoMaybe you don't know what prosciutto is...? It's not just ham. Buying an entire prosciutto costs hundreds of dollars, obviously people don't want to buy a whole one. It's also usually not heated, by the way. This has zero to do with not liking to prepare meals... most people who buy sliced prosciutto are doing it as part of the meal they're preparing. We're not talking about hot pockets or frozen lasagna here.
- aaronblohowiak 6y agoMaybe they know what prosciutto is but don’t know that in USA we use that term to only refer to prosciutto crudo?
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoEven when I ate meat, I wouldn't buy a whole ham. What the heck am I going to do with a whole ham?? I literally do not have the freezer space for this. I've never had children, and have only been in a house with one other human. That's a lot of food waste. Heck, I sometimes lament that I can't buy smaller amounts of spinach because I hate seeing half the bag go to waste.And I'll add that this has nothing to do with cooking or not cooking: I like to cook, and do so most days. That packaging keeps food waste down because it breaks things into smaller portions - not to mention that many food places seal them in ways to make them last longer (example being adding a mix of gasses to help it not oxidize).
- powersnail 6y agoIt's not sad; it's practical. A whole ham is giant, expensive, hard to store, and might take months to get through, unless you eat it every meal. I prepare my own meal, and I don't need meat to be pre-sliced, but I do need it to be in a small enough portion that can be put into my fridge.
- peanut_worm 6y agoIsn’t Cellophane biodegradable?
- minikites 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellophane#Material_properties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellophane#Material_properties >Cellophane is biodegradable, but highly toxic carbon disulfide is used in most cellophane production.
- peanut_worm 6y agoOh well, I tried.
- minikites 6y ago>Can you provide a material that does all that but starts degrading after 60 days? What's the motivation (market pressure) to develop such a thing? Plastic is cheap, so without other external pressure, there's no reason for any company to fund the development of something new. This is why pollution and other society-scale problems need a society-scale solution (government regulation).
- ornornor 6y ago> What's the motivation (market pressure) to develop such a thing? That’s a good point actually. Up until now it was “impossible” to make a vaccine in less than 7-10 years. The epidemic happened and we were able to make one in less than a year. But there was a fuckton of money to be made in it so we found a way.
- mikem170 6y agoDoes it need to be a big deal to wait a few minutes at the deli counter? In our rush to maximize everything for efficiency we are causing numerous small problems that are adding up, a tragedy of the commons and loss of our humanity. Our culture seems to value efficiency above too much else.
- minikites 6y ago>Our culture seems to value efficiency above too much else. Capitalism tells us that if we're not making money, we're worthless as humans. It's not about hard work or efficiency, just look at the lack of respect for work that doesn't make money (e.g. stay-at-home parents).
- mikem170 6y ago> Capitalism tells us that if we're not making money, we're worthless as humans. I agree that pure capitalism thinks that way, and some cultures are closer to that than others.
- Chris2048 6y agoNo it doesn't it says that the value of living in a capitalist society should be reciprocated with value, i.e. individuals providing value to society, as societal value is nothing more than the aggregation of individual contributions. I'm not saying this is entirely good/correct, but I am saying you misstate the message. > just look at the lack of respect for work that doesn't make money This conflates individual value with societal/communal. But why should anyone give a dam about stuff that doesn't benefit them? To be clear, I'm not saying people shouldn't give a damn, I saying why couldn't they i.e. why should they be forced if they choose not to. There's also a nuance to value: Capitalism determines value on the basis on what money people are willing to spend. Firstly, if people go out of there way to ensure money is not involved with something, don't be surprised if it's value is miscalculated by a capitalist system: this is like not winning a competition you never entered. That said, the economic impact of packaging is undervalued because no one is attaching an accurate debt/penalty to it, which is arguably the real problem here. Secondly, there is a notion that things of value create "market demand", so if little money is offered for something, then market doesn't want it, and people supplying it are refusing to offer what society actually wants. I think this makes sense: people have children even though parental benefits might be low suggesting they aren't really doing it for society, though I've discussed this before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24423077 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24423077 TLDR: Capitalism only deals with societal value; so it only determines your value (of actions, say) on the basis of value to society. People are free to value things outside that system; If you think "people don't care about X" because "people don't provide money for X" then it is you declaring the value of something to be its dollar amount.
- SN76477 6y agoMakes me wonder what our diets would look like if plastic was never invented.
- i_haz_rabies 6y agoprobably healthier
- michaelbrave 6y agoThere are bio-plastics(usually made from corn) that degrade fairly fast, the problem is they cost less than a percent of a cent more. This is really a thing where government subsidies that are forward thinking about the environment could help.
- ksdale 6y agoAre bio-plastics really a big improvement though? Growing corn burns a lot of fossil fuels. I think there's a case to be made that plastic that ends up in a landfill after few carbon emissions is better for the environment than plastic that degrades after lots of carbon emissions. Not saying that's definitely the case, just that I'm not sure it's so clear.
- Loughla 6y agoThe assumption there is that plastic emits less carbon when it's being created than corn. Is that accurate?
- X6S1x6Okd1st 6y agoThere is also a land cost. I'd be surprised if we determined that plastic is better than bio-plastic, but until we are making bio-plastic with a low land footprint land will continue to be a factor here.
- Loughla 6y agoThis might be a really stupid question, but how does land factor into carbon emission?
- frettchen 6y agoI think the issue isn't emissions in that case but a "amount of land space necessary for landfills for traditional plastic" vs. "amount of land space necessary for plant growth for bioplastic." If the bioplastic growth land takes up more space by a certain amount than is used to dispose of regular plastic, that's presents its own set of issues.
- walleeee 6y ago> Obviously, the main alternative is having someone slice it at the deli counter for you, but that means you could only ever buy prosciutto at places with a staffed deli counter, including the 15-minute wait for the deli counter if you're going grocery shopping at the end of a regular workday... This and a million other small inconveniences hardly seem too great a price to pay to avoid filling the planet's air and water (and by consequence our bodies) with plastic waste
- whiddershins 6y agoI think this is overblown. The earth is already ‘full’ of oil and gas and minerals and lots of toxic things. We are just transforming one type of substance into another - more useful to us - type of substance. The issue is when the waste gets in to places where it wreaks havoc, like especially waterways. Currently, afaik, this problem is primarily driven by a few countries in Asia, so I think the effort that would have the most impact is figuring out how to convince those particular Asian countries to stop throwing plastic in to rivers. And anyone else who gets it in their head to throw plastic in to rivers. As long as waste is contained properly it doesn’t seem to make so much of a net change in the earth.
- walleeee 6y ago> Currently, afaik, this problem is primarily driven by Asia, so I think the effort that would have the most impact is figuring out how to convince Asian countries to stop throwing plastic in to rivers. The west could start by not exporting a huge portion of its plastic waste to said Asian countries. > I think this is overblown. The earth is already 'full' of... toxic things. The earth was certainly not "full" of macro-, micro-, and nano-plastics 50 years ago. Americans ingest and inhale tens to hundreds of thousands of microplastic particles per year[0]. Microplastics likely impair cognition in hermit crabs[1]. Nanoplastics accumulate in plants[2]. It's not just waterways. Nobody really understands how this might affect human health. We're all participants in a planet-sized experiment to find out. [0]: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2020.0030 https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2020.0030 [1]: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.9b01517 https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.9b01517 [2]: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41565-020-0707-4 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41565-020-0707-4
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hinkley 6y agoIf we solve the problem by proliferating plastic eating bacteria and fungi, then all of these qualities will be lost.
- ev0lv 6y agoCouldn't we just augment the existing plastic with seeds/fungi is some way? That way, after some time in the trash, the fungi actually develops a colony which eats the packaging?
- undersuit 6y agoIf the only reason we're choking our planet with plastic is so we don't have to wait at the deli counter might I suggest we just start placing orders to the deli counter a few hours before we arrive?
- lhorie 6y agoIMHO, material transparency is the only difficult to meet requirement. Paper works fine to wrap most cold cuts and it's already used extensively in packaging for fruits and vegetables. People are already willing to pay premium for organic and other hard to inspect/certify labels; it doesn't seem outside the realm of possibility that people would be ok buying paper-wrapped prosciutto that has some similar stamp of quality.
- quicklyfrozen 6y agoPersonally I find paper wrapped items from the local deli fine, but I'd be pretty skeptical of any food products shipped only in paper -- too easy to contaminate.
- crazygringo 6y agoPaper also works fine if you're ordering your prosciutto at the deli counter. But even waxed paper isn't going to prevent the prosciutto from drying out for more than a day or two. The whole point of the plastic that prosciutto is often sold in is to keep it good for months, since it's usually a low-volume item that may sit on the shelf for a couple weeks or more.
- gabuyabdabudabu 6y agoHonestly, it's called a glass jar. Folks should eat fresh local meats and produce and make their own preserves. Less reliance on mass-produced products and support local farmers/producers. Back before the garbagization-of-food you'd go to the butcher and get high quality meats. You'd go to the market to get produce. And, you'd make your own preserves for the winter WITHOUT PLASTIC. Simple, and in fact they taste much better if seasoned well!
- slothtrop 6y agoWhat will actually happen is they'll make the switch to biodegradable plastics. Too few will want to give up the convenience of ready-made packaged foods. It could also require more travel to reach small distributors who don't use plastic, which wastes CO2 and time. The alternative would be more feasible if we had better-designed, walkable cities. But in North America places are built staggered, public transpo sucks.
- gabuyabdabudabu 6y agoYeah, it's unfortunate really. All I can say is, as a collective people are really lazy and stupid. Even smart people are stupid because they think adding an _unnatural_ amount of mushrooms to the world will solve the problem. Like, hello people, adding _a bunch_ of something to the _bunch_ of something else is not a solution. By bunch I mean _trillions of tons_. People just value money more than anything and it will be our undoing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- foobiekr 6y agoTraditionally, that would be cellophane.